4 ms·
We should also start treating rising housing prices as a policy failure.
by maxerickson 10y ago
We should also start treating rising housing prices as a policy failure.
- bandrami 10y agoUnfortunately we taught a generation that housing was an investment platform rather than something you primarily get utility out of.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThat's been a common belief for several generations, not something that was taught to one recent generation alone.
- mywittyname 10y agoI disagree. Previous generations valued housing for its utility: it's a place to live. The land would be seen as an investment if it was used for farming. Gen-X came of age at a time where housing was viewed as an investment to make money on. The idea of buying a house with the promise of selling it later to make a profit is very modern. My great-grandparents and grandparents all owned one house and lived it in for the majority/entirety of their lives, so the value of he house was inconsequential to them. My parents and their siblings have mostly owned multiple houses. They never moved for pragmatic reasons, like relocating for a job. Instead, they took to the modern notion of "starter homes", where a family continues to move up to a better house by "using the profits" from the sale of their previous home.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Gen-X came of age at a time where housing was viewed as an investment to make money on. Yes, because the idea was established when the leading edge of the Boomer generation was young adults and became dominant fairly quickly. So, it's been a common belief for three generations that have reached adulthold. Hence, my statement in GP.
- JBlue42 10y agoUgh, "starter homes". Someone saying that about their most recent purchase usually tells me all I need to know about them. American over-idealism at its finest.
- travmatt 10y agoI've never heard that argument before but that sounds interesting - can you link me towards more writing on it?
- wil421 10y agoWhat about inflation? Why would anyone buy land if it was guaranteed to depreciate. I'd be better off renting from someone else losing money.
- maxerickson 10y agoLots of people buy vehicles that depreciate like mad because they believe the total value of the purchase exceeds the total cost. I'm not necessarily saying that prices should have significant downward trajectory. Of course desirable locations will command a premium over time and so on. But as a society we probably shouldn't be excited that housing sometimes goes up substantially, even as the stock deteriorates.
- ams6110 10y agoVehicles are a consumable, not an investment. Land is generally not, because most uses increase its value.
- maxerickson 10y agoYes, but I'm talking about housing rather than land. Most housing suffers from use and age. (Note where I conceded the point about some land having value due to location or such)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 10y ago> I'd be better off renting from someone else losing money. No, you wouldn't, because if the rental market wouldn't support recovering the full costs to the owner, no one would bother owning land and renting it. Whatever costs fall on land owners will, inevitably, be fully (and then some, usually) distributed to renters of the land.
- 10y ago
- dragonwriter 10y agosince it's usually a policy goal supported by the voting public, I don't see how it's a policy failure. Now, the fact that it is a policy goal with that kind of support may be a failure on a more fundamental level, but that's a different issue.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhat I wrote is perfectly compatible with your pedantry. "We should also start"... Obviously I didn't go on and on about it, but it is implied there that attitudes would need to change.
- dragonwriter 10y agoYou seem to have read a "No, we shouldn't, because..." into my post that wasn't there. My point was directly that it is, in fact, not a policy failure in the usual sense since it is working both as policy makers and voters intend, and, on a deeper level, that --given that people who, in fact, benefit from housing price appreciation are overrepresented among those who actually vote -- changing this is likely to require either changing who actually votes or getting people to vote against their own financial interests.
- maxerickson 10y agoI simply didn't state that it is a policy failure. I said We should also start treating rising housing prices as a policy failure. It's a prescription for what society should do, not an assessment of whether current policy aligns with voter wishes. In the comment I replied to initially, rising prices are treated as a measure of economic success. Treating them as a policy failure would contrast with that current attitude...
- dragonwriter 10y agoYes, and, as I said in GP, I'm not arguing against your point, I'm pointing out the practical difficulty in realizing the goal you have set out.
- jimlawruk 10y agoThe physical house will typically depreciate with regular use. It is the value of the "location" that can fluctuate wildly in recent years. The policy failure is allowing location values to to become so disparate and sometimes hard to predict.