3 ms·
Won't there be fear that proportional representation = BNP gets a seat?
by _delirium 17y ago
Won't there be fear that proportional representation = BNP gets a seat?
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThat's democracy. It represents the people. If you fear opposing views then you should avoid democracy. I'm not a BNP supporter by a long stretch but, if they get a significant proportion of the vote then IMO they should get representation in parliament. I actually considered not voting, our ward is a pretty much foregone conclusion, proportional representation (in preference to first-past-the-post) makes all votes count and would encourage people to vote with their conscience rather than tactically.
- _delirium 17y agoYeah, I'm not really that afraid of them either. It was more a descriptive comment, asking if, in practice, fear of fringe parties getting seats would prove to be an impediment to electoral reform. My impression is that it's been a significant issue in some countries with proportional parliamentary systems, and some (most?) have adopted variants of PR for the main purpose of keeping the fringe parties out (e.g. in Germany, you get zero seats if your total vote share is <5%, which keeps the NDP out).
- DrJokepu 17y agoIt is reasonable and practical to exclude opinions whose popularity is below some threshold from the government; otherwise the number of these insignificant opinions will make government an awful lot harder.
- thomasz 17y agoCertain Constitutions have a mandatory minimum percentage required to gain seats (5% in Germany, 10% in Turkey)
- arethuza 17y agoI would be quite happy for them to get a seat so that they have more opportunity to advertise how nasty they are.