10 ms·
Anecdote, I was at Google in 2006 and there was (is?) a database of ideas that people shared that Google might pursue. As their motto was organize the world's i
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Anecdote, I was at Google in 2006 and there was (is?) a database of ideas that people shared that Google might pursue. As their motto was organize the world's information and make it easily accessible.
I had gotten a ticket for obstructing the intersection (the "anti-congestion" law in California that sought to limit gridlock by making it illegal to enter an intersection that you couldn't exit before the other light changed). I was fighting it and wanted to find other cases that had been decided on this law[1]. The only way to do that was to go to the public library and look through their published volumes of decisions and cases. So I thought here is a really useful thing Google could do, it isn't even a hard problem, collect the decisions that the courts publish anyway, and just connect the ones that are about the same part of the code. Match a number, match a date. And very useful to people who are fighting cases. It saved me some time and money [2]. But the idea never made it past the discussion stage because, as I was counseled, doing that would take on "powerful interests" who would really fight back hard and Google didn't want to draw that level of scrutiny. It wasn't until Carl Malamude started attacking this problem in earnest[3] that it became clear to me what it means to take away a revenue stream from lawyers.
[1] And learned this is called 'Sheparding' based on finding citations -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shepard's_Citations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shepard's_Citations
[2] turns out there had been no case law on this particular law and lots of dismissals so I just entered a plea of not guilty at the clerk, and the court informed me a week before my trial date that the prosecution had declined to prosecute.
[3] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150726/23080731763/even-if-state-georgia-can-copyright-legal-annotations-should-it.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150726/23080731763/even-...
- marcoperaza 10y ago>I had gotten a ticket for obstructing the intersection (the "anti-congestion" law in California that sought to limit gridlock by making it illegal to enter an intersection that you couldn't exit before the other light changed). You monster. :)
- diogenescynic 10y agoTo be fair, there is a lot of traffic created from this problem--especially in the Financial District in San Francisco. Whereas NYC has those "don't block the box" signs and it seems like their drivers are much more aware of it.
- marcoperaza 10y agoOh, I agree. I was gently chiding OP. I think blocking the intersection like that is one of those things that everyone hates, but has also committed at one point or another. Though from his explanation of the situation in another subthread, it sounds like he was in the right after all.
- braveo 10y agoNo one is going to explain how they're wrong, if he was ticketed the officer involved had a perspective that included him not being in the right.
- cletus 10y agoI don't know what NYC you're referring to but the one I live in has huge problems with asshats blocking intersections and I've never once seen the NYPD pick up anyone for it (or any other traffic violation). Of course why anyone drives in Manhattan is beyond me.
- jrockway 10y agoIf there's one thing New Yorkers like doing, it's blocking the box. I haven't seen the grid get locked though.
- greenleafjacob 10y agoSF does have these signs, for example on Battery crossing onto Market [1] (including most intersections onto Market). Unfortunately it doesn't look like the intersection I see block most often (California / Montgomery) has any, and I've been honked at plenty of times waiting for the intersection to clear, so education is probably pretty bad. [1] https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7914051,-122.3995502,3a,15y,200.15h,97.05t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sHtmGgcgyd1PHLtynuCEEvQ!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo3.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DHtmGgcgyd1PHLtynuCEEvQ%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D256.9824%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656!4m5!3m4!1s0x80859a6d00690021:0x4a501367f076adff!8m2!3d37.7749295!4d-122.4194155 https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7914...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 205guy 10y agoWhy were you fighting it?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe citing office was on the corner of the intersection and upon seeing him, a car on my left which had been heading for the carpool lane, opted instead to cut in front of me to stay in the legal lane. Both driving in the car pool lane and the unsafe lane change were illegal on the part of this other car. My argument was that the officer (having seen this whole thing (we talked about it when he wrote up my ticket)) was that safely avoiding the collision from the illegal driver was the proximate cause of the alleged violation. I was also irritated he didn't cite the other driver for his egregious actions.
- eloff 10y agoThat would have rubbed me the wrong way too. Good on you for pushing back and winning.
- nothrabannosir 10y ago> I just entered a plea of not guilty at the clerk, and the court informed me a week before my trial date that the prosecution had declined to prosecute. It is disappointingly common. To the point you can unironically say: tickets are a tax on the busy, and those unfamiliar with or frightened by the courts. This shotgun "see what sticks" approach is infuriating.
- ajmurmann 10y agoMy wife had a even more annoying case of this in SF. They actually set a trial date, she went, sat on court for hours and then when the trial came up it turned out that the cop who had given her the ticket hadn't shown up and she got to get home and get the money from the ticket back. Then it took the city about a year to pay the money back. Just imagine we had taken a year to pay the ticket...
- dctoedt 10y agos/Sheparding/Shepardizing </lawyer pedantry>
- nwenzel 10y agoCaseText (https://CaseText.com https://CaseText.com) is pretty close to Google for law. They have a new tool that is aimed at lawyers doing legal research where they suggest other relevant cases based on the cases you're already citing. Disclaimer: I have nothing to do with CaseText but I do know the CEO as a result of being a legal operations software CEO and being in YC with them.
- Jemaclus 10y agoI came here to recommend CaseText as well. It's a superb resource for law-related research.
- zepto 10y agoSo much for google ever really caring about anything other than an easy advertising revenue stream.
