4 ms·
I don't see the big deal with this. Building a command system on top of a general purpose operating system seems like a reasonable cost-saving decision. It has
by foldr 10y ago
I don't see the big deal with this.
Building a command system on top of a general purpose operating system seems like a reasonable cost-saving decision. It has attendant risks, but so do all of the alternatives.
Security issues are moot, I would have thought, since these systems are not connected to the internet, and the main threat is from people who have physical access to the hardware.
- origami777 10y agoI would have thought the same until stuxnet. Otners know the story better than I but if memory serves, the Iranian nuclear facilities had systems that were not connected to the internet compromised. No internet connection for sure reduces the risk, but for those looking to compromise a sub I don't think it's an insurmountable roadblock.
- foldr 10y agoRight, but my point is that if you have physical access, then the security holes in Windows XP, as compared to more modern iterations of Windows, aren't so relevant. It's not like the sub is going to be compromised via a bug in IE 6. I also sort of suspect (without making any pretence of knowing what I'm talking about) that it's futile to try to make the computer system itself invulnerable to attack, and that human factors are likely to have a far greater influence on the overall security of the system. After all, Stuxnet was propagated via flash drives, and no-one should be sticking a random flash drive in a military submarine's computer systems.
- cryptarch 10y agoI don't recall any *nix OS's having automount and autorun enabled by default? What I'm trying to say is, physical access does not necessarily mean full physical access, and when the virus has to spread through some storage medium connected to e.g. USB the underlying OS certainly matters. I mean, they probably autorun that for the subs, but I think its indicative of the design philosophy behind most MS products. "Made for those who don't need full control, with politics prioritized over security", because what security-minded programmer would ever enable that by default? Edit: inserted middle paragraph + fixed typo
- izacus 10y agoWait, do you really think that embedded Windows versions behave the same as end-user ones?! That's like saying "Linux sucks for embedded devices because Ubuntu automatically updates kernel and breaks stuff".
- ktRolster 10y agoWait, do you really think that embedded Windows versions behave the same as end-user ones?! Typically they're worse, in my experience. Harder to work with, easier to make mistakes.
- avian 10y ago> Wait, do you really think that embedded Windows versions behave the same as end-user ones?! After having to install anti-virus software on an 100k+ EUR oscilloscope, yes. Yes, they do behave the same as end-user ones.
- foldr 10y agoYou have no idea whether this is true in the case of British nuclear submarines, though.
- pjc50 10y agoPoint-of-sale Windows dev checking in: yes, mostly they do behave the same. Especially the "embedded" ones, which are desktop versions with different licensing, a few management features, special bits of userland (e.g. the OPOS subsystem) and, most crucially, longer support life. "Compact" versions (CE, or "embedded compact") genuinely have removed features, but CE will still automount devices if it has drivers for them and you've not turned it off.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoIs that CE Windows CE, which is a completely different operating system designed for less powerful devices?
- 10y ago
- tw04 10y agoDo you honestly think a state actor doesn't have Linux zero days coming out of their ears? You're talking about a government entity that created stuxnet by stealing driver signing certificates. Linux would provide exactly 0 additional protection over embedded Windows if China or the US decides they want what you've got.
- mfukar 10y ago> since these systems are not connected to the internet, Brave, brave assumption.
- FreezerburnV 10y agoAs someone who actually worked on software for submarines, I can attest to all the machines not being connected to the internet. I had to have a separate laptop with me at all times so I could do google searches. Not that I needed to do that most of the time, considering the level of proprietary libraries being used on machinss that didn't behave like any OS you've seen before...
- mfukar 10y agoI was hinting more to the assumption that the internet is the only way to expose such systems.
- foldr 10y agoIt's not, but I see no reason to think that Windows XP is going to be more vulnerable to other kinds of attacks than any other OS.
- FreezerburnV 10y agoExpose them to what? All the computers I developed on were generally supposed to replicate the hardware on the sub itself. Everything is self-contained on a sub. (maybe they have Ethernet going between computers, and never wifi because that could generate findable "noise" by sensors in ships or other subs, but not to the internet at large) This is by necessity as subs don't get access to the internet when they're underwater for 6-9 months or so, except in VERY limited cases where they can connect to a satellite for a very brief period of time and get something like 1kb of download.