9 ms·
Very funny quote: “You’ve got some engineers making 20 million yen ($170,000) a year. Then you try to fit them in the traditional manufacturer-based salary stru
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Very funny quote: “You’ve got some engineers making 20 million yen ($170,000) a year. Then you try to fit them in the traditional manufacturer-based salary structure where it should be 7 to 9 million yen.”
Clearly they don't understand the market, if the other parts of the market are paying 20Million Yen for this position then that is where it "should be" and you have to figure out how to cover that cost.
I get really tired of companies saying "Talent Shortage" when they really mean "I don't want to pay that much."
- elastic_church 10y ago"Tech" companies treat their engineers as investments Mr. Business from Business Factory LLC treats their engineers as expenses this isn't relevant to just salaries, but to the tools available and requested, to the blanket IT policies
- micaksica 10y ago> Mr. Business from Business Factory LLC treats their engineers as expenses Mister Business can go without engineers, then. You'd think he'd let his own biases not get in the way of how a market actually works. It's not just MBAs that act this way. A lot of engineers believe that their rockstar skillset is the only one that runs a company, and therefore only they should be compensated at some "elite" status.
- WaxProlix 10y agoMight just be another instance of everyone living at the center of their own universe - their skillset is the most valuable, their viewpoint the most legitimate, etc. While I do love me a good anti-MBA circlejerk from time to time, this is probably not the best target. If Mr Business didn't try to optimize and pay his engineers as little as possible, for instance, The Market would be broken in another way.
- raverbashing 10y agoOf course But the engineer who put up with Mr. Business crap are not the brightest ones usually. And to be fair they probably won't care to correct when Mr. Business wants to do something stupid (or just don't know this is the case). Or even if they do care Mr. B knows better right? Because he's the boss Then Mr B goes out of business because his product sucks, or "gets hacked".
- user5994461 10y agoI've never seen a company where engineers were the "elite" status.
- mtgx 10y agoWhich is why I wouldn't trust any of the traditional car makers with their "self-driving cars" over the next decade...or two.
- GVIrish 10y agoDon't trust the Silicon Valley 'break the rules until you're forced to stop' types either. The traditional car makers are much more likely to be very deliberate and methodical about the tremendous variability in conditions that a self-driving car has to succeed in. On the other side you have guys like George Hotz who had a reporter in the car with him when he turned on the self-driving system he had only gotten working that morning..
- pzh 10y ago> On the other side you have guys like George Hotz who had a reporter in the car with him when he turned on the self-driving system he had only gotten working that morning.. Do you think that's actually true? I thought it was just something that George Hotz misguidedly said for dramatic effect...
- GVIrish 10y agoI hope he was being dramatic but judging from how he responded to the NHTSA letter he received and his general disregard for regulations I have to take him at his word.
- __derek__ 10y agoDo you have reason to believe that they treat their software engineers poorly? I know people who work on software at Ford and GM, and they seem to enjoy it. Plus, just based on Glassdoor[1][2], the salaries seem pretty good relative to cost of living. Edit: On another read-through, my comment is a non sequitur. The Big Three are just so intertwined with automakers in my mind that it was hard to shake the association, even knowing that this article is about Japanese car companies. [1]: Software Engineers at Ford: https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Ford-Motor-Company-Software-Engineer-Salaries-E263_D_KO19,36.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Ford-Motor-Company-Software... [2]: Software Engineers at GM: https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/General-Motors-Software-Engineer-Salaries-E279_D_KO15,32.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/General-Motors-Software-Eng... // Software Developers (not sure about the title difference) at GM: https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/General-Motors-Software-Developer-Salaries-E279_D_KO15,33.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/General-Motors-Software-Dev...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoYes, and technical engineers are like designing in bits of platinum to the engine, its more expensive but that it what it takes to get the performance out of the product. They (the MBA types), of all people, should understand that. And I think they do, what they don't like is that given the expense and what they expect they can charge for the service, they can't figure out how to get the profit margin they want/need. It has been my experience that nothing is more frustrating to an MBA than a really killer market winning idea that happens to be unimplementable because the humans involved need to be paid to build or operate it.
- id122015 10y agoYour last paragraph seems unreal. A business person is not someone who has an MBA but someone who had a proof of running a successful business. Idnt that the same treatment CS graduates get ?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoPeople confuse credentials as having the same weight as experience, when reality couldn't be further from the truth.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThere are CS graduates that are frustrated that their perfectly good algorithm or idea takes "too much" CPU time or memory to run. And in that way they are similar. It is the notion of the 'unreasonable man' who wants something which reasonable people consider impossible.
