8 ms·
I'm becoming scared of Facebook
- _red 10y agoMany people have some sort of mental disorder that forces them to disclose confidential information to unrelated 3rd parties....then bizarrely when they discover that others know this information, they complain about it. Why do you need facebook? What is the compulsion to include Zuckerberg in all your private conversations?
- the8472 10y agoProbably the same reason people entrusted their private conversations to POTS for a much longer time than facebook existed.
- cryptarch 10y agoPOTS?
- astrodust 10y agoTapping POTS phones was hilariously easy. There was also an even easier time when anyone with a 47MHz tuner could hear people read out credit card numbers over the air with their cordless phones. It would happen at least once an hour in any busy neighborhood.
- tyingq 10y agoThe pre-cdma and pre-gsm AMPS cell phones were pretty easy to eavesdrop on as well. https://www.wired.com/1993/04/phreaks/ https://www.wired.com/1993/04/phreaks/ Ctrl-F and search for OKI 900. A normal commercial cell phone, but usable as a cell phone conversation scanner, out of the box.
- emersonrsantos 10y ago> The pre-cdma and pre-gsm AMPS cell phones were pretty easy to eavesdrop on as well. While waiting in the car for someone, my friend changed his Motorola StarTac to engineering mode and then proceeded to search channels until finding something interesting to listen.
- astrodust 10y agoNot only was there various test modes for handsets, but older tuners would easily access the bands used for analog cellular communication. These bands used to be used for UFH range used for analog television until those upper channels were trimmed to make way for cellular. I'm sure someone with criminal intent could have made a small fortune skimming credit card numbers off the open air.
- doctorshady 10y agoBut from an architectural standpoint, unencrypted data over an analog pair or over a TDM (basically, time multiplexed serial PCM streams; what the phone network uses for internal transport) network is probably better off than ethernet, seeing as anybody can say they're your MAC address even if they're not physically connected to your circuit.
- wheelerwj 10y agothat wasnt being mined or used to target ads the same way facebook is.
- mustacheemperor 10y agoI think many people don't adequately realize how much data they're disclosing, or how it will be used. It can be a surprise that you're "including Zuckerberg" in private, verbal, face to face conversations just because your phone on the table has the Facebook app on it.
- wheelerwj 10y agocalling this a mental disorder is an egregious belittling of actual mental disorders and a gross miscalculation of what it is needed to solve the problem. most people using facebook are simply uneducated non-technical consumers. they barely comprehend that this "personal" data exists, let alone that its mined and actively exploited. most people don't understand what they are handing over or how its goong to be used. you would have to use terminology equating it to psychological warfare to get an appropriate response.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 10y agoFacebook is one of those Internet phenomenons that make me feel like I'm getting old. I truly don't understand the product, and why people feel the need to not only use it, but also donate so much sensitive personal information to it. I'm pretty sure that with the amount of sensitive data that the average Facebook user contributes VOLUNTARILY to their accounts, I could easily take out a loan in their name and answer most of their password reset questions correctly. All so they can self-promote all day (or whatever it is they get out of FB). Mind boggling.
- dontJudge 10y ago> have some sort of mental disorder. I'd step off that high horse. I bet you use a credit card on the regular. All your purchases permanently recorded. And can be looked up on demand. I bet you talk on a phone everyday. Every convo permanently saved and can be brought up on demand. Your face-to-face conversations can be listened to even when you turn off your phone, although that does not happen passively. I bet you use the internet in such away that identifies yourself. Having your porn preferences permanently saved so they can be brought up on demand. I bet you use google search. Everything you ever looked for permanently saved and can be brought up on demand. I bet you use gmail, or some other email service. Almost everyone gives up freedom for convenience. Unless you're living like a medieval monk you're just as mentally disordered.
- supernintendo 10y agoI deleted my Facebook account years ago. Don't miss it one bit.
- askafriend 10y agoI swear this exact text shows up in every conversation about Facebook wether it's related to the story at hand or not. It's almost like a meme at this point. Look we get it OP, but stating that by itself doesn't drive the conversation forward in a meaningful way.
