3 ms·
In science and engineering you almost never have a "major breakthrough" where some radical change happens over night. Progress is made by slow incremental impro
by adrianN 10y ago
In science and engineering you almost never have a "major breakthrough" where some radical change happens over night. Progress is made by slow incremental improvements. Only from a historian's bird-eye view can you make statements like "the steam engine started the industrial revolution". Steam engines existed before James Watt. He just improved them a little to make them commercially viable.
AI in particular suffers from poor definitions. Nothing computers can do is "AI", only the things that are still impossible can be called "AI". Doing arithmetic was once thought to be a sign of intelligence. So was playing Chess, or Go, or recognizing faces. Now that computers can do this easily it is no longer considered difficult.
So while the recent progress with neural networks is likely somewhat overhyped you shouldn't discount the importance of making things commercially viable. In the 90s we had software that could do image recognition, true, but it wasn't accurate enough, general enough, fast enough to be useful in practice. This has changed over the last ten years to the point where image recognition has tons of commercial applications.
- marcosdumay 10y ago> Only from a historian's bird-eye view can you make statements like "the steam engine started the industrial revolution". I'm always baffled by that example. The Industrial Revolution was already ongoing when the steam engines become practical.
- archgoon 10y agoSeems like it's unintentionally apt then ;)
- goatlover 10y agoSo we have better, commercially available, versions of what existed decades ago. That's progress, but is it progress toward general AI?
- adrianN 10y agoMaybe. We don't know how to do general AI yet, so nobody can really tell.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoIt's revealing when you read older books pontificating about why computers can never be as smart as humans. They would say things like a computer will never be able to write poetry, prove a theorem or play chess like an expert. Now that computers have achieved all of that of course the goalposts have shifted.