10 ms·
Richard Feynman Put Himself on the FBI’s Do Not Call List
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- spathi_fwiffo 10y agoYou would think being part of the Manhattan Project would have put him under more intense scrutiny from the FBI, during the Red Scare. The FBI even mention him as an associate of Oppenheimer in the notes showing his 'do not bother' request.
- okreallywtf 10y agoThe first soviet atomic bomb was detonated in 1949[1] so this was nearly 10 years after that fact. His association to Klaus Fuchs[2] was probably more suspect than Oppenheimer (despite how suspicious they were of him) given he was allegedly an actual spy (I say allegedly because I know how suspicious of the FBI people are around here, and not without reason in some cases). According to the Feynman Bio I'm reading right now [3], Fuchs was said to have joked (when Feynman wasn't around) that he would be the most likely person to be a spy because of how often he left the base alone to visit his sick wife (or so he said). [1] http://www.atomicheritage.org/history/soviet-atomic-program-1946 http://www.atomicheritage.org/history/soviet-atomic-program-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klaus_Fuchs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klaus_Fuchs [3] https://www.amazon.com/Genius-Life-Science-Richard-Feynman/dp/0679747044 https://www.amazon.com/Genius-Life-Science-Richard-Feynman/d...
- simplicio 10y ago"I say allegedly because I know how suspicious of the FBI people are around here" Fuch's was caught by MI5, not the FBI. And he gave a detailed confession even before he was arrested. So there isn't really any reason to be suspicious of his conviction.
- Bartweiss 10y agoFeynman himself casually notes Fuchs as "the fellow who turned out the be the spy", and despite their friendship never offered an skepticism about the conviction.
- pvg 10y agoFuchs confessed before he was prosecuted.
- pkaeding 10y agoI'm not familiar with this particular case, but innocent people confess more frequently than you might think. Investigators put tremendous pressure on suspects during interrogation, and they can often feed details of the case to the suspect, resulting in a 'detailed confession'. Many times, the investigator is not intentionally trying to get a false confession.
- pvg 10y agoThat's not the case here and you can simply google the guy, his case is famous. He confessed voluntarily, likely because he was tipped off and knew he was already exposed. After serving his time he continued his life in East Germany. There is no doubt whatsoever he was a spy and he never disputed it when no longer under duress.
- okreallywtf 10y agoGood catch, I almost looked it up but I got lazy. I don't know if the Feynman bio I'm reading specified exactly who caught him but it didn't seem like there was ever any particular question whether or not he had done it but I can't either say that I know he was, I've just read it and not looked into the details myself.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoIt doesn't matter if Fuchs is an actual spy for the purposes of figuring out if the FBI should be worried - all that matters is that the FBI believes that he's a spy.
- darpa_escapee 10y agoI assume he was being bothered often for this reason.
- mvidal01 10y agoI wonder who else is on this list?
- sbierwagen 10y agoan unnamed colleague citing his hobby of cracking safes at Los Alamos as evidence he was a “master of deception and enemy of America.” There is speculation that it was his ex-wife, Louise Bell: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2014/07/11/smeared-richard-feynman/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2014/07/11/smeared-richard-fe...
- saycheese 10y agoFeynman's willingness to think more objectively than most about the world and share his thoughts likely resulted in a long list of enemies, people that desired to control him, etc. Most obvious person to report it was the head of security at Los Alamos; Feynman told them about his exploits and actively tested the security.
- a3n 10y ago"Never pen test without permission."
- CalChris 10y agoBeen there. Done that. Suffered the consequences.
- sasas 10y agoDon't leave us hanging! What happened ?
- trendia 10y ago... unless you have a Nobel and a diagram named after you.
- sfifs 10y agoI believe those came well after his Los Alamos days. When he was cracking safes, he was essentially going out on a limb. The leaders of the establishment knew of his oddities and usefulness, so he was tolerated.
- saycheese 10y agoLittle known fact, but all you have to do is ask not to be contacted, watched, etc. - and the FBI will respect your request and note it in your file. (Okay, ending sarcasm.) Find it hard to believe they stopped, reads more like a note saying to stop keeping "official" records.
