7 ms·
Trump easily won the popular vote for the 48 states that aren't California and New York. Popular vote indeed. There's a very good reason the electoral college e
by adventured 10y ago
Trump easily won the popular vote for the 48 states that aren't California and New York. Popular vote indeed. There's a very good reason the electoral college exists.
- kevinh 10y agoAnd if you take out a couple states, Clinton won the electoral college. What's your point? That we should ignore the votes of two of the largest states because they don't agree with you?
- EpicEng 10y agoIf we change to a popular vote system then the entire race looks different. It's a silly argument either way.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> That we should ignore the votes of two of the largest states because they don't agree with you? Ahh, yeah. That's the point. So America isn't CaliforNewYork. The electoral college isn't a scam, it exists to bring balance, so your hipster javascript developer gets the same weight as a coal miner in rural Ohio.
- baddox 10y agoSo then, America now is TexasOklahoma? If those two states went blue, Hillary would have won. This argument is extremely weak.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoThe same weight is one human, one vote. Period. Your system has only ensured that a few swing states like Ohio exercise a tyranny of the minority over the rest of us[1]. You keep implying that the rest of us aren't Americans and don't deserve an equal voice, and don't be surprised if we start trying to secede or revolt violently against the tyrants ruling over America's urban majority against our will. [1] -- http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/21/upshot/as-american-as-apple-pie-the-rural-votes-disproportionate-slice-of-power.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/21/upshot/as-american-as-appl...
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> The same weight is one human, one vote. Period. You are entitled to your opinion! That's not how the system is currently designed. > You keep implying that the rest of us aren't Americans and don't deserve an equal voice, and don't be surprised if we start trying to secede or revolt violently against the tyrants ruling over America's urban majority against our will. Good luck with that. You want to bleed out in the street, go for it. Plenty of other first world countries for me to move my family to.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Good luck with that. You want to bleed out in the street, go for it. Plenty of other first world countries for me to move my family to. Very few others with low taxes, no universal health-care, no universal pension, and a general fetish for empowering the rural bourgeoisie at everyone else's expense. Personally, I've got three countries on my short list to apply to, maybe four. But I'm still going to start taking self-defense lessons, because with a neo-fascist government, you people have gone too damn far. You are enabling the most violent, evil elements in society, and that warrants a response.
- pcardh0 10y agoHow are MS-13, Bloods, Crips and other various street gangs enabled by Trump's election? I am confused.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYou actually think street gangs are worse than neo-Nazis?
- kmicklas 10y agoHacker news is a racist cesspool, you shouldn't be surprised.
- 10y ago
- serge2k 10y ago> so your hipster javascript developer gets the same weight as a coal miner in rural Ohio Except it doesn't do that. It gives the farmer in Wyoming more power than either. And no, it wasn't designed to be this way. Not to this extent.
- kevinh 10y agoThe design of the electoral college was not to prevent influence by larger states. That's the function of the Senate. The electoral college exists in part to enable the 3/5ths compromise and in part to allow the vote of the people to be changed by someone who is theoretically more sophisticated.
- Frondo 10y agoWhy should the coal miner get more of a voice than the guy who lives in a city? They're both citizens, right? They both get to vote on their state, city, and county stuff. Why should the guy who lives in the middle of nowhere get to say "my vote's worth 50x what yours is, sucker!!"?
- toomuchtodo 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
- baddox 10y agoSo the alternative is tyranny of the minority? It doesn't reassure me that we give much more weight to a minority of voters just because they live in less densely populated areas. That's completely arbitrary.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoLots of decisions in life are arbitrary, or based on fuzzy moral standings.
- jellicle 10y agoThe U.S. should move to a political system where coastal city-dwelling individuals have 4x the voting power of people who live inland and in rural areas.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pawn 10y agoIt could be argued that 100 people living in 3 counties have a greater diversity of concerns and opinions than 100 people sharing an apartment complex.
- brewdad 10y agoCA would be the 7th largest economy in the world if it were its own country. NY would be 11th. But yes, let's just pretend like they don't matter when it comes to the US as a whole.
- RUG3Y 10y agoIf California were to become it's own country tomorrow, Californians would learn how much they also depend on other states.
- cableshaft 10y agoYou don't even have to go further than electricity and water supply to see how much they rely on other states. But I'm sure there's a lot of other areas where they're reliant on other states as well.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoOther than the Colorado River, does California depend on other states for water? If California seceded, wouldn't they retain their part of the Colorado River Compact? Power, I'll grant you. They've been "exporting pollution" by having power plants built in other states for a while now...
- xienze 10y ago> If California seceded, wouldn't they retain their part of the Colorado River Compact? Well I would imagine that deal would have to be revisited in light of a secession, no?
- cableshaft 10y agoThat's basically what my point was. Maybe they wouldn't have to, but I imagine they would.
- WalterBright 10y ago
- SEJeff 10y agoUmmmm and Illinois, you know the one with Chicago. Hillary won IL popular vote with 3,090,729 votes to Trump's 2,146,015.
- kesselvon 10y ago"If I discount 20% of the nation's population, he won the popular vote"
- serge2k 10y agoClinton won a plurality of the popular vote in the United States of America. That includes California and New York and every red state you can name. Seriously, what a stupid fucking argument. You should be ashamed.
- hillz 10y agoThat's like saying: let's ignore 58.55 million voters for no reason other than where they live. More than 18% of the entire US population. States are arbitrary dividers, it's silly to think there's some great reason for allowing people in some random groups (states) have much more voting power than others. What if the dividers were based on income, race, etc? Wouldn't even that be more reasonable?