5 ms·
Seattle's record apartment boom is ready to explode
- WalterBright 10y agoIt's interesting to see people rediscover the law of supply and demand. :-)
- bluebeard 10y agoThe law of supply and demand doesn't necessarily apply. Companies seem to be fine with empty units since rates are so high, and the market seems to be regulated by algorithms based on my observation of daily price fluctuations. It is my personal opinion that the "law" of supply and demand is the biggest lie told in Economics 101, and is easily repeated to the point that people accept it as truth. The place I moved out of in Seattle saw a 30% rate hike as it was entering the shadow of a new apartment complex... which also killed the view. True value drops, price goes up. It's a regulated bubble. That's my experience.
- toasterlovin 10y agoI think the standard caveat for most economic theories is "given enough time".
- peatmoss 10y agoYes. That, and a whole bunch of other caveats about market competition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition There's a storybook understanding of economics that pervades pop-culture and is dangerously okay-ish as a first approximation. Faith in the potential for free markets to exist can be a powerful force. Unfortunately, the conditions required to have a truly free market are pretty rare--and I'm most definitely not advocating for reflexive deregulation here. When perfect market conditions don't exist, you can think of things like information asymmetries and transaction costs as economic friction. Sometimes that results in market lag. Sometimes, especially in big markets, that friction can lock big tectonic plates building pressure until something fails catastrophically. As for housing in Seattle, additional supply is a good thing. It's not the only thing needed for near-term affordability, but it's one thing.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt always applies. The rate hike you saw was supported by an increase in demand relative to the supply. The new apt complex simply kept the price from rising even higher.
- chillacy 10y agoThat's why you moved out of it, and if nobody wants to move into it, then the price will drop. Supply and demand are still setting prices, but its a bit of a dance.
- emmelaich 10y ago> "law" of supply and demand is the biggest lie told in Economics 101 The law of supply and demand cannot NOT apply. The relationship might be elastic or inelastic. The cause and the measure of supply and demand may be difficult to find. But it cannot NOT apply.
- cylinder 10y agoSounds a lot like what's been happening in Melbourne for a decade now. Lessons to be learned there.
- ido 10y agoIsn't this a positive thing? Increased supply will reduce prices.
- cylinder 10y agoI don't mind it even if it's all to sell to foreigners, but I do mind when they don't rent it out and the apartments are built horribly, with major defects, unlivable sizes, paper thin walls etc because the overseas buyers don't care and just want bank accounts. You need strict minimum standards.
- woodpanel 10y agoI do think too there should be always quality standards for construction to secure a minimum quality of housing (Most of what attracts people to suburbia besides the price is privacy). But I think the biggest inflater usually is height-restrictions, parking-lot-requirements and a general uncertainty of what an ownership title actually means: in every municipality you'll find different possibilities of NIMBY-interference and likelihoods thereof.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoIs there a lot of Chinese speculation in the Seattle market?
- cylinder 10y agoRecently more interest as Vancouver turned against foreign buyers with new taxes. However, the strong USD should clamp down a bit. Seattle also has strong local demand though, for now.
- woofyman 10y ago
- jandrewrogers 10y agoThis a great thing considering Seattle's insane, tech-driven population growth and the pressure it has put on housing supply. To the city's credit, they have not been shy about aggressively constructing new housing, both rental and for sale. Nonetheless, housing costs have been skyrocketing because the builders haven't been able to keep up with the demand rate. Hopefully this is a sign that they are finally catching up with Seattle's market demand and rental rates can come down a bit. While it is difficult to grow an urban region this fast without side effects, I think Seattle has done a reasonably good job managing the crazy population growth compared to some cities like San Francisco. The money quote: "The city is on pace to see more apartments built this decade than in the previous 50 years combined"
- saosebastiao 10y agoThe problem isn't the builders, it's the city's fear of its own NIMBY residents. It takes 4-5 years to build an apartment building, but less than 1 of those years is actual construction. The rest is taken up by draconian regulatory compliance, permitting, and several community reviews where developers basically have to concede to every possible demand of current residents. And this is the best case scenario. If you need to rezone, you should be prepared to sit on empty land for ten years or more. If Seattle was more serious about increasing supply, that build cycle would be a lot closer to 1 year than 5...housing developers would love to respond more quickly to demand.
- woodpanel 10y agoAnd because of this there is the YIMBY-movement: http://yimbytown.com/ http://yimbytown.com/ :-)
- woodpanel 10y agoRegarding the money quote: Doesn't it beg the question as of why exactly supply took so long for catching up with demand? Because I doubt the increase in citizens in the last years is also more than in the "last 50 years combined". Also, those new citizens surely didn't only moved to Seattle just because of the "amazon effect". Is this the story of too much red-tape or the story of too low a demand to cut-through (costs of) red-tape? Seattle has seem to cut back on it by "allowing denser housing or rolling back requirements to build costly parking garages". IMO, supply here isn't being built for the existing demand, because entry-level housing (cheap) isn't being built as much. Indicating a market interference to me. There (as in most cities) doesn't seem to be much done to make efficient housing construction possible. So for the less affluent ones: Scale down your housing-expectations per dollar, wait out until those new constructions have been worn down and the boom-buildings have seen their bust-caused ownership changes.
- coliveira 10y agoThis is very good news. The worst thing cities can do is to create silly laws to curb construction, driving prices to insane levels. Hopefully rental prices will go down towards a more sustainable level.
- sjg007 10y agoWell I think they will get rented by all of the ex-silicon valley folks who want a better deal.