- colechristensen 10y agoSeems more like Feynman got the attention of upper management to some overzealous low-level agents.
- saycheese 10y agoBack then, the FBI had a nasty habit of keeping files at field offices in such an insecure ways that it would have been very easy for some with Feynman's skills to get access to if they wanted; clearly there would have been a risk of getting caught, but likely small for someone like Feynman.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> been very easy for some with Feynman's skills to get access to if they wanted I thought Feynman was a physicist. What skills are you speaking of? Was he a spy in a former life or something?
- theandrewbailey 10y agoHe had safe-cracking skills, apparently. Also, he was a well respected person that could have pulled off social engineering.
- lb1lf 10y agoIn (I think, it has been a while since I read it) "Surely you're joking, Mr. Feynman ", a collection of anecdotes from his life, he states he - to prove how inadequate (not to say pointless) security measures at Los Alamos were, he made a habit of opening safes he shouldn't have access to only to leave cryptic notes or objects in it for the safe owner to find and puzzle over.
- RangerScience 10y agoFun Feynman fact: He was friends with an artist who, among other things, built a home in the hills of Altadena (an LA suburb) using discarded construction materials from the area, and that was predominantly not enclosed, as he had claustrophobia from being smuggled out of Armenia during the genocide - I think in a coffin? Wikipedia has some of the information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jirayr_Zorthian#Friendship_with_Richard_Feynman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jirayr_Zorthian#Friendship_wit... , but if you go to the ranch the people there will tell you more.
- thfuran 10y agoThat sounds more like a Zorthian fact than a Feynman fact.
- RangerScience 10y agoEh. The people in your life are pretty significant, and I doubt most people here have heard of Zorthian. For example, it's both a Tesla and Twain fun fact that they were buds, but I don't have to explain who either of those people are. Edit: Still, fair critique.
- adamgamble 10y agoI read the title as Richard Stallman and I was super confused.
- skykooler 10y agoSo did I - although it does sound like something Stallman would try to do.
- keithpeter 10y agoI think that Stallman is so completely transparent and articulate about his views and so totally outer field that I think he is unlikely ever to be close to an investigation into (say) documents being leaked or anything.
- hulahoof 10y agoOr Stallman has devised the perfect cover, only time shall tell
- ruminasean 10y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one. I was so sure I sat there wondering why I had never heard he worked on the bomb or how he was that old.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI don't understand how this list works - you can just go and ask FBI not to be interested in you, and they whitelist you from their investigations?
- atmosx 10y agoDoesn't make sense, if it was simple as that I think virtually everybody would do that, because 9 out of 10 when the feds (or any other police body) is interested in you, it's not a good thing (for you, might good for the society)...
- TeMPOraL 10y agoExactly; that's why I don't understand what's up with this list.
- NegativeK 10y agoBecoming a well connected, famous physicist who worked on the atomic bomb appears to be a prereq. According to the article.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- simplicio 10y agoIt's not an exemption from investigation, just not having FBI agents try and interview him without a go-ahead from the higher ups. Since they can't force him to respond to an interview request anyways, and he's said he won't do them, it's seems like basically just a time-saver. From the file and the Nuclear Security blog post above, it looks like Feynman was considered for a position on a gov't science advisory panel in 1958, the background investigation became concerned because of his safe-cracking hobby, his one-time friendship with (Soviet spy) Klaus Fuchs and a poor character reference from an angry ex-wife. After several interviews, Feynman said he wasn't interested in being interviewed any further. As he never served on the panel, he presumably withdrew himself from consideration or the gov't decided he was a security risk. As a result, there presumably wasn't any reason to investigate him further in any case.