- quirkafleeg 10y agoIs it even possible to delete a FB account? I know someone who deletes their FB all the time. Every time they log in there it is again. Unless, if you don't log in after X months/centuries it's completely removed, but I don't see why FB would do that. Apparently, according to what I've read here, even people without FB accounts have FB accounts (shadow profiles).
- SallySwanSmith 10y agoThey're deactivating their account: https://www.facebook.com/help/214376678584711 https://www.facebook.com/help/214376678584711 this is vastly differently then deleting the account: https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674 https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674 The delete can take up to 90 days to remove all traces, but it is gone and will not allow logins when the process starts.
- Clubber 10y agoHow about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because the likelihood the FB willingly gives any and all information, conversations, public or private to the government without a whistle of a fight. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because employers started looking up people's accounts, forcing people to friend them as a condition for employment. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because it's incredible foolish to have your real name and any personal details on the internet for public consumption. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because there isn't any meaningful conversation on there anyway and most people are just posing for the camera. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because some crazy friend of a friend passes masses of ridiculous propaganda all day long. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because it allows people to tag my name in photos they took that I don't want publicly available. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because I don't particularly want to be a product. How about I deleted my Facebook account years ago because I don't particularly care for Zuckerberg. I could go on and on.
- cryptarch 10y agoAre there any organizations that try to peddle these concepts to the masses? Just basic things like "there's no such thing as privacy when you're on the internet", and "Facebook owns all your private chats and exploits them to coerce you to click ads and use more Facebook".
- amiga-workbench 10y agoThis all used to be common sense and was drilled into people when the web was new, along with "when online, never share your real name or location with anybody, always use a pseudonym." Roll on 2016 and people are pouring every personal detail into the web, what the fuck happened?
- gruez 10y ago"social networks" happened
- alphabettsy 10y agoYep. People think they're sharing with their "friends" because you get to choose by accepting people and don't seem to fully understand they're handing it over to a megacorp and their data hoarding buddies.
- nxc18 10y agoDepending on a pseudonym for anonymity is dangerous... It would be better to adopt a real-name policy and consciously remember to only take actions that you don't mind being associated with your real identity forever and always. When you depend on fake names, it only takes a sentence (or possibly less) to permanently shatter the lie and associate all those actions you thought were private with your real identity. This is less applicable with things like Facebook tracking ads and Google searches, but in that case, a good approach is separating browsers/devices.
- morgante 10y agoAgreed. That's exactly why my username everywhere is my real name (morgante). I'm under no illusion that anything I say online is anonymous.
- 467568985476 10y agoI'm having a hard time believing anything substantial from the linked thread. It seems like an obvious example of confirmation bias and frequency illusion. If anyone has some data or a "smoking gun" so to speak, I'm all ears. As it stand now though, I don't really care for another iteration of all the people who don't use facebook gloating about it and intentionally failing to understand the value it provides for its users.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoI can't believe people legitimately think Facebook is spying on them through microphones. There's so much that's more likely to be happening I can't fathom why they just default to assuming that and it only serves to make the conversation seem crazy to anyone with a hint of rationality. Here's a more likely scenario that is scary in its own right: I have a private conversation with John Doe. John Google's it and ends up on a page with the Facebook tracking pixel. Google knows John and I know each other, knows John and I were in the same place and knows John googled something not long after or while we were in the same place. Facebook doesn't know we talked about it but it can make a guess. Worst case is they show me an ad without much context like dozens of other ads I ignore every single day. That kind of profiling is what we should be talking about because it doesn't take much to figure out who's talking to who about what when you have information about their every move and page load.
- c0nducktr 10y agoI can definitely believe that people think Facebook is spying on them through their microphone, because it's the most obvious answer. Most people don't know anything about how tracking works and how Facebook tailor ads to you, but everyone knows how a microphone works. I realize that this was posted on the technology subreddit, but that subreddit reaches an extremely wide audience, most of which certainly doesn't know all the ins-and-outs of the tracking/advertising business.
