4 ms·
> Empire collapse (has happened with every single empire in history - what makes the U.S. exempt?) The US isn't anything like traditional historical empires fo
by adventured 10y ago
> Empire collapse (has happened with every single empire in history - what makes the U.S. exempt?)
The US isn't anything like traditional historical empires for one. It hasn't built its prosperity on invading other nations to annex them and plunder their national wealth, which is traditionally how empires temporarily sustain themselves. The US built its immense wealth today (just under half of all private wealth on earth is owned by Americans) overwhelmingly through invention, engineering, industry, trade, manufacturing, radical productivity gains spanning two centuries, and lots of immigration. Historical empires have always run out of lands to conquer and wealth to steal from other nations, and then they collapse as they fail to placate their own people or get defeated militarily by the lands they previously conquered.
The USD global reserve is a vulnerability? That's one potential issue. However, the US was the world's largest economy - by about 1890 - long before it had the global reserve currency. Japan has a disastrous situation on its hands economically, and a currency they're very aggressively abusing, and yet they're still the world's #3 economy with a substantial GDP per capita. The notion the US would just wilt without the global reserve currency, is absurd.
What lands has the US annexed that it's going to get pushed out of (and lose the plunder/tax from said nations)? What nation/s is the US stealing all of its prosperity from, such that that is going to end soon? Are we taking $5 trillion annually from Vietnam and Mexico (it's actually the other way around given the vast US trade deficit, we're sending hundreds of billions to the rest of the world)?
Further, the US was the first Capitalist nation. From day one it was heavily built on the principles of the free market and trade, not invasion and plunder. (and before anyone chimes in to loudly proclaim that the US has never been a perfect Capitalist nation: no kidding, such wasn't implied) Otherwise there would be no Canada, at some point in the last century we would have invaded for their natural resources. The US also would have pulled a Russia, and taken Japan and parts of Europe, using its rather wild military & resource advantage at the end of WW2.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoThe US has always been built on the plunder of its nonwhite inhabitants. One can wax poetic about the free market or educated work force but that is the truth. The roman republic didn't fall because of issues with resource extraction or plunder. It fell when a powerful enough demagogue named Ceasar took power and undermined it on a wave of populism. A Nero like dictator (trump) is all we really need to crash and burn into the annals of history.
- pwthornton 10y agoThe U.S. economy exploded after the end of slavery, precisely because a capitalistic economy where everyone participates generates a lot more money than a Southern slavery economy. The South was significantly poorer than the North, partly because it had a really backwards economy that didn't incentivize innovation or technology. Slavery made a lot of individuals quite wealthy without doing any real work, but it's a poor system to build a capitalistic economy on. A consumptive economy like ours needs as many people as possible to have money and to spend it. Slavery is one of the defining stories of the founding of America, but ending slavery and increasing equality has allowed the U.S. economy to go much further. Additional actions to further increase equality and get more diverse economic participation will only help the U.S. economy. The U.S. also has a reprehensible history with American Indians and did not properly compensate them for land. And the U.S. doesn't always have the best past with immigrants to this country. But, again, getting more people involved in our economy has only helped the U.S. It's one thing to say that the founding of America was built on the plunder of nonwhites; it's quite another to say that it's current wealth is based on that. Engaging more people in the economic system is precisely what allowed the U.S. economy to get so big.
- legodt 10y agoYou must be new to hackernews, not abiding by racism is a big no go by this community.
