6 ms·
Everyone always wants to prevent cures for autism, but no one ever suggests inventing something that gives people autism. (It was sort of a plot point in a Ver
by astrange 10y ago
Everyone always wants to prevent cures for autism, but no one ever suggests inventing something that gives people autism.
(It was sort of a plot point in a Vernor Vinge novel. And Brave New World?)
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoAren't those functionally the same thing? It reminds me of a debugging technique I sometimes use, to prove to myself I understand a complex issue I try to make it worse. If I can then I almost certainly understand how to fix it too.
- nikanj 10y agoA reliable repro is 98% of solving the problem.
- jessriedel 10y agoGP comment is drawing out an ethical tension, not a technical one.
- api 10y agoProblem is there is autism like (maybe) Einstein or Tesla and then there is autism where the child can't communicate or adapt to any form of human social interaction or contact. The former is neurodiversity, the latter a debilitating disease. These are not the same thing and need different terms.
- rntz 10y agoIs there any evidence that they have different underlying causes or are otherwise fundamentally distinct rather than one simply being an extreme case of the other? (Honest question; I'm not familiar with the literature here.) Or, even if they were in some sense fundamentally the same, is your argument that their effects are so practically different that they ought to be called by distinct names anyway?
- mercer 10y agoAsperger's used to be classified separately but is now considered part of the autism spectrum. That said, I don't think this was done primarily because of a consensus over there being just one 'fundamental type' of autism. As I understand it, there isn't even a consensus on any theory of what autism fundamentally is. Some theories try to explain the social issues as a lack of Theory Of mind, but these theories don't cover the many other symptoms typical of autism. One more recent theory ('Intense Worlds') does present a 'fundamental' explanation for all/most symptoms, but AFAIK it's not well-accepted or supported by evidence (yet), and the fact that it explains so much is also considered a drawback (too vague / overfitting / whatever the term is). > Or, even if they were in some sense fundamentally the same, is your argument that their effects are so practically different that they ought to be called by distinct names anyway? I've noticed that there seems to be a movement in treatment approach that focuses on treating individual symptoms without focusing too much on the overarching 'labels'. In my experience it's been a very nice, down to earth approach, and it strikes me as more measurable too. This approach strikes me as particularly useful for autism because there's so much variation between different autists and the particular symptoms they exhibit.
- wbl 10y agoThey are the same thing, just as someone with a slight sniffle and someone with a sinus infection can both have a cold, and there are lots of places in between. We've also gotten a lot better at treatment: a significant fraction of children with large language delays end up living independently.
- kosma 10y agoThe recent developments of DSM-5 and ICD-11 show the opposite: decades of research failed to show any scientifically valid distinction between functional and non-functional autism. That's why they are being conflated into a single "autism spectrum disorder" category.
- bbarn 10y agoThose books exist as a method for billing insurance. The DSM only recently (1983) stopped considering homosexuality a diagnosis. As a result we're hearing the phrase "somewhere on the spectrum" for any number of behaviors we don't see fitting the norm, and the reality of autism is not this "beautiful mind" scenario for many, but instead a crippling illness like the AP mentions. They are definitely not the same thing to the people who live with them. The article is completely centered around the media image that autism creates geniuses, and that's a dangerous, misleading idea at best. The reality of living with it is usually much more ugly. Children who often become grown adults who can't make connections between cause and effect violently lashing out, throwing feces, biting care givers, screaming, screaming, and more screaming. We should absolutely keep looking for ways to prevent and try to treat/cure it, and not act like everything is fine and great and accept it as diversity, for the sake of those who can't live normally.
- throwaway876543 10y agoAs someone who falls in the "Beautiful Mind" end of the spectrum I find it insulting and abhorrent that people would do anything OTHER than cure us if they could. Beneath superficial success and contribution, my life is a nonstop Munchian scream. I find it less insulting when people say everyone on the spectrum should be exterminated, than when people say some of us should be allowed to continue existing because our particular end of the spectrum happens to write pretty code / invent pretty theorems / etc.
- euyyn 10y agoOn the other hand, I've met high-functioning autists that feel offended at the idea that people want to cure them. My cousin is on the "very crippled side" of the spectrum, so I'd give anything for a cure. So I guess if the person can understand the concept, it should be their own call.
- SonOfLilit 10y agoI think you're talking about Distress by Greg Egan? Was the book about the announcement of a Theory of Everything on an artificial island?
- teraflop 10y agoPretty sure OP was referring to A Deepness in the Sky.
- SonOfLilit 10y agoI'm very surprised that two authors that are commonly confused with each other would make a secondary plot point about the same subject that is very weakly related to their main interests.
- astrange 10y agoYes, but I didn't want to spoil it.
- rntz 10y agoThis isn't as inconsistent as it seems. People would probably also be equally uncomfortable with both the idea of "editing" an embryo's genome to make it light-skinned, and the inverse idea of editing it to make it dark-skinned.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoWhy are people uncomfortable with this? While it's not important enough for genetic engineering on it's own, I'd probably edit my children to be darker. Having spent a few days on the beach in Thailand, the genetic inferiority of my own fair skin is quite visible and painful.
- up_so_floating 10y agoYour body evolved skin to suit an environment other than a Thai beach. I would not consider that genetic inferiority.
- jessriedel 10y agoPale skin is thought to have evolved as a rapid (last ~5k years) and crude adaptation to avoid vitamin D deficiency shortly after farming was developed and allowed non-animal-based diets at the very high latitudes of northern Europe. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/04/how-europeans-evolved-white-skin http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/04/how-europeans-evolved... It is reasonable to think that there the significant drawbacks associated with that hacked-together solution are no longer necessary because modern diets easily give adequate vitamin D.
- Tycho 10y agoSo you're saying pale skin is a "hacked together" solution but modern vitamin supplements are not?
- jessriedel 10y ago
- nabla9 10y agoAn illustrated transcript of a talk presented at the First Biennial Conference on Induc ed Humanoid Subspecies Peter Watts, Ph.D. FizerPharm Evoconsumables http://rifters.com/blindsight/vampires.htm http://rifters.com/blindsight/vampires.htm http://www.rifters.com/real/shorts/VampireDomestication.pdf http://www.rifters.com/real/shorts/VampireDomestication.pdf
- gcr 10y agoTed Chiang wrote a short story, "The Evolution of Human Science", about that idea. If I recall, the main premise was that new parents could choose to give their children a neurodevelopmental drug that would cause vastly increased intellectual prowess at the cost of gradually losing their connection to human society to the point of indecipherability. I think it was a bit heavy-handed. But maybe I'm not remembering the story correctly.