- randyrand 10y agoThe anti gridlock law is actually a great law that DOES stop gridlock. The problem is you need to get people to actually follow it and in california for some reason no one does. In chicago we all know about this law and I had never seen gridlock the whole time I lived there (23 years). crazy right? not really. But to the people in LA it seems crazy to them. within a year of moving to LA, I saw gridlock. I had no idea this was still a problem in the united states. I thought it was only a 3rd world problem. But nope. In LA they have it. And it's becuase people block intersections here ALL THE FUCKING TIME. It's crazy. Why? I don't get it. Do LA drives really not know it causes gridlock? Or do they just not care. I remember talking to an uber driver who didn't even know what gridlock was, or why blocking intersectinos was bad. As someone from chicago, I was amazed. And even on HN, OP doesn't know that blocking intersections causes gridlock, it amazes me. I thought this was common knowledge. For some reason people in these gridlocked towns are skeptical that the law doesn't work. for example, in downtown LA they blocked one street for a festival and the entire downtown became gridlocked. Ive never seen traffic this bad IN MY ENTIRE LIFE. All because of people blocking intersections. I was able to walk 10 blocks faster than cars did. I saw cars sitting in place for an hour and more. It was crazy. I've never seen anything like it. And when the lights turned green people still blocked the intersection. THEY WERE SITTING IN GRIDLOCK AND STILL DIDN"T STOP BLOCKING INTERSECTINOS. Like wow. I was dumbfounded. How are LA drivers so bad at driving?? I was so glad to be on foot. It's a completely fair law; it's easy to follow, and it benefits everyone. blocking intersections DOES CAUSE GRIDLOCK. IF YOU STOP BLOCKING INTERSECTIONS, GRIDLOCK WILL GO AWAY. Get this through your head! the problem is people dont know about the law in california, and don't have the common sense to figure out themselves. it needs to be enforced more. LA has some of the worst gridlock problems ive ever seen.
- mistermann 10y agoI would appreciate if anyone can point to any noteworthy studies documenting the impact on traffic flow that avoidable gridlock can have, I would like to contact administrators in my city to get them to consider a public education campaign to teach drivers about turning lanes and pedestrians about walk signals. The combination of these two things means at rush hour we're often lucky if we get 2 cars at a time through a light (1 lane plus turning lane, driver trying to turn leaving his ass in the main lane preventing anyone else from passing, meanwhile pedestrians don't respect walking stop signal, so sometimes the turning driver can't even make it through after the light has turned red as then the main traffic is coming, as they even often have to wait for someone crossing).
- DannyBee 10y agoChuck, I'm not sure who you talked to in 2006 at Google, you should know we basically done done it already :) It was being done then, in fact. It made it well past the discussion page, and was already being implemented. We spent a lot of time building up a case law, pushing to open Pacer (meeting with the federal judiciary and offering to just pay the revenue they make), etc. Scholar has pretty up to date legal data since then, from OCR'ing federal reporters to parsing it, to what have you. In fact, ask Carl. We worked really closely with him and have helped fund him for years, both directly, and through public.resource.org (https://yeswescan.org/index.court.html https://yeswescan.org/index.court.html - 9F is Anurag, who started/ran Google Scholar, 22F is the group I ran) A lot of states have exclusive contracts with westlaw or nexis or what have you, so it's non-trivial. The target was also to try to have data for the kind of situation you mention, not to try to replace the dedicate legal resources that exist. Anyway, again, not sure why you think Google didn't do it.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> A lot of states have exclusive contracts with westlaw or nexis or what have you, so it's non-trivial. Have you considered bidding for the contracts when they come up?
- DannyBee 10y agoYou say this as if they aren't like 10+ year contracts :) Also, they often come with crazy requirements and local IT support (designed this way in order to ensure only lexis/westlaw can fulfill them).
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThat sounds suspiciously like Corruption.
- foxyv 10y agoSorta, but not really. Usually what happens is that a company works with a state or local government on custom projects for so long that they create their own niche which is extremely difficult for a newcomer to fill. This is mostly just an emergent property of bureaucracy. Eventually these niches are choked off and die, however it takes decades.
- rayiner 10y agoSheparding isn't hard and Google Scholar does an adequate job of it for cases in its database. Doing anything more sophisticated is much harder though. Take a simple query I needed the other day: when is it proper to file a summary judgment motion before claim construction of a patent? The query "summary judgment before claim construction" on Google Scholar returns a bunch of highly-cited cases, and on the first page only one is even a patent case, and none answer the question. In contrast, the first hit on WestLaw is a directly relevant case. It's a District of South Carolina case, cited by a single other case, but it answers the question! And that's with a free-form query, which I'd never do. One minute of planning to create a good terms-and-connectors search immediately returns mostly-relevant cases.
- agumonkey 10y agoReading this made lawyers the closed source programmers of society in my mind.
- regulation_d 10y agoYes. This. Not just in terms of access to code but general willingness to be helpful to your colleagues also. As a lawyer turned programmer I remember when I discovered IRC thinking "Why can't attorneys be this chill with each other?!"
- rahimnathwani 10y agoI'm sad to hear that gridlock laws were not enforced. Gridlock is a pet peeve of mine as it wastes a lot of time unnecessarily. It's a simple coordination problem, with an easy solution (yellow boxes with expensive, automatic fines) that's proven to work (at least in London). One day ~3 months ago, I spent >3 hours going 16km in Beijing, as large parts of the city were gridlocked: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12980961 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12980961
- DanBC 10y agobut see the charity Bailli http://www.bailii.org/ http://www.bailii.org/ They don't seem to have been targeted by uk lawyers. If anything they're a respected site.
- all_usernames 10y ago> I had gotten a ticket for obstructing the intersection > I was fighting it I hope you lost.