- pjmlp 10y agoNot only that, Mr. Business from Business Factory LLC is what gives bad name to consulting with fixed size projects and zero expectations about quality, as long as, it kind of works.
- jzelinskie 10y agoThe creation of the typical Japanese "salaryman infrastructure" has prevented any kind of flexibility in their jobs market. I'd love to actually live there for a decent amount of time if it didn't mean making x5 less my salary in the US doing the same work.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoHey, I don't know if you'll appreciate my little crusade, but: It's best to use a fraction when talking about a reduction in amount, and a multiplier if you're talking about an increase. For example "one fifth my salary" would be a reduction, "5x my salary" indicates a tremendous increase. Five "times" your current salary. Carry on and Happy New Year
- mikestew 10y agoWell, I appreciate your little crusade, as the original statement was unparseable. I allow for a little ESL when I run across such things, and I get the idea, but the statement might as well have been "a lot less than I make now" for all the sense it made.
- fuayenaha 10y ago"x5 less my salary" means what you think it means. If he's making $100000 a year, he'll make x - x * 5, this is, he'll have to pay his employer $400000 a year.
- bnjms 10y agoThis is clever though by this interpretation he will make 5 times (implied) [his salary], less his salary. Totalling four times present salary. Quite some trouble.
- snovv_crash 10y agoYeah that annoyed me. I would have used 20%. The other case is when somebody uses % for something greater than unity, eg 500% instead of 5x.
- devoply 10y agoHow much you pay should be determined by the market and how much profit each person contributes the company. Instead managers have driven this figure down to the point where salaries don't in any way reflect the value being generated, and does not even match inflation. That's because the market isn't working, instead the managers are deciding and since they are all in implicit collusion with each other the market does not have the chance to actually work. The recent debacle of agreeing not to poach between the big 5 companies was explicit proof of this sort of thing occurring explicitly instead of implicitly. But it's managers who determine the pay structure not the market. And they keep on keeping it low by complaining about lack of workers. Getting H1Bs in to the country. Forcing pro immigration policies when the local population does not have job. It's all a conceited effort to diminish salaries. And they really are not affected by how it impacts their company. Company has billions sitting in the bank. As long as H/R does its job, i.e. keeping the salaries low, none of these sorts of people get fired. So they keep on. The work doesn't get done, but the CEO doesn't care. Enough profit is being generated, enough costs are being cut. Who cares if the economy has to pay for this sort of thing. It's not the people who are actually making the decisions. Small businesses depend on money from big companies paid out to employees to thrive. If they don't have it small business does not get done. But it's not as if that affects the managers making the decisions, so they keep on.
- gnopgnip 10y agoWithout all of those managers and admin and sales doing what they do the engineers wouldn't be able to generate as much value. How do you decide who is responsible for the value and how everyone should be paid? If you can do it better than it is done traditionally, start your own company and eat their lunch.
- devoply 10y ago> If you can do it better than it is done traditionally, start your own company and eat their lunch. You can't make a company do anything objectively better through these insights, though in specific cases things would get done sooner, and even if you could which company is going to listen to someone saying that they should pay their employees more. In fact lots of management "wisdom" goes exactly against that, they see their engineers as idiots manipulated by pop psychology. Not people who deserve to get wealthy. It's just that operationally they adversely affect the economy, not necessarily the company. As I said usually the companies exercising this sort of behavior are already doing well. They have plenty of profit and plenty of money in the bank. It's those size of companies that have the sort of managerial class that practices this sort of behavior. And the managerial class justifies it, and the CEO believes it, so it continues. Who pays is the economy at large, and engineers who are not becoming wealthy who continue to be wage slaves. But lots of CEOs and managers believe that this is exactly how things should be. You can't change this by starting your own company. Because then you are a CEO or a manager. And if one company pays their employees well and does well, well that changes very little. Companies are simply systems, there are many ways to run them and still be profitable.
- h1fra 10y agoSalary can't and shouldn't be compared accross the globe. Being paid 170k€ in san francisco is maybe the "normal" but few company can afford it in europe or just about anywhere else. And salary is missleading because way of life is way more expensive there. For me the claim is right, there is not enough engineers and they are all going abroad aka there is a shortage. From my perspective (paris, france) even if you would pay engineers double from now on to match US salary, there will still be a shortage for the next 10years at least.
