10 ms·
COP21: Arnold Schwarzenegger: 'Go part-time vegetarian to protect the planet'
- dkarapetyan 10y agoThe framing in these things is always wrong. We are not protecting the planet. The planet will be fine. The planet has been fine for a long time. What won't be fine is a certain kind of primate that likes to live in certain places.
- adamnemecek 10y agoNow that we've rephrased the problem, what does it mean moving forward?
- debacle 10y agoThat not every person choosing to be ecologically responsible is the tree-hugging, job killing, PETA strawman, for one.
- adamnemecek 10y agoWas there such an implication?
- ZenoArrow 10y agoCulturally, yes. It doesn't matter if that was the reality or not, the cultural narratives that surround environmentalism do have an effect on who takes part, which means overcoming personal prejudice is part of the movement towards a greener future.
- wuschel 10y agoSpot on. Once the food chain collapses, primates and many other higher life forms will be in peril.
- moufestaphio 10y agoGeorge Carlin had a good bit on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fdVE-efyv2c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fdVE-efyv2c
- dkarapetyan 10y agoThat's indeed pretty good. Thanks for the link.
- almostApatriot1 10y agoThis type of response is intentionally obtuse. By 'planet' people mean the planet's ecosystems. By the time humans are in danger, 90%+ of other species will probably be long gone.
- _qc3o 10y agoSo? The planet has also gone through several extinction events. The white knighting ain't helping anyone. Obtuse or not.
- lern_too_spel 10y agoHis obtuseness point is that you know exactly what he means by protecting the planet, but you chose to interpret that phrase literally.
- jogjayr 10y ago> but you chose to interpret that phrase literally. But when we're dealing with geological timescales I think a literal interpretation may be the right way of looking at it. Would it be sad if 90% of Earth's species died off? Certainly, if there were any humans around to do the mourning. But zooming out a bit, the current die-off isn't anything new. There have been mass extinctions and rapid alterations of climate and atmosphere in the Earth's past too. Humans originated on this planet and we are a part of the ecosystem. In a way, anything we do to nature is simply one part of nature being wildly out of equilibrium. If we mess it up, it'll mean curtains for us but life itself will march on. In 10-50 million years after we're gone, there will arise lifeforms that are just as interesting and varied as anything we have now. Which, on a geological timescale, really isn't that long (between 0.0025% and 0.0125% of the Earth's age). I think that promoting environmentalism in terms of it being a means to saving ourselves might be more effective than appeals to "save the rapidly dying $ENDANGERED_SPECIES".
- handsomechad 10y agoIsn't this rather rich coming from a guy who has probably consumed 100 times more animal protein in his ~70 years on earth than the average joe to whom he is now rationing.
- taeric 10y agoMeh. Assume it works and that only a hundred people listen to him... More, people can learn and advance their thinking. Robbing newcomers of help and assistance is bad. Suggesting better practices is not. Combining this with his other writing lately, I am willing to respect what his intentions seem to be.
- sp332 10y agoNot especially. Water is more constrained now that it used to be, and there are more people to feed. Anyway it means more coming from him than from some skinny hippie-type, so people are more likely to take it seriously.
- jschwartzi 10y agoActually, he's right. You do not need to eat animals to get good protein. It's easier to supplement with whey or soy protein. I wouldn't be surprised if his bodybuilding diet involved supplementation since it's much easier to meet macronutrient goals with protein shakes than by eating meat, because you don't have to worry about the fat that comes from the meat.
- tcj_phx 10y ago> It's easier to supplement with whey or soy protein. Soy is a rather poor source of protein (phyto-estrogens, etc). Whey is a waste product of the cheese industry. (Edit: All things considered, milk is a pretty good source of protein.) The milk cow is the most efficient means of converting the grass on a rocky hillside into human-edible protein (ref: some old book I have somewhere. They're all in boxes). The fat in grass-fed milk is more orange than industrial milk because there is more vitamins A & E (and beta carotene) in the milk than is in cottonseed meal (a waste product of the cotton industry that is commonly fed to dairy cows in a feedlot).
- kleiba 10y agoReminds me of this: https://www.theguardian.com/world/german-elections-blog-2013/2013/sep/13/german-election-wurst-policy-veggie-day-greens https://www.theguardian.com/world/german-elections-blog-2013...
- marricks 10y agoOr full time vegan and do more good for the planet. It's good to see people are finally acknowledging the great toll that animal ag takes on the planet. Yes, this guy used to be a big time meat eater, but he's changing his tune which should be taken as a good thing. Our propensity for vilifying people who turn the corner is baffling to me.
