5 ms·
Why Russia’s Economy Survives
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- refulgentis 10y agoDepressing. Is there any reason to think Putin's strategies are unsustainable?
- gragas 10y agoHow is this depressing? Is it not a good thing that Putin's conservative fiscal and monetary strategies were able to keep Russia afloat?
- Filligree 10y agoNot if you're in a country bordering it.
- gragas 10y agoDo you seriously expect Putin, of all people, to raise up neighboring countries in lieu of Russia? He is a strategist who puts his country above all else. This is practically out of Machiavelli's The Prince: Putin "entertains" neighboring countries and keeps a strong grip over them. But he won't expend resources on them.
- refulgentis 10y agoYou have invented a straw man. The parent was referring to activity such as draining resources and stoking fears in the populace of Estonia. See http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/12/trump-russia-worries-estonia-214511 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/12/trump-russia-.... Also, Russia's backing of Assad in Syria propped up a dictator assaulting civilians with banned chemical weapons and lead to the deaths of hundreds of thousands, and a refugee crisis that disrupted a continent.
- refulgentis 10y agoThe Syrian atrocities.
- gragas 10y agoYeah, and by that logic it's sad that the US is still afloat because all the atrocities that it has committed. I think comments like "Oh so depressing, think of the Syrian atrocities, etc." are at best simplistic nihilism. It's very easy to make comments like those; it's more fruitful to say something worthwhile.
- refulgentis 10y agoYou extrapolated a particular interpretation of my comment into a bizarre straw man (how in the world does the US being afloat justify the acts I named? Completely invalid argumentation), downvoted me, and put me down. I'm not sure there's much charitable behavior occuring here, but I upvoted you across the board. :) Troll away, good sir!
- gragas 10y agoI honestly didn't downvote you. I'm not trying to argue that the US being afloat justifies the acts you named. I was just trying to point out that what you said can be said about almost any country. I understand where you're coming from, but I think it's ridiculous to wish harsh economic conditions on Russia simply because Putin's geopolitical strategies don't align with your own. :/
- refulgentis 10y agoIt's complete non-sequitor - noting that all countries do bad things doesn't have any relation to wanting countries who commit bad things to have less resources. I'm guessing you're attempting to claim that I'm saying that all countries should have less resources, thus making my point moot, but that would require me not believing all countries should have less resources, which requires you guessing about my state of mind to prop up a straw man. Bwah? Anyways, the whole thing is obviated by the larger category of error: black and white thinking on your part. The context of the atrocities matters.
- refulgentis 10y agoSabre-rattling destabilizing Estonia. http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/12/trump-russia-worries-estonia-214511 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/12/trump-russia-...
- devoply 10y ago> When the Soviet Union confronted this array of challenges in the mid-1980s, it promptly collapsed. Bullshit. Soviet economy was just fine at the end of the Cold War. In fact Soviet GDP per capita was half that of the US, compared to now where it's like 10% of the US. Many historians agree that there was no economic need for the Soviet Union to be dismantled. Article reads of conventional wisdom as advocated by Cold War propaganda about the Soviet Union. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Soviet_Union
- frozenport 10y agoThe Russian SSR actually seceded, with its delegates citing economic reasons - in particular giving more than recieving. Compared to western countries there was a palpable lack of consumer goods.
- icebraining 10y ago*seceded Sorry, but I spent a few minutes trying to make sense of that :)
- woodpanel 10y agoEvery time I read about the "lack of consumer goods" in the eastern block as proof of its justified demise I kringe. On the one hand, it sounds just mean to denounce the efforts of complete nations (unfree or not) by such a mundane metric as whether you can choose between a plethora of car brands and models or just choose between "No-Car" and "Car". Having "Car" is still good. But the difference between output in the west and the east tells so much about how this diversion must have come about: much, much force. In so many aspects of daily life. Most easterners have them, their stories of this ridiculous economy. A friend of mine owns an ash-tray that is simultaneously a rubber duck (!). But my favourite story is still the one of once-staunch socialist Dr. Wolfgang Seiffert who was part of a COMECON conference somewhere in the southern GDR in the 1960s. There, top economists of the eastern bloc conferred about why there was an ongoing shortage of toothbrushes in Saxonia. After three weeks he broke with the idea of central planning (and the mindset that created it): 1) Not only did the system provide a shortage for such an inferior day-to-day product as toothbrushes 2) The system needed its elite economists to gather for three weeks to find a solution 3) which they didn't The eastern bloc's economic prospects were dire from the get-go and some in the elite knew very early on. It's not a coincidence that Putin comes from one part of that elite that knew all too well: the KGB.
- Grue3 10y ago"Why Venezuela's Economy Survives" (under Chavez) It won't. Big government and economy stability are incompatible.
- diimdeep 10y agoHow we supposed to read this paywalled story?
- grzm 10y agoClick the "web" link under the submission title and follow the link to the article on the subsequent page. Some people find it necessary to use an incognito window.