- joe_the_user 10y agoPart of the reason for the shortage of IT talent is that companies want workers who are: 1. Intelligent 2. Talented 3. Willing to work insane hours 4. Willing to put with the companies insane crap If companies were willing to settle for 1 & 2, they could draw on a large pool of people. But 3 & 4 have become such the norm that companies wind-up with permanent shortage. And 3 & 4 are standard as part of the program which reduced the wages of shlep workers and random bureaucrats from 1980 to now everywhere so they aren't very negotiable. The standard has been to endless rounds of layoff and we loose talent or common sense, we can hire from outside. It seems like this is the result.
- metaprinter 10y ago"Salary can't and shouldn't be compared accross the globe." I disagree. If the hiring company is looking for the best candidates in the world, then they must be prepared to shell out comparable 'global' salaries.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 10y agoIt depends at which level At a "unique/very few in the world", yes, location only makes your (high) salary goes higher. But then you have 6 digits in your salary regardless if it's in $/€/£ At a "specialized position" (I guess several people on HN are here), you absolutely don't need to offer the same salary regardless of geographical position, but it has to be competitive.
- a3n 10y ago> Clearly they don't understand the market, if the other parts of the market are paying 20Million Yen for this position then that is where it "should be" and you have to figure out how to cover that cost. Or figure out how to get along without it, or with less of it. As I was reading this article, I kept wondering if cars really need all the IT/SW tech being poured into them. Maybe people wouldn't buy cars without it. Or maybe people who currently don't buy or otherwise use cars would be attracted to a simpler and cheaper solution. A safe frame, seatbelts and airbags, reliability, reasonable gas mileage and honest pollution controls, plus a good enough radio/stored music player, and a warranty. We already have all that, to a mostly excellent degree. No additional IT talent required. It seems that car manufacturers have trapped themselves into being feature whores.
- GVIrish 10y ago> It seems that car manufacturers have trapped themselves into being feature whores. That's because customers are feature whores. If there are two cars and one has a backup camera, internet connection, and an automatic transmission, people are going to buy that over a car with just a radio and a stick shift. For the vast majority of drivers, a car is an appliance and any appliance that is easier and more comfortable to operate is better to them. So when a car can park itself, call the ambulance if you crash, keep your coffee hot in heated cupholders, and tap into your cloud music account, all the better for them.
- tantalor 10y ago> customers are feature whores Yeah... or maybe because those features are now required by law: https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/u-s-requiring-back-up-cameras-in-cars-by-2018/ https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/u-s-requiring-back-up-cam...
- GVIrish 10y agoThat's a law going into the effect over a year from now. Backup cameras have been popular long before the Feds decided to mandate it. The point is that plenty of people pay extra of their own volition to have stuff like backup cameras, blindspot warnings, automatic headlights, etc.
- id122015 10y ago+1 because The companies dont want to pay that much. Very few people are exposing the truth, and even fewer go into details. Why dont companies want to pay yhe fair price ? Who are the gatekeepers or middlemen/middlewoman (- to be politically correct) ? How many jobs on the internet are duplicates ? How great developers are rejected and succeed on their on a few years later ?
- 20years 10y agoThere is no talent shortage but there is a willing to pay decent wages shortage. This entire article stinks of exactly that.
- ecnal 10y agoIf there were no talent shortage, companies wouldn't have to offer high wages to hire people. You're looking at two sides of the same coin.
- 20years 10y agoProblem is they want senior developers but only want to pay junior developer wages. There is a flood of junior developers out there that can't get jobs. These companies don't want them though. They want senior developers who don't have to work for those lower wages because they can easily make $170k on their own or elsewhere. If they really do want those senior developers then they need to pay up. Otherwise, hire junior developers and put in place a program to get them up to speed.
- segmondy 10y agoNot true, you can't base Japanese salaries on US salaries. Countries have different currencies with different buying power. Salaries are based on the local market. Even in US, we see such broad differences between CA, NY and say OH and TN.
- jjawssd 10y agoBTW If you consider white rice and noodles a meal then both will cost you $7 USD in Tokyo. However if you want to compare a meal with vegetables and meat then that will run you around $15 USD per meal.
- sidek 10y agoYou can get premade meals at 7-11 in Tokyo for much less than 7 USD.
- jjawssd 10y agoThey are 50% rice, 20% sauce, 30% other
- EliRivers 10y agoA Yoshinoya beef bowl can be had for 6 USD and is a lot more than rice and some noodles. If I didn't have to eat it all at once, I wouldn't eat anything else that day.
