6 ms·
Zero chance Paris pulls a large percentage of these bankers. They do have a lot of bad labor laws and quite high taxes, both of which have contributed to France
by adventured 10y ago
Zero chance Paris pulls a large percentage of these bankers. They do have a lot of bad labor laws and quite high taxes, both of which have contributed to France having a very stagnant economy (both in terms of innovation and growth) for decades. In real terms their economy hasn't expanded in nearly 25 years. The centers of power in Europe are still by far in Germany and the UK. French voters have noticed the problem, which is why their Socialist leader recently had a 4% approval rating and the far-right is making big gains. The same disastrous policies that have left them with a broken economy, will keep the London bankers away. There are half a dozen other major cities that will get a look before Paris.
Not to mention, France is increasingly an outlier in Europe with a punishing corporate income tax rate (33%). Most of their European competitors have been slashing that rate the past decade plus: Netherlands 25%, Spain 25%, Austria 25%, Sweden 22%, Denmark 22%, Portugal 21%, Finland 20%, UK 20%, Iceland 20%, Czech 19%, Poland 19%, Switzerland 17.9%, Ireland 12.5%. The average across Europe is about 20%. Why would an international bank want to be there, except for local French business purposes?
- camus2 10y agoThis. Nitpick : it is not a left vs right problem, Sarkozy did next to nothing to make France a better country for entrepreneurship and Fillion who is said to be the next french president was prime minister at that time. France isn't a country for young innovative businesses, it's a country where basically a dozen of big corporations control the entire economy and the rest are just sub-contractors. Neither the left nor the right want to change that. French people will continue voting for high unemployment and stagnation.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoFrom the sound of things, what France really needs is to break up its largest companies and implement much stronger competition laws.
- acchow 10y ago> They do have a lot of bad labor laws and quite high taxes, both of which have contributed to France having a very stagnant economy Can you elaborate on the bad labor laws?
- throwaway1892 10y agoI think he meant the labor laws are protecting more the employee than the employer, notably on the firing part. So, as far as some theories go, if it is hard to fire employees, employers will be more reluctant to hire, reducing worker mobility. But I only have a small experience of the consequence of our current labor laws (which are very hard to change, the current gov tried last year and got massive protests for their trouble). Edit: Also the employment taxes (the one paid by employers) are very high in France (half of the salary +/-).
- vidarh 10y agoFrance has a large percentage of EU bankers already. Only Frankfurt and London are at a similar level as Paris in the EU for banking today, and if London ceases to be a viable alternative (due to passporting etc. post brexit), then Paris will end up taking a lot of that business for the simple reason labour laws and taxes are not the only things the banks need to care about, but also where their employees are willing to live and work. My ex works in HR at executive level at a major investment bank. French labour laws etc. never comes up when they consider where to staff up/down (and they do continuously). As for corporate taxes, no investment bank has a problem finding schemes to shift profits around. > They do have a lot of bad labor laws and quite high taxes, both of which have contributed to France having a very stagnant economy (both in terms of innovation and growth) for decades. Their GDP per capita is largely moving in lockstep with the UK and Germany, despite far fewer hours worked per year for the average French worker. As it turns out there's very little evidence that these "bad labour laws and quit high taxes" have much impact on growth. > Not to mention, France is increasingly an outlier in Europe with a punishing corporate income tax rate (33%). In line with Germany. > The average across Europe is about 20%. Why would an international bank want to be there, except for local French business purposes? They are already there for purposes other than "local French business purposes". Many international banks have similar numbers of staff in Paris as in London.
- gaius 10y agoFrance has a large percentage of EU bankers already. Hilarious. Did you know that London is the 7th largest French city? Those people are not here for the weather. And Frexit is not off the cards either.
- vidarh 10y agoFactual. The bank my ex works at has as many traders in Paris as in London, for example, and that's fairly common. I don't doubt there are many French traders in London - these banks shifts staff and roles around as if they're commodities. But that doesn't change the fact that Paris has a large proportion of the EU financial industry. Not as large as London, but substantial enough for Paris to be a major financial centre.
- mamadrood 10y agoThis is simply not true. If you look at the report of the Cour des Comptes regarding the tax rates of the financial sector [1] you will see that France take less taxes on bank than pretty much all OECD countries, the only exceptions being Portugal, Spain, Finland and Austria. There are a lot of methods for banks or big company to lower taxes in France and it works well with both bank and France's interests. [1] http://www.ccomptes.fr/Publications/Publications/Les-prelevements-obligatoires-et-les-entreprises-du-secteur-financier http://www.ccomptes.fr/Publications/Publications/Les-preleve... (in French)