10 ms·
Open Letter to a Car-Addicted City (2014)
- toodlebunions 10y agoThis is part of the reason many European cities are so walkable and livable, they were designed for people rather than vehicles.
- mc32 10y agoI think a couple of things have helped their cities compared to the US. Their cities developed and grew before cars became locally mass-available and our move to the city (from farms) more or less coincided with the rise and availability of cars to consumers. Especially post-wwii. Plus, in suburban Europe, you see more cars. However, in cities, which developed before cars, they have lots of public transit with the requisite higher density housing.
- stevesearer 10y agoA recent video I found to be pretty interesting covering this topic among others regarding city density and comparisons between Europe and the US: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aQSxPzafO_k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aQSxPzafO_k
- TillE 10y ago"Suburban Europe" is sort of a tricky concept. In most countries, you have the outskirts of cities, and then you have the countryside with towns and farmland. You generally need to own a car in the latter areas, though you also typically get half-decent bus service. Even in the UK I don't think there's anywhere that truly resembles American suburbia, with its vast sprawling acres of large houses and large yards where it's actually impossible to safely walk anywhere. It's a uniquely inefficient design.
- mc32 10y agoTrue, in Europe as in advanced east Asian countries, the urban rural/agrarian transition is usually more abrupt. One side of the road is development the other is fields. However, Marseilles, for example [I imagine outer London and beyond has areas exhibiting suburban detached housing tracts] do have suburbs and if you want some mobility you need an estate sedan or the like to get things done.
- aninhumer 10y agoThere are some "suburbs" in the UK, but they're much more compact than American ones, and usually still have some local shops and public transport.
- rsync 10y ago"Even in the UK I don't think there's anywhere that truly resembles American suburbia" I once visited a very new housing development in Marbella (Southern Spain) that was identical to new housing developments in San Diego. Two car attached garages, everyone had cars. It was completely American. Eerie.
- stormbrew 10y agoI think this is probably oversimplifying a bit. Most big north American cities also predate cars, even if not by much. By my understanding, many of those cities had public transportation systems in place that were outright dismantled in the drive to a car-centric urban design. So I don't think it's a matter of never having had it. It seems like we have actually regressed.
- mc32 10y agoIt does simplify it a bit, but consider that the pop for US cities ramped up after the turn of the 20th c. (in 1900 it was approx. 70% rural 30% urban, by 1940 it was 55% urban vs 45% rural) So when they grew cars were becoming more ubiquitous. We also have different land-use regs which affect how land can be used. Mass transit has to be understood in terms of how it allows spread. Buses allow people to commute rather than walk. Trolleys, cars, horses and subways do the same. Some of those trolley lines were put in place to make the new developments attractive to people who would have to work in the city center. As cars become more available fewer people opted for trolleys and they got pulled (some people believe the GM-LA deal for buses lead to the demise of all trolleys, but I think that's more wishful thinking. However, trolleys then, as today, are relatively expensive to run and investors are better off making money elsewhere.
- onlyrealcuzzo 10y agoI think the problem is less how cities were designed and more how Americans wanted (and maybe still want) to live. Los Angeles is probably the epitome of the American city designed for the car, now suffering from some of the worst traffic on the planet. And, yet, because people are finally starting to demand walkability, it's becoming walkable at an awesomely fast pace. In just the last 4 years, the West Side seems to have gone 180. It's projected to be the 11th most walkable city in the U.S. in the near future [1]--keep in mind the sheer insane size of LA. And, that's despite having been clearly planned NOT to be walkable. The will of the people is stronger than the plan. 1: http://time.com/money/2887232/the-futures-most-walkable-cities-prepare-to-be-surprised/ http://time.com/money/2887232/the-futures-most-walkable-citi...
- kirykl 10y agoLA is pretty walkable, thats part of the reason its not very drivable. Limited road capacity. It actually wasn't even designed originally for the car, it had an extensive electric rail system.
- sampo 10y ago> how Americans wanted (and maybe still want) to live In a free market economy, we should take home prices as an indication of how people want to live. The densest, most walkable city centers tend to have the most expensive homes. Manhattan being the extreme data point.