- iamnothere 10y agoThe factors you outlined are definitely a part of the equation, but I'd argue that the US role in geopolitics post-WWII has had a much larger role in its success. First, Bretton Woods established a system that heavily favored US interests -- it was based on dollars and gold, and the US had most of the gold supply. The US was able to achieve this favorable position thanks to its place as the major merchant-state, lender, and latecomer ally/victor in WWII. Among other effects, this system led to the dollar becoming accepted as the foundation for most international trade in the latter 20th century. After the dollar's position became less favorable in the late 1960s, the US ended the Bretton Woods system and worked out agreements with OPEC to shift oil trades into dollars. This had the effect of cementing the USD as the currency of global trade (among other benefits), as all countries needed to hold dollars in order to purchase oil. This "agreement" was backed up by US military and economic hegemony. Additionally, during this time, the global "south" was being pillaged for resources -- particularly oil, but also cropland (see bananas and sugar) and other scarce resources. The US established and propped up dictatorships that were favorable to its aims under the guise of fighting Communism. The USSR was doing the same thing in reverse, of course -- a grand game of chess, with the spoils to the victor. Finally, the US "won" against the USSR through a combination of clever psychology, propaganda, and economic warfare, as well as Soviet mismanagement. When the USSR collapsed, the US obtained some economic benefits from the disentangling of the Soviet system, prolonging its advantage. The US position was unsustainable, though, and this is when the shift occurred. With the relative increase in global stability and international "free" trade, as well as the power of the Internet, corporations no longer needed the protection of the US system quite so badly. Outsourcing and distributed operations became more and more common. The US position is not so rosy as it once was. The petrodollar system seems to be unwinding as well. I do live in the US, so I do hope that the inevitable correction is a slow one. I also hope that we can avoid starting new conflicts in an attempt to prolong or reestablish our advantage.
- linkregister 10y agoYou've taken some factoids from history and attached some simplistic "just so" explanations for events. The U.S. has egregious acts in its history but it's inaccurate to presume that its success is solely due to plundering the world economy. Do remember that European, African, Asian, Oceanic, and Latin American countries experienced a massive improvement in their economies post-war; how could that happen if they were haplessly at the mercy of a cruel victor's reserve currency? 1. Bretton Woods worked out to the disadvantage of the U.S. in the long term. Massive budget deficits brought on by Vietnam War borrowing and ballooning social programs, as well as trade deficits, led European countries to withdraw gold from the U.S. in order to preserve the value of their currency reserves. Leaving it was the only option to both stop the drain of gold and also to escape currency pegging so the dollar could be floated to reflect the trade deficits. 2. The reason why OPEC adopted the dollar was for maximum convertibility; at its inception, the dollar was the most circulated currency in the world. It was, at the time, the one backed by the most gold. The Euro did not exist and the Yen was not as strong or stable. 3. Resource pillaging surely occurred, but in that time period, massive improvements in domestic manufacturing, resource extraction, and agriculture accounts for the largest increase in U.S. citizens' wealth. Multinationals accounted for a small proportion of U.S. revenue. 4. The U.S. didn't "win" against the USSR despite what Mr. Reagan may told you on TV. The USSR failed economically due to a drop in oil prices due to its undiversified economy and the political impossibility of stopping social and military expenditures without upsetting Communist Party elites. The U.S. received paltry economic benefits from the Soviet unraveling. If anything, it received increased competition from suddenly available labor pools. Political advantage does not translate to economic advantage. 5. Outsourcing began long before the internet was significant. The cause of outsourcing was the improved political stability of countries with competing pools of labor and the improvement and commoditization of technology. It's convenient to adopt a zero-sum outlook on global trade, to assume that if a country does well it must be at the expense of others. However, study of history does not support this conclusion.
- kmicklas 10y ago> It hasn't built its prosperity on invading other nations to annex them and plunder their national wealth, which is traditionally how empires temporarily sustain themselves. That is exactly how it has built its wealth, what?
- rhino369 10y agoThe US didn't plunder their wealth. It extinguished / concentrated the previous civilizations and created a new civilization in it's place. Even if the US experienced severe economic, military, and social decline, Illinois isn't going to turn back into the Illiwek Confederation. Those people don't exist anymore. To put it more simply, America isn't a patchwork of nations and nationalities. Empire's are several nations aggregated into one political union. If America were in decline, we might lose parts of the southwest to Mexico (due mostly to heavy immigration, not because we stole the land from them), maybe Hawaii, and the colonial territories (Guam, Puerto Rico, etc.). In a total collapse (post apocalyptic), new nationalities would form, but that takes a long time.
- kmicklas 10y ago> The US didn't plunder their wealth. It extinguished / concentrated the previous civilizations and created a new civilization in it's place. It did plunder their underlying wealth in natural resources. That's not to mention what we've done in the Middle East, South America, Africa, Asia, and even Europe if you go back to the world wars. I get what you're saying about there not being enough of substrate national power to undermine the US on its own territory but I think externally anti-imperialism is gaining currency just about everywhere. And that will come back to bite us one way or another.