- tedunangst 10y agoIs it the most obvious answer? 20 years ago, I drank a glass of milk and watched the X Files, and then there was an advertisement for milk. Is the most obvious answer that my TV was watching me?
- c0nducktr 10y agoWell, maybe 'obvious' is the wrong term, but there's something different between drinking a glass of milk and seeing a milk ad, and pointing out an Arcadia in a parking lot and telling your friend you liked the car, and then just later that night getting an ad for "2017 GMC Arcadia - Low Financing". The precision is what makes it seem weird, and without an understanding of how a company would target ads to you, the idea that you're being literally listened to by the app, seems possible.
- rl3 10y ago>Facebook is advertising products to me based on conversations I've had in bars ... Is there any evidence that Facebook surreptitiously listens to conversations? I could see mining the ambient content of any Facebook video/VOIP sessions, but beyond that I can't see it being true. Facebook location services can be genuinely creepy though. Earlier this year I enabled location services on the app (while keeping location history disabled), and it would suggest anyone in my phone's proximity using Facebook. It even suggested the attendants at my local gas station, and nurses at my doctor's office. Neighbors too, but only the ones in the same building (~75ft). I suspect this was due to my friends list numbering in the single digits at the time, since I'd otherwise neglected Facebook since its inception. Then, I took a brief vacation and added a bunch of new people. The creepy location telepathy suddenly vanished. Ever since, all it's been suggesting is acquaintances of said people, despite the fact I live thousands of miles away with location services enabled 24/7. So, I guess Facebook can be as dumb as it is smart sometimes. The notion of a private investigator (or psychotic stalker) buying a cheap smartphone, installing FB on it with a clean account, enabling location services, muting it, attaching an external battery and dumping it in a bush somewhere unfortunately seems feasible. It strikes me as a good experiment for a security researcher to conduct.
- matt4077 10y agoHe must be spending time in awfully boring bars if Facebook can do speech-to-text on sound captured while his phone is in his pocket.
- k_bx 10y agoVoice is pretty good target for being separated from everything else. My "ok google" recognizes my voice pretty good even if loud music is playing, for example.
- bpchaps 10y agoSurreptitiously, not really. Obscurely? Kinda: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13252761 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13252761 It wouldn't surprise me if they had some decent fudging to match most conversations to TV quotes. I'll be taking off my tinfoil hat now.
- avenoir 10y ago> Yes. Facebook uses a trick to keep running in the background on your phone. At least on iOS, most apps aren't able to run background processes constantly. One of the exceptions is apps that play music, so Facebook plays a silent audio clip in the background so it can stay running. Interesting, according to this [1] article, Facebook claimed that running silent audio on a phone was a bug. That's one heck of an interesting bug. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2015/10/22/facebook-says-it-fixed-a-bug-that-caused-silent-audio-to-vampire-your-iphone-battery/ https://techcrunch.com/2015/10/22/facebook-says-it-fixed-a-b...
- haikuginger 10y agoI don't think it's that interesting. My guess is it was a glitch with the logic that autoplays videos silently while you scroll through the feed.
- alphabettsy 10y agoA glitch? I'm pretty sure they use location changes to notify the app just like Dropbox does for Auto Photo backup, but either way it's no glitch, audio doesn't even play unless you tap the video unless I'm mistaken.
- haikuginger 10y agoSure. But the audio has to be ready to play from one of any number of videos immediately that are already playing silently. My guess at architecture is that Facebook grabs audio device priority ahead of time and starts playing silent audio so that they can use their own logic to splice in the audio stream of any tapped video immediately when tapped, rather than first needing to acquire audio device priority. Twitter had something similar for a while; if you were listening to music, then if you scrolled through your timeline and came across an autoplay video (which would play silently at first), your music would stop. They were preemptively grabbing exclusive audio mode in anticipation of needing it for the video, and then playing silence through it until you tapped on the video itself.