- eth0up 10y agoI have several friends who keep chickens. These chickens are never killed, but their eggs are consumed occasionally. These chickens roam freely during daylight, then are corralled into "cages" overnight to prevent wild animals from eating them. What benefit would come of eliminating these chickens? I am neither vegetarian or vegan, but admire both, despite perceiving veganism as the more ideological of the two. I struggle to imagine how the world would be spared demise by invading Tibet and prohibiting the use of yak butter; or banning the cultivation of fish and their superior waste as fertilizer; or exterminating the last remaining nomadic tribe of Africa through prohibiting their practice of non-fatally bleeding their animals for sustenance. If it's a matter of numbers, it is obvious that great benefit would result from the popularity of veganism; but there are also variations in quality and circumstance to consider, i.e. a diet of cellulose might benefit the world and all those not on a cellulose diet, but not necessarily those on the cellulose diet; i.e not all dietary classes are equal and a vast disparity of options may exist between individuals, groups, etc, therefore dietary practices may be circumstantial. The world is large, one person's needs vary from another's, and one group from another's. Might there there be positional benefits to all three diets? I ask this respectfully, as my unsure self, with no desire for debate, but rather a will for suitable answers. Some things I've admired recently: 1. https://impossiblefoods.com/faq/ https://impossiblefoods.com/faq/ 2. http://www.monksmeats.com/ http://www.monksmeats.com/
- epmaybe 10y agoI think that you're more right, to be honest. I'm a vegetarian myself, but in my current place of living veganism would be the most environmentally friendly. But if I lived elsewhere, maybe a different diet would be more beneficial.
- mojoe 10y agoHe's certainly right about the fact that people are not going to quit all at once -- it's an example of the tragedy of the commons. If someone can figure out how to grow a meat analog in a lab cheaply and efficiently it will probably be one of the most positively impactful technologies ever created.
- AlexeyBrin 10y agoAs a member of the commons I'm not sure if I should feel insulted or amused by your condescending tone. I eat meat because I like it and I don't try to impose my view of the world to other people.
- Infinitesimus 10y agoPerhaps English isn't your first language? This is what your parent comment is referring to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons Your statement also further solidifies his/her point.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago>"I don't try to impose my view of the world to other people." Everyone does, just not necessarily directly. Meat eating has consequences that extend beyond those that choose to eat meat. If our choices existed in isolation to the rest of the world, then we could say we didn't impose our view of the world on other people. I'm not saying you have to stop eating meat, but at least do so with awareness of what happened before the meat arrived on your plate.
- detritus 10y agoI live in a city, rarely drive and have been consciously limiting my air travel for over a decade (tricky when my family and friends live abroad) — May i enjoy a steak once a month, please? Who dictates what spread of consumption and therefore environmental impact I am allowed? - ed Apologies, I responded here instead of generally..
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nebulous1 10y agoDoesn't he drive a hummer?
- coolsunglasses 10y agoI think he converted it to run on bio-fuel. Not sure how much of a difference that makes.
- bluedino 10y agoHe has also has at least one that runs on hydrogen
- justinator 10y agoSo how many cars does this guy have, and why won't he talk about how much natural resources are used up and pollution created by the mere manufacture of a car/truck/light infantry vehicle? Saying, "go veg. part time" could be analogues to, "Hey, you need only one car? Own only one car - I'll start!"
- c0nducktr 10y agoDoesn't really change the truth behind his statement either way.
- mcv 10y agoThe leader of the Dutch Party for Animals, Marianne Thieme, once arrived somewhere in a Hummer to make a point about meat being worse than car pollution. Not sure I agree, but it's certainly an interesting point to make. (I don't think she normally drives a Hummer, though. She just loves to make dramatic statements.)
- surrey-fringe 10y agoOur population exploded when we started farming grains.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoThe largest population explosion has been in the past 100 years: https://i0.wp.com/www.historyfuturenow.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/populationgrowthhistory2.jpg https://i0.wp.com/www.historyfuturenow.com/wp/wp-content/upl...
- surrey-fringe 10y agoDoes that refute what I said? Maybe I'm misunderstanding.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoDepends on what you intended. You pointed to something which represented a relatively minor cause of population growth in the context of our overall history on this planet. What did you intend to illuminate with your earlier comment?
- surrey-fringe 10y agoRelatively minor compared to the industrial revolution, maybe. But it's certainly not minor if you look at the change in world population when Sumeria began. Just a thought. Obviously I think anyone who goes vegan means well.
