12 ms·
“Children of Men”'s vision of the future is now disturbingly familiar
- bbarn 10y agoWhen the Zika outbreak hit, I was reminded of this movie. It's not the same magnitude, but still.
- macintux 10y agoI was surprised the article didn't mention Zika.
- the_duke 10y agoChildren of Men is one of my all-time favorite movies. Top 3 I think. If you haven't seen it, find some time over Christmas to do so. Won't exactly get you into a holiday spirit though...
- lmkg 10y agoIt actually is a Christmas movie. More specifically, it's a re-telling of the Nativity story.
- peller 10y agoAye but is it something you'd watch with a bunch of 8 year olds? Perhaps it's one on a technicality, in much the same way Die Hard is. But it's definitely not what most people think of when somebody says "it's a Christmas movie."
- user837387 10y agoHow so? I've watched it several times and not sure how it relates?
- vecter 10y agoThe baby (or the fact that it exists and will be born) is purported to be the savior of humanity. Sound familiar?
- JonnieCache 10y agoAnd the scene in the barn with the animals all around, c'mon.
- thatusertwo 10y agoAgreed.
- s_kilk 10y agoSame, easily in the top 3. It's also my favourite opening lines of any film: > Newsreader: Day 1,000 of the Siege of Seattle. > Newsreader: The Muslim community demands an end to the Army's occupation of mosques. > Newsreader: The Homeland Security bill is ratified. After eight years, British borders will remain closed. The deportation of illegal immigrants will continue. Good morning. Our lead story. What a way to set the scene
- mcphage 10y agoThere's one scene in it—and I think people who have seen the movie know the one I'm talking about—that's possibly the most powerful, intense scene I've ever seen on screen. Absolutely worth watching.
- waterphone 10y agoThere are several scenes which could qualify, and they are each masterpieces of filmmaking both from an artistic and technical standpoint.
- stevens32 10y agoWhen they exit the building and the chaos pauses for a moment.. absolutely breathtaking every time. It really sold that in the end everyone is on the side of humanity, and everyone hopes for a future. They just couldn't agree on how it should come about.
- braveo 10y agoagreed, It was amazing because everyone automatically knew what was at stake and sides no longer existed in that conflict (temporarily atleast).
- zizee 10y agoI think the grandparent was trying (rightly so) to avoid giving a spoiler by being ambiguous. Perhaps you could put a [spoiler] prefix on you post.
- Vanit 10y agoPing pong? :)
- pasquinelli 10y agoIt's moving moment, but what I remember about it is how the rug is immediately yanked out from under it.
- mcphage 10y ago
- madebysquares 10y agoI've got to go and re-watch this it's been a while.
- cardamomo 10y agoI've been thinking about how familiar Children of Men feels in recent months, especially given civil war in Syria and the wave of nationalism sweeping Western Europe and the United States. This article is a great analysis of how the film creates this uncanny sense of familiarity. I'm overdue to watch it again. (On a side note, I just finished reading Octavia Butler's Parable of the Sower