- dragonwriter 10y agoNo, we shouldn't. In a free market economy with an equal distribution of wealth and income (which is unlikely to be a sustainable state), that would make some sense, but in a free market economy with a distribution of wealth and income similar to that of our real economy, prices are at best a wealth-weighted indication of preferences. And even then, you need to be careful about whether the variable you are looking at is really the demand driver. > The densest, most walkable city centers tend to have the most expensive homes. Manhattan being the extreme data point. Alternatively, places that are attractive places to live (e.g., because of climate and access to fresh water) or to locate trade centers (e.g., because of natural ports, navigable inland waterways, etc.) tend to be high demand places to live, driving both price and density. In this view, Manhattan isn't in demand because it's dense, it's dense because it's in demand.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nickff 10y agoSpeaking as someone who is from Vancouver, it is very hard for me to see it (or cities like it) as a good example. Congestion has skyrocketed there, and many people are wasting 5-10 hours a week in traffic delays because of infrastructure which does not match citizens' needs. City planners have wreaked havoc on cities with their continual obsessions with fads; maybe they should focus on helping people get what they want instead of trying to change people.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhat percentage of the population drives in Vancouver? If only a smaller fraction of commuters are stuck in congestion the situation is probably working okay for everyone else.
- nickff 10y agoThis is a complicated question because the (rich) population in the city center generally doesn't drive much, but the average resident in the (GVRD) area drives quite a bit. I don't think many people have even argued that the traffic situation is 'working okay'.
- maxerickson 10y agoI don't think many people have even argued that the traffic situation is 'working okay'. That isn't what I said. I implied that someone riding in a train probably doesn't care much about road congestion.
- nickff 10y agoYou asked "What percentage of the population drives in Vancouver?", and another commenter replied that it is about 65%, which means it is unlikely that most people see massive congestion as 'okay'.
- wott 10y ago> This is a complicated question because the (rich) population in the city center This is a MYTH that must be ended someday. No, not only people living in most city centres are not rich, but they are even poorer than people living in the suburbs. In my country, this the case for every single city except the capital. I don't know Vancouver, but a 5 minute search of maps of densities and maps of income seem to confirm this again: centre, dense areas are the poorest. And yet, on every thread (same in US forums or at my place) about transportation, transit, housing, bicycle(!), urbanisation, whatever that relates to cities, someone (or many) will come and say that people from the centre are rich and privileged and that the suburban people are poor and that they had no other choice than to move there to survive. Truth is, except for a few slum-like suburbs, other suburbs are mostly populated by people who chose to move there to have a bit of a garden or to have bigger houses or to park their cars or to have dogs or to have a swimming pool, etc. and these people have a higher living standard.
- vdnkh 10y ago[2014] Here's the 2016 update of the "Walkscore": https://www.walkscore.com/cities-and-neighborhoods/ https://www.walkscore.com/cities-and-neighborhoods/ 1. NYC 2. San Francisco 3. Boston ... 7. Washington DC This list makes a lot more sense than the 2014 list.
- chris_va 10y agoTo me, SF does not seem particularly walkable, bike friendly, nor transit friendly (it is ranked #2 for all). It isn't terrible, but #2 in the nation?
- sqrt 10y agoI think that might speak more to the dismal state of cities in the rest of the country, rather than SF being particularly good.
- dexwiz 10y agoMy city, Indianapolis, is in the bottom 10 for all three scores. Not surprising, its in the 5th largest US capital by land [1]. Owning a car is a must. The city has great highways, but you have to use them to get anywhere. Public transit outside of main thorough fares is nonexistent, there is a single major bike path, and good luck trying to walk to a grocery store [2]. I live in the downtown area, which is fairly walkable, but its equivalent to a single neighborhood in a larger city. To get another nonresidential neighborhood, you have to drive 3-5 miles. People keep telling me Indianapolis is going to blow up, that is just on the brink of making it big time. That is only because land is so cheap. And land is only so cheap, because its so spread out. But that means the city is essentially suburbs with a few high density hubs. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_capitals_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_capitals_in_the_United... 2. http://indianapublicmedia.org/news/indianapolis-ranks-worst-nation-food-deserts-67800/ http://indianapublicmedia.org/news/indianapolis-ranks-worst-...
- acd 10y agoWhy even allow cars in the cities? The air will be cleaner without them. Have parking spaces outside the center and then automatic electric shuttle trains to transport people in. Walking and biking in the city center with lots of green areas. No cars means clean air and safe traffic. Air pollution from cars is a silent killer.
- mzw_mzw 10y agoI'm guessing it never snows where you live, and nobody ever needs to buy more than one bag of groceries at a time?
- nja 10y agonot saying the parent poster's solution would 100% work, but as an anecdote: I live in Boston. It snows here and I do often buy more than one bag of groceries at a time. Fortunately, I just walk two blocks down the street and go into one of the two grocery stores that are right there. Compare where I grew up in southern NH: it snows there, too, but the nearest grocery store was a 20 minute drive, so of course I would drive there. Rural NH is not a city, though.
- chongli 10y agoSnow is even more of a reason to get rid of cars. A car-less city with underground subways/metros and integrated residential/light commercial districts sounds like a dream. No more shovelling, no more plows, no more going outside during the cold wind! I would love to be able to go from my house to the grocery store and work and the movie theatre (or whatever else) without ever having to set foot outside. This is possible for some people in Toronto and a few other big cities (that I know of) but not the common case.