- lucb1e 10y agoSome jokes are being made in the thread how you can extricate yourself from surveillance by the FBI by asking not to be watched, but seriously, what is this list? The article mentions that he "has stated he does not desire to be interviewed at any time by FBI Agents relative to matters of any kind". Why would the FBI reach out to him in the first place? I don't know about mr. Feynman but I don't regularly get contacted by the Dutch FBI (which is what anyway, the KLPD? I don't even know) for interviews, unless I did something wrong or when they think I know something to help further an investigation. I can hardly imagine anyone (let alone mr. Feynman) witnessing crimes (especially ones that warrant FBI investigation rather than a local police office's) that it was becoming a real burden for him to keep giving interviews.
- astronautjones 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism
- halspero 10y agoCheck out the FBI file: https://www.muckrock.com/foi/united-states-of-america-10/fbi-files-on-richard-feynman-1165/#file-4617 https://www.muckrock.com/foi/united-states-of-america-10/fbi... The sheer amount of black ink, rubric, marginalia, stampage, redaction, etc, is a reminder of how deeply dysfunctional (and even hellish) bureaucracies can be. It may not have been possible for the FBI to stop investigating Feynman without orders from the top.
- EekSnakePond 10y agoI find that nostalgic personalities such as Feynman imply that the authorities of the past were not only evil, but conquered, and therefore, sublimated into the dominant mythos of progress. In the post-9/11 world, this mythos is central to the authority of authority: "See? We no longer run overt, clumsy, and brutal humint! We learned our lesson, thanks hippies!" Everyone nods in agreement and dismisses the people saying, "Covert sigint just got cheaper, that's all."
- okreallywtf 10y agoI don't dispute that they have done harm, but I think everyone is getting a little ahead of themselves. We have no idea what it is like (yet) to live in a true police state but judging by the average perception on HN right now about the FBI, CIA, NSA we're getting shaken down in the street daily and spied on in our homes. The truth is much more nuanced and these are massive bureaucracies and if you average the effects of everyone in them and all that they do I honestly don't know whether its a net positive or negative. The problem is if they do something right, we'll likely never know and we can never really know what our lives would be like if they didn't exist. We should fight injustices and be vigilant but I think people understate the good and overstate the bad. If I could wave a wand to do away with them here and now I wouldn't know what to do, but I know I wouldn't do it without question.
- pimlottc 10y agoSlightly off-topic, but the magnifying-hover feature on the scanned images is pretty useful and done wel without being overly intrusive to the design.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoOn a related note, there seems to be a nearly infinite demand for stories related to Feynman in HN in particular[1] and internet in general. No wonder, his colleagues like Schwinger and Gell-Mann were pissed off as they didn't receive anywhere close to that kind of attention[2][3]. [1] https://hn.algolia.com/?query=feynman&sort=byPopularity&prefix=false&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=feynman&sort=byPopularity&pref... [2] https://hn.algolia.com/?query=gell-mann&sort=byPopularity&prefix=false&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=gell-mann&sort=byPopularity&pr... [3] https://hn.algolia.com/?query=schwinger&sort=byPopularity&prefix=false&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=schwinger&sort=byPopularity&pr...
- akira2501 10y agoPerhaps this isn't the place for this, but I've always loved this comic: http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2103 http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2103
- hug 10y agoFeynmann is not a popular figure just because of his contributions to physics. I'd say his popularity stems from how engaging a person he is: It's hard to watch Feynmann talk about something he's interested in (and he's interested in everything!), and to see that twinkle in his eye, and not be gripped by whatever the subject is. There's something special about his childlike wonder at the way things work. All of that, and he's absolutely astoundingly intelligent, articulate, and friendly. This video where he's asked how magnets "work" [youtu.be/ewcJR2nqDV4 - 7:30 long, from The Fantastic Mr. Feynmann] is amazing. He takes seven minutes to respond to a question. He doesn't even answer the question properly, and yet it's the perfect response. Even the most science-averse of my friends are able to enjoy watching that video. And that's just the science bit! He's also done crazy and interesting things: Cracking safes in Los Alamos that had research documents on the atomic bomb and leaving taunting notes. He used to work off napkins in topless bars. He was just an all-round interesting guy. I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that neither Schwinger nor Gell-Mann have these same qualities.
- 10y ago