- thebiglebrewski 10y agoThis literally just happened to me. I was having a conversation with my girlfriend and then opened facebook and saw a status about the exact thing we were talking about. Is it possible to know if this is happening on an android phone? I'd love to eliminate the possibility it is happening...
- vinchuco 10y agoI don't have facebook and with an Android phone I had a similar creepily tailored advertising experience (google?) Fun additional: a family member using facebook, when I had one, was getting ads of Amazon products I had recently watched
- Falling3 10y agoJust a status? Any reason to think it was anything other than a coincidence?
- thebiglebrewski 10y agoIt was really, really uncannily related to what we'd been talking about and a friend that I don't see updates from that often.
- SallySwanSmith 10y agoDo you think your Friend was coerced into making the status update? Or do you think the status update was faked by facebook?
- Falling3 10y agoAs the sibling comment pointed out, the most unlikely aspects of the situation are that your friend posted on the topic and that the post coincided in time with your conversation. I'd say the fact that Facebook decided to show it to you at that point is the least unlikely part of the story.
- sasas 10y agoThere is a name for this cognitive bias - 'Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon' or 'Frequency illusion'. "The illusion in which a word, a name, or other thing that has recently come to one's attention suddenly seems to appear with improbable frequency shortly afterwards" [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases#Frequency_illusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases#Frequ...
- anondon 10y agoOr, that reddit post was a place where everyone who experienced something similar shared what has already happened.
- rubyfan 10y agoIs that like after you start looking to buy a car and you now see the same model like 100 times in a day and you previously never noticed seeing it ever?
- vinchuco 10y agoThere is a name for this cognitive bias - 'Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon' or 'Frequency illusion'. "The illusion in which a word, a name, or other thing that has recently come to one's attention suddenly seems to appear with improbable frequency shortly afterwards" [1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases#Frequency_illusion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases#Fre...
- sasas 10y agoPlease do not plagiarise people's comments.
- gkya 10y agoIt seems to be a la mode to post a bias or a syndrome for everything. The effects the post refers to are possible and possibly real, only the mediums described seem to be wrong. Heck, I bought a couple of boxers a week ago online, now the whole internet is NSFW for me, all the ads are male and female underwear, including Google ads. I'm quite tech-literate and have a rough grasp of how ads work and how to get rid of them, but a normal user is just perplexed and confused, and all he can think of is the big brother.
- iamben 10y agoClick the arrow in the top right corner of the ad and click "why am I seeing this ad". Usually the targeting explains it pretty well.
- rubyfan 10y agoSo I have noticed FB recommend people that all attended the same party that I have no previous relationship to. It was more people than I'd assume would look me up or be able to spell my name, so quite weird. I didn't assume a mic situation, I assumed the app can read SSIDs or something similar. I don't allow FB to use location services, so either they buy my location from Waze and link it back to my FB ID somehow or the SSID thing. I could see it being technically feasible to sample audio on multiple devices to see who's in the same location, something like Shazam and less for actual content analysis. Nonetheless it is scary. Imagine you were gay in 95% of the countries in the world. Or Muslim in the US. Or Palestinian in Israel. Or Uyghur in China. Just being in the same vicinity as others in your community establishes a network ready to catalog and analyze. It's more than FB though.
- morgante 10y ago> So I have noticed FB recommend people that all attended the same party that I have no previous relationship to. You probably knew some people at the party though, and some of them had location services on. It's really not hard to guess that you were at a party.
- rubyfan 10y agoInteresting, you think there is something at FB to detect an event like that? It's true we all knew our host but it was one of those worlds collide parties where he had invited friends, neighbors, old friends from high school, some work friends, etc.
- morgante 10y agoI will pay $1,000 to anyone who is able to provide conclusive evidence of Facebook targeting advertising based on listening to all conversations. It's an easily testable hypothesis which is blatantly false. If Facebook had an always-on phone recording, people's data limits would be swiftly used up. There are tons of alternative explanations.
