6 ms·
An article very much on the same line as the author's book (and recent movie) on "Command and Control". A very good read by the way. On a side note, the title i
by ekianjo 10y ago
An article very much on the same line as the author's book (and recent movie) on "Command and Control". A very good read by the way. On a side note, the title is poorly chosen - if a nuclear exchange occurs, it's not World War III, it's just "game over" for everyone. Even the few survivors would have a very harsh time just to endure the nuclear winters, lack of energy, no medical supplies and complete destruction of infrastructure and production capacities - even simply finding places to live without massive radiation contamination would be a serious challenge. I fear there would be historian to recount what would happen next.
- themodelplumber 10y agoI thought nuclear winters were found to be a myth? (A minor point of course)
- wwweston 10y agoHow can they be a myth? Harsher winters from volcanic eruptions appear to be a historical fact. Nuclear explosions can kick up a huge storm of stuff into the atmosphere -- that's part of their point. Multiple explosions, multiple effects, likely similar enough to volcanic winters. Or worse, depending on the breadth of the exchange. And, of course, there's making massive amounts of the environment radioactive.
- justin66 10y ago> Nuclear explosions can kick up a huge storm of stuff into the atmosphere -- that's part of their point. I've never read that. It's easy enough to do, but the (planned) usage of these weapons (outside of hitting the enemy's heavily hardened targets on the ground) tends to rely on airbursts. I don't remember either side relying on nuclear winter strategically. The logic of MAD is terrible enough to serve as a deterrent even without maximizing dust in the atmosphere. I remember the disarmament advocates warning of nuclear winter, and the warmongery types minimizing its liklihood.
- intransigent 10y agoWell, the idea of global doomsday for all, beyond mere tactical retaliation, is probably drawn from the media, with movies like Dr. Stangelove playing the part of the primary narrative. As to how much any world power has actually strategized and mobilized resources toward such an end (deliberate global suicide that destroys both sides by design) is likely to never be fully revealed, since it's a slightly alarming idea. Even so, some of the plans that have been revealed really are quite terrible. Bad enough, that the difference between deliberate and accidental nuclear winters could be considered an argument that splits hairs.
- sehugg 10y agoNo, it's even worse than we thought back then. Recent research predicts even a regional nuclear exchange could create global famine conditions for years (not to mention the political and economic instability): http://www.ippnw.org/nuclear-famine.html http://www.ippnw.org/nuclear-famine.html
- prodmerc 10y agoDepends on the nuclear players involved. If it's just the US and Russia (for whatever reason), plenty of the world will survive. Seems that people disagree on how many detonations in what places would be necessary for a serious and long nuclear winter. An all out nuclear world war (the reasons for which I could not begin to comprehend), then it's game over.
- arethuza 10y agoI'm pretty sure that even if it was just a US and Russia thing that some places in the UK would be hit - the Fylingdales BMEWS site, possibly the UK Trident facilities on the Clyde.
- SalimoS 10y agoI'm pretty sure that Africa won't get touched
- ekianjo 10y agoThe US and Russia would target each other allies' as well.