- jdminhbg 10y agoI'm not sure I'd call the invention of grain agriculture relatively minor; all human population expansion depends on the availability of grain as a food storage mechanism.
- nappy-doo 10y agoArguably because of the Haber process.
- dgudkov 10y agoI wonder when will lab-grown meat become economically feasible?
- mathetic 10y agoIt is not popular to say this, but if you really want to protect the environment, you should consider not having kids. Especially if you're doing well because the chances are your kid will grow up and drive for most of his life, fly in planes, obtain lots of stuff that requires CO2 emission in its production, and perhaps even consume meat. If you have multiple kids and they go on to have more kids etc, the environmental effect of having a kid becomes exponentially worse. This doesn't mean that you don't deserve to be a parent, it is only natural to desire to be one. The closest orphanage will have many kids who are wishing for a warm home every day of the year. There are many impoverished and brilliant kids around the world who will live and die working under horrific conditions. Now there is an argument to be made about you and your partner's genes being so exceptional that it would be more harmful to the society not to pass them to future generations. I guess it is up to the individual to make that judgement.
- trymas 10y agoThis! [0] About 12 years ago I proposed during class in school, that to save the planet we must reduce number of people living on Earth significantly and relatively quickly. Well the teacher thought that I was new Hitler (at least at first). Just like you said, the point is that either people shouldn't have kids at all or have no more than 1. If whole Earth's population would do this, in 30years we will see a sharp fall in the population count. And in 60years it should be reduced by 30% at least [1]. If we will not do this now - our children, or grand children will not thank us. [0] this is probably against HN ethos, though I couldn't resist [1] It's completely out of my head, though if the perfect scenario would work - I guess it's a reasonable number.
- crpatino 10y agoWe need both, to reduce the total number of people AND to reduce the per capita consumption. I have seen more than enough people that claim to have no children for the sake of the Environment, only to go and buy pets and treat those like children; retarded children that will never learn to speak, walk in 2 feet, or become productive members of society, demanding constant attention for their natural lifespan, and which will age rapidly and die in their teens, - and have valuable medical resources expended in heroic efforts to futily prolongue their agony for weeks/months. You could claim that the pet dies early and does not produce offspring, but then the pet owner will likely mourn for a few weeks and then go to the pet store and start all over again.
- dorfsmay 10y agoBeside saving the planet, we actually don't need to eat a lot of meat, once or twice a week should be sufficient in terms of health benefit.
- isaac_is_goat 10y agoYou don't need any meat. There's no health benefit from meat you can't get from plants, and plenty of things in meat that are horrible for your health.
- ajanuary 10y agoI know this isn't the point you were making, but I wanted to take the opportunity to do a PSA. While it's true you don't need any meat, it's not true you can get everything you need from an unsupplimented vegan diet (more accurately, it's incredibly hard). If you're looking at a vegan diet, consider researching supplements such as for B12. If you're lazy and in the UK, Holland and Barret sell a single tablet supplement designed for a vegan diet (just ignore all of the other bollocks they sell in there)
- isaac_is_goat 10y agoEveryone should be conscious of B12 and be supplementing. It's dirt cheap, and crucial to proper brain function. Last time I checked something like 40% of Americans are deficient or borderline deficient but less than 3% are vegan. Humans don't get B12 from dirty water and trace amounts of dirt on vegetables like we used to thousands of years ago and a lot of people aren't getting enough from the meat they are eating. B12 from meat is usually coming by proxy through the animal because farmers typically supplement the animals with it too. B12 is an issue for everyone.
- Pxtl 10y agoIirc, from a land management perspective this is also the most efficient - some land is only good for livestock, not people. So while a vegan diet is a close second for "most efficient use of Earth's bounty" the ideal approach for that is a small amount of animal products. That said, we don't need meat. There are countless healthy vegans and vegetarians that are living proof of this.
- PerfectElement 10y agoFor those who are interested in reducing their animal consumption and need an extra push, I recommend this great talk by Dr. Melanie Joy about carnism, which is the invisible belief system that conditions us to eat certain animals: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0VrZPBskpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0VrZPBskpg
- aaronblohowiak 10y agoBeef is the worst. Avoid ruminants because of their methane release (cow burps are 25x more potent a ghg than co2). Also look at the feed to weight ratio for animals, cows are like 6:1 whereas chicken is 1.5:1, and chicken don't release substantial methane. Pork is about 4:1. Rabbit is about 3:1 and has a very fast time to cull.