- FrancoDiaz 10y agoRemember downtown Minneapolis being like that for obvious reasons. I think a lot of people in the Minneapolis area have heated garages so essentially you can park in a garage downtown, walk around the skywalks between the downtown skyscrapers, and never have to set outside. I was only there for the Superbowl and never actually walked one, so maybe it's not so convenient.
- bgirard 10y agoI recall in ~2009 my university (UWaterloo) had a referendum to increase tuition by $50/term (now $80/term) to increase city bus routes to the university and provide free service to students using your student card. I voted against it because I could easily carpool and was against another mandatory fee. The vote was fairly controversial and passed by a narrow margin. But since the service was improved to every 15 minutes and I was already paying for it I started using the service and shortly stopped driving to school altogether. By the time I graduated I really loved the system since it really improved my commute and really regretted voting against it. I just checked and now the approval is at 94% for the UPass.
- m_mueller 10y agoThis is the dilemma in a car society - whenever you ask people what they want, it's more roads and parking spaces. People can't even imagine how a good public transit can improve their lifes, including that of the remaining road users. I think the solution is just for everyone to visit a place with a good public transit network and live there for a few months - in the US I can only think of New York. Exchange student programs should be mandated anyways, to mend the cultural gaps within the nation.
- brianwawok 10y agoMy parents would say the trains are dirty and shake their head. So hard to get people in the US to like public transit :(
- dexwiz 10y agoBecause trains are dirty in the US. Go to Vienna, ride a train, and then go to San Francisco, and ride BART. Its night and day. Vienna had clean trains with a smooth ride. BART seems to always be dirty, and the cars screech like banshees. Its a vicious cycle. No one wants to fund trains, so they fall into disrepair. The then get a bad rap about being in disrepair, so no one wants to fund them. If you want a real villain, blame the oil companies that bought up local trains and dismantled them in the first half of the century.
- colinshark 10y agoThe car of the future fixes many of the problems, and it fits right into existing infrastructure. Think autonomous electric single/dual occupant taxis (2+ per lane). We are still a ways off, but this is where things are headed. We might not need the parking, but the roads will be useful.
- hrktb 10y agoThis piece is centered on congestion and moving from a place to another, but the discussion on how to manage cars in a city extend beyond that 'moving' part. Roads are also the target of a lot of rethinking, and the model where whole blocks of the city are completely closed to motorized circulation got traction in a few big cities already.
- marcoperaza 10y agoA car gives you privacy and freedom that trains and buses cannot. It's your space that you control; you're not forced to share it with strangers. You control the music, the temperature, and the route you take. You talk on the phone about whatever you want without worrying about being overheard. You can fill your trunk with a cart-full of groceries and drive it home. When you want to get somewhere, you can immediately get on your way. No train schedules, and no late buses. You drive home every day to your reasonably priced house, an appreciating asset that you own and that comfortably fits you, your spouse, and children. There's a reason why even in dense cities with great public transit and walkable neighborhoods, the rich choose to be driven everywhere.
- estebank 10y ago> There's a reason why even in dense cities with great public transit and walkable neighborhoods, the rich choose to be driven everywhere. I don't think that is true of every dense city with great public transit[1]. [1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=tube+london+picture+celebrity https://www.google.com/search?q=tube+london+picture+celebrit...
- dodders 10y agoAgreed. Lots of rich people ride the subway in NYC too: http://gothamist.com/2015/12/31/best_subway_celebrity_sightings.php http://gothamist.com/2015/12/31/best_subway_celebrity_sighti... https://www.thrillist.com/entertainment/new-york/celebrity-photos-mta-subway-bus-new-york-city https://www.thrillist.com/entertainment/new-york/celebrity-p...
- hrktb 10y agoI have the feeling you live in a place where cars are privileged and where the whole environment might have been built with the car in mind. In places that kept a historic center, or built themselves around walkable commercial areas, cars are just liabilities that you'll spend time and money to park, get frustrated to no limit by the congestions, slow paced traffic, overall polluted air, and cramped one way streets that you have no idea how to navigate without a car navi. IMO it's really a matter of context and how the city works. You'll want to adapt depending on that.
- andrewmutz 10y agoIf I were making decisions in a city that was currently car-centric, I would wait until the effects of self-driving cars are better understood before making dramatic changes. If we get fleets of on-demand self driving cars in cities that are currently car-centric, many of the disadvantages of car transportation will be ameliorated. A 45 minute commute by car is no fun, but when the car is able to drive itself and you've got high speed wireless data access, it probably won't be so bad.