- automatwon 10y agoSure salaries are based on local market, but the issue is companies are pondering why the local market is having a "shortage" to begin with. You can argue people must accept local market salaries if they want to live in a certain city or lifestyle. But why not live somewhere where you are compensated 3x as much, and travel to said city, and still have money left over? It's not as if Tokyo's cost of living is 1/3rd of San Francisco. Personally, I live in San Francisco. This wouldn't be my first pick if I was "retired" / didn't work. But, being a salaryman in SV, even with the higher cost of living, provides me a higher standard of living, insofar that I can travel to other places in the world, eat / live well, and still have money leftover. The reverse wouldn't be possible if I lived in Japan with this purported 1/3rd compensation. For me, traveling as a tourist is sufficient, I don't need years long "immersion".
- merb 10y agowell I would be happy to get ~60kUSD-80kUSD a year. For me that would be a dream since I have no bachelor and no master. Guess I probably wouldn't be the biggest talent to hire and I actually would need to change my main programming language for japanse carmakers (I actually do Scala mainly and I guess they probably need more like c/c++/rust guys...) also for 170k USD I would even move out of my country and learn a new language (not programming language)...
- user5994461 10y agoWell. The salaries are for experienced people, preferably with a bachelor/master.
- merb 10y agoI doubt that there aren't many bachelor/master out there, directly after graduating (where they already get 60k) who know the same as I do. With more than 5 years of experience and working with open source projects, I think I'm already pretty experienced. I just didn't take the time to study it, which I eventually will do (at some point in the future, if I have the courage to attend a evening school)
- user5994461 10y agoEveryone think they're pretty experienced. People can't evaluate themselves, they don't know what they don't know ;)
- merb 10y agoWell I already interviewed some people and I tought wow, they didn't programmed a lot during their studies. And I actually tried to study, but it was more like 10-20% science and the rest around business, that's why I canacled it after a year. Well I know a lot of smart people already and their were pretty smart directly after their graduation, but somehow I already seen a lot of people who just graduated and have no idea what they are doing. I actually think that's the people I compared myself with and I know that this is maybe not the best idea. (I already had some people that wanted to hire me, but they wouldn't have paid me 60k (the highest was like 45k-50k or so and some didn't even written what they offer but probably not more than 45k.) or more and it would've involved moving and that's what I didn't wanted, at that time)
- stale2002 10y agoIf bread costs 100 dollars per loaf, would that fit the definition of a "bread shortage"? If 90% of the US population is unable to afford to buy food and is going to starve soon, is there a food shortage? I would think so. The literal definition of a shortage is that price is too high. Everything ALWAYS has a price.
- linkregister 10y agoIn the bread scenario, the high price was driven by the shortage. That is, there isn't enough wheat physically available to fulfill the demand. Typical wheat production ends up with a surplus, which is stored, destroyed, or sold to lower-tier markets at a large discount. I see the point you're trying to make. But the point remains that the high price of a commodity is a reflection of scarcity, not the other way around. I didn't downvote you, but I'm assuming most commenters on HN don't want to be compared to bread or other commodities.
- RealityVoid 10y agoI don't see where you disagree with the OP. You say the same thing. > But the point remains that the high price of a commodity is a reflection of scarcity, not the other way around. I really fail to see the difference between OP and your point. Can you please elaborate?
- muninn_ 10y agoPeople aren't a commodity. Bread can't collectively bargain, improve it's own flavor to increase it's value, or start it's own granary. Comparing commodities to software engineers or what have you is be it's very nature an oversimplification and isn't very useful.
- RealityVoid 10y agoI agree with this point of view and it makes a lot of sense to me. If the price is high for something, that is indicative of a shortage. I fail to see how this can be in any ways controversial. On the other hand, I can't not notice that most readers on HN are very well paid SW engineers that profit from this shortage, quite handsomely sometimes. So it's understanding that posts like this will not be received on HN, it's the public's bias showing. On the other hand, I'm an Eastern European dev that is, while well paid for my location, still 1/5 as I would be in other locations so I'm incentivized to come and compete with other high paid professionals, so maybe this post is MY bias showing.
- mrb 10y ago"I get really tired of companies saying "Talent Shortage" when they really mean "I don't want to pay that much."" I wanted to agree with you but then, by your definition, there would never be any shortages. Because with a high enough offer one would always be able to purchase anything, in spite of "shortages".