- chrisan 10y agoIn addition to saving the planet, you can also save yourself from cancer and heart disease! http://www.aicr.org/reduce-your-cancer-risk/recommendations-for-cancer-prevention/recommendations_05_red_meat.html http://www.aicr.org/reduce-your-cancer-risk/recommendations-... http://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/new-study-links-l-carnitine-in-red-meat-to-heart-disease-201304176083 http://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/new-study-links-l-carniti... We have moved to eating red meat to a max of twice a month
- Paul_S 10y agoIf fewer people eat meat will meat be more or less expensive for me?
- IIJamesII 10y ago"one person could have flown coach from New York to Japan (and back) 3,408 TIMES with the amount of fuel the Governator used to commute within California." Who does he think he is lecturing poor people like me about what I ought to be eating for dinner?! http://www.hopesandfears.com/hopes/now/question/214841-how-much-jet-fuel-did-arnold-schwarzenegger-waste http://www.hopesandfears.com/hopes/now/question/214841-how-m...
- Turbots 10y agoEven though, indeed, he used up a lot of fuel (and therefore emitted lots of carbon) to perform his duties as governor (which is measurable as proven by your link), I still think he had a positive net effect on the climate by the actions he took as governor (which is much harder to measure ofcourse)
- Infinitesimus 10y agoI think most of us here agree that ditching the Gulfstream will do wonders for the environment; but this isn't a pitch for "Arnold is living the best life for the environment." He is a man who is becoming more conscious of his meat intake and taking steps to reduce that and his footprint. Can he do better? Of course! Does that negate the validity of the argument that reduction of meat intake is a good idea for the environment? Nope. The overall point is that we can all take little steps to reduce our footprint and meat is just one of them. That said, it is quite amazing just how much fuel has he used.
- khedoros1 10y ago> Does that negate the validity of the argument Does that matter? Most people will just say "What a hypocrite" and ignore the message. People don't respond well to logic, they respond to emotion. A valid argument that doesn't convince anyone is worthless.
- IIJamesII 10y agoI'm saying it's a glaringly bad strategy. Buy hey, continue trotting out complete and utter hypocrites to lecture us on what ought to feed our families for dinner.
- belorn 10y agoThere has been quite a few articles about the climate effect of meat eating, but every time it lacks a good comparison towards the older common problems like car emissions. They general do not mention that driving 10 minutes each day, or choosing a vegetarian diet vs meat rich diet for a whole day has the same effect on the environment (from a CO2 perspective). 10 min drive, or a 5 min commute from one place to an other, is something I think most people don't consider as far away. Driving to a vegetarian place for lunch might set back the environment more than a walk to a beef restaurant. We should have a cost table if we want to minimize the environmental impact on this individual level. > He said it was pointless trying to persuade people to give up things they wanted, like big cars And this is why I suspect we have seen so many articles trying to address diet instead. Having everyone reducing CO2 a bit is easier than addressing those that do order of magnitude more damage, since there is so much more people who eat than people who own a car. *edited 10m -> 10 minutes
- konschubert 10y ago10 meter or 10 miles? And if miles, what kind of mile?
- josh64 10y agoOr minutes?
- lacampbell 10y agoI read it as minutes. I'm from a metric using country, but IIRC "mile" is commonly abbreviated to "mi".
- belorn 10y agoYes, sorry for the confusion. I meant a 10 minutes drive or 5 minutes to a lunch restaurant and 5 minutes back.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- applecore 10y agoNine of the top ten leading causes of death[1] in the United States can be directly attributed to meat consumption, so there's already a perfectly "selfish" motive to go vegan or vegetarian. [1]: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm
- f- 10y agoThe "top ten" list you linked to includes accidents (such as poisonings and falls), suicide, and influenza. I do not mean to be a jerk and I am no meat apologist - but is meat consumption playing a direct, notable role in at least two out of these three?
- toxicFork 10y agoHow can you link suicide, cancer, Alzheimer's, or accidents to meat? And most of the rest of that list?
- DanBC 10y agoWe know that eating processed red meat causes cancer, and the evidence for this is very good. We also know that it doesn't cause many cases of cancer. This was poorly reported last year with people talking about red meat, cancer, and smoking.
- Tade0 10y agoI looked at the statistics and apparently I eat 3-5 times less meat than an average US citizen. I guess I'm doing my part then.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoAt the age of 70 Arnold has probably consumed more meat than an average sized U.S family will in their lifetime. It's nice that he's changed his tune on meat consumption, but it's come rather late in his life. Arnold has had his fill and then some and now he wants to make the planet better by suggesting others limit their consumption.