- Clubber 10y ago>If Facebook had an always-on phone recording, people's data limits would be swiftly used up. Not if they were converted to text with the phone before they were sent.
- morgante 10y agoEven text would involve a vastly higher upload amount than Facebook actually uses at-rest.
- Clubber 10y agoText is pretty small. It's even a multitude smaller when compressed. It could easily be added to normal send packets without anyone noticing. Furthermore, when things are encrypted, it distorts the actual size of the message. I mean I came up with a way to do it unnoticed in a few minutes, imagine what a top team could come up with in a few months. I obviously don't know if it's happening or not (deleted my account years ago) but it isn't hard.
- morgante 10y agoPerhaps, but I've monitored the volume of data uploads by the Facebook app and they're pretty minimal. There's also the fact that Facebook has gone on the record specifically disavowing this conspiracy. If it were true, they wouldn't so unequivocally deny it. [0] There's far more harm for them deceiving customers than there is in them admitting to a creepy feature. Additionally, everyone who has promulgated this conspiracy has been fairly suspect. None of them make any effort to analyze the alternative reasons. But, like I said, I have $1,000 for whoever can prove this is happening. It really shouldn't be hard. If this conspiracy works the way people claim it does, you should be able to mutter about any random product to your phone and have Facebook start showing you ads for it. [0] http://www.theverge.com/2016/6/3/11854860/facebook-smartphone-listening-eavesdrop-microphone-denial http://www.theverge.com/2016/6/3/11854860/facebook-smartphon...
- foxfired 10y agoThis is the feature that is where it all started[1] > If you don’t turn it on, we won’t use your microphone to try and match TV or music when you write a status update. If you do choose to turn it on and later decide it’s not for you, you can easily turn it off at any time. > Fact: Nope, no matter how interesting your conversation, this feature does not store sound or recordings. Facebook isn’t listening to or storing your conversations. > Here’s how it works: if you choose to turn the feature on, when you write a status update, the app converts any sound into an audio fingerprint on your phone. This fingerprint is sent to our servers to try and match it against our database of audio and TV fingerprints. By design, we do not store fingerprints from your device for any amount of time. And in any event, the fingerprints can’t be reversed into the original audio because they don’t contain enough information. The app does fingerprint the audio and send it to their server to match a movie or audio. But they say they don't save it. [1]: http://newsroom.fb.com/news/2014/05/a-new-optional-way-to-share-and-discover-music-tv-and-movies/ http://newsroom.fb.com/news/2014/05/a-new-optional-way-to-sh...
- foxfired 10y agoQuick note, now that I reread what I quoted, I noticed how they say they do not store sound or recordings. But what if it is converted to text? Notice below they say that the fingerprint cannot be reversed into the original audio because it doesn't contain enough information. Text cannot be converted to the ORIGINAL audio but it can be converted to audio. This may be just me being paranoid, but I do know that legalese is designed exactly to say something without saying everything. Anyway.
- fencepost 10y agoHuh, that would raise the interesting question of whether it's also able to "fingerprint" individual spoken words if they're distinctive enough. Admittedly this is probablymaybeperhaps only happening while you're writing a status update, but even so it's not that unlikely that some words/brands could be recognizable. After all, low-impact recognition of specific phrases is the core of a variety of things - "OK Google," "Hey Siri," "Hey Cortana"
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoWhy don't people just use the mobile site in their browser? The passwords should be saved in your phone's keychain, and phone screen sizes are plenty big enough to use efficiently these days.
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoLots of people here saying Facebook probably isn't spying on your conversations are missing the point. I suspect many people finding excuses to exonerate a service they're addicted to. The fact of the matter is that you should be scared of Facebook, because Facebook is fucking scary. Facebook is a horrifying company. It's the largest and most personal and invasive tracking engine on the net, more so even than Google. They know everything about you. Facebook is tracking and making available to advertisers everything from your employer to your political affiliations to your ethnicity to your charitable donations to your credit [1]. Facebook is (illegally) now combining your WhatsApp information with your Facebook profile [2]. Facebook once collected the unsubmitted status updates you typed and decided against submitting [3]. They track when you are asleep [4]. You already know that Facebook has trained a neural network to identify your face. Facebook engages in censorship on a regular and systematic basis, against journalists and political activists, and regular users too. Even when they aren't censoring explicitly they're building a filter bubble around you that is polarizing our population to extremes. What happens when they get hacked, badly? Even big companies get hacked and have their databases dumped. Are you really comfortable with everything they know about you being made public? What happens if government actors get access to this data? What makes you think they don't already have it? I saw a stiff give a talk at HOPE who mentioned that they have an FBI agent staffed full-time at Facebook HQ. You should be scared of Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674 https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674 [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2016/08/19/98-personal-data-points-that-facebook-uses-to-target-ads-to-you/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2016/08... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/aug/25/whatsapp-backlash-facebook-data-privacy-users https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/aug/25/whatsapp-... [3] http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/12/facebook-collects-conducts-research-on-status-updates-you-never-post/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/12/facebook-collects-co... [4] http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/12/facebook-collects-conducts-research-on-status-updates-you-never-post/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/12/facebook-collects-co...
- Animats 10y agoI'm more worried about Amazon Echo, which really is listening all the time. "The more you use Dot, the more it adapts to your speech patterns, vocabulary, and personal preferences. And because Echo Dot is always connected, updates are delivered automatically." "Always getting smarter and adding new features". Some toys listen, too. Toys-R-U pulled "My Friend Cayla" from sale due to complaints from a watchdog organization.[1] "Most devices aren’t recording continuously, and won’t start recording unless activated. You know, a lot of the stuff in the future might get a little more fuzzy.” [1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/smart-devices-amazon-echo-google-home-my-friend-cayla-security-privacy/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/smart-devices-amazon-echo-google...
- edblarney 10y agoThis is the scariest of all. * Anything you say in your home is the property of Google/Amazon * You have sex with your wife? The sounds you make are their property. Say something politically incorrect? Amazon/FB might not use it against you, but they might have the data stored and others can. I really can't believe allow this stuff in their homes. FB/G etc. are too big to do directly nefarious things like 'use the mic on your smartphone' without your permission, it would blow up on them ... but to do it with your permission? It's crazy.
- fencepost 10y agoKeep an eye on Ars Technica in the next week or two, and also take a look at this article: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/12/police-ask-alexa-did-you-witness-a-murder/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/12/police-ask-alexa-... TL;DR: The Echo uploads audio for cloud-based recognition when it detects voices, but it's not clear if or how long Amazon keeps that. The Echo also has its internal audio buffer which is used for that detection, and in this case the police were looking for any audio that might have been retained in that buffer in the time period before the device was disconnected during the investigation.
- owly 10y agoDelete FB. At least mobile. Your brain will thank you.
- cyberferret 10y agoHmmm. As crazy as it sounds, I've been freaked out by this recently too. I recently had to get glasses due to degraded eyesight. I never posted anything about it on social media because quite frankly i was embarrassed by it. Never did any searches etc. Just went to my optometrist, did the test and got my glasses. Whenever friends see me working, or out and about (where i usually have my phone with me), they usually comment "oh, you have glasses now!" Or something equivalent. I usually respond with a light hearted "oh yeah, i am going blind these days" or something along those lines. Well dang - my Facebook feed is full of ads for optometrists and lasik surgery etc. these days! Let me reiterate, i have never mentioned my affliction on any social media channels, nor done a search for anything related to my failing vision. The coincidence is spooky.
- brandon272 10y agoI have always seen ads for glasses. Didn't actually notice them until I actually got my first pair.
- err4nt 10y agoMicrophone could be one possiility, what about additional knowledge from GPS (knowing you're at a location people have checked in on Facebook as being at the optometrist/glasses store, as well as being in locations where people post about such things without checking in. With as many different users doing as many different actions as Facebook can see, it wouldnt take much to piece it together.