- sampo 10y agoIf a self-driving car makes driving more palatable, people will buy homes behind even longer commutes, and you get even more traffic (more miles driven per day). The throughput capacity of a road (cars per hour) will not improve much, so they may even make congestion worse.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThat's my concern too. In LA and DC there are plenty of people who have 90 minutes commute each way. With autonomous cars this is much less painful so people may move even further away from work.
- andrewmutz 10y agoI think it's too early to be sure of the effects. A widely available fleet of self-driving cars may help the last-mile problem with public transportation (how do you get from, say, the subway station to your workplace or from the subway station to your house). If this makes public transportation easier, this may decrease miles driven per day. Will self-driving cars reduce the accident rate, and the congestion that results from traffic slowdowns near accidents? Will self-driving cars make better use of less obvious travel routes and avoid bottlenecks in the road network?
- wott 10y agoYes, that's also a common problem with infrastructures (be they road or public transit): each time you spend millions (or billions) building/improving them, people go farther, keeping more or less the same commuting time (and keeping complaining about it), thus you then have 2 new problems instead of 1: the congestion happens farther on areas/lines you haven't treated yet, and soon it also accumulates on the sections you have just treated because new traffic from remote places ends up gathering there, making them as congested as they were before you spent m/billions on them...
- Tade0 10y agoI have an idea: stop making people commute to work. Half of the folk who hop in their cars every morning to spend two hours in traffic have no business going anywhere - their line of work doesn't require them to be in any specific place.
- paulsutter 10y agoSelf driving buses will be smaller, more flexible, and less of a hindrance to traffic than current buses, because there will be no need to amortize the cost of a driver over so many passengers. Self driving cars will reduce the cost of Uber-like services as well, and lower the cost of tunneling (self driving cars will mean higher capacity and smaller shoulders and lanes, and electric cars will mean less ventilation required). Going underground is the best way to increase travel speeds and reduce friction between pedestrians and vehicles. Cities should look more like Venice.
- Smaug123 10y agoVenice is sinking and floods regularly, by the way.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoPosted this on an Uber tread the other day: I live in New York, frequently travel to suburbs around the country and world, and have not missed for a second the driver's license I gave up almost 5 years ago. It's not always seamless, but neither is driving. A shockingly good trade, already, and one that will only get better as cars drive themselves.
- Tempest1981 10y agoAlthough taking Uber isn't any different than having your own car -- as far as highways being over-capacity. Uber may save on parking density, but not traffic density. http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/San-Francisco-traffic-Uber-Lyft-SFMTA-blame-10791265.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/San-Francisco-traffic-... (Maybe your argument is that you normally walk/bike/train, and use Uber for rare special situations?)
- bostonvaulter2 10y agoAlthough not having a car makes one more likely to use public transit, even if you take uber most of the time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- innocentoldguy 10y agoI think the reason many people refuse use public transit, me included, is because it is costly, the service sucks, and it takes twice as long to get anywhere. The foul smell and filthy conditions that too often accompany the public transportation experience aren't good selling-points either. Where I currently live, the high-speed commuter trains, which only stop at a handful of hubs, come every 30 minutes during the morning and evening rushes, and then once an hour outside of those times. Even then, sometimes the train goes all the way to my destination, but other times, it stops and goes out of service half-way there, so I end up having to wait for 30 minutes for the next train. Regular trains, that stop at every station, arrive every 15 minutes, and are NOT coordinated, meaning that instead of being able to transfer by jumping off one train and walking across the platform to get on another, or waiting just a minute or two, I end up standing around for 12 minutes for the transfer train to arrive. In my case, I can drive to work in 40 to 50 minutes in heavy traffic, or I can take the train and get there in an hour and a half each way. Furthermore, rail passes are a joke where I live. They don't sell a pass for just the commuter train, or just between two commuting points. Instead, you have to buy the premium pass, which includes bus, train, and commuter rail services to everywhere the transit authority goes. I don't need that! A monthly commuter rail pass costs $198.00. I drive a Toyota Avalon Hybrid, and a rail pass ends up costing me about $100 more a month that I spend on gas. If we want to make public transit attractive, it has to be cheaper and faster than driving, otherwise nobody with an ounce of economic sense will do it. I lived in Japan for a number of years, and the train system there is one of the best in the world. It is cheaper and faster to use the trains there, so most people do. I never wanted to own a car while I lived in Japan. In their society, especially in big cities, it is cars that don't make economic sense. This is what must take place for a public transit society to exist in America, in my opinion. We can't provide an abysmal experience for riders, and expect anything to change.
- ryandrake 10y ago> If we want to make public transit attractive, it has to be cheaper and faster than driving, otherwise nobody with an ounce of economic sense will do it. Hell, I would take either one of those--cheaper OR faster. Where I live and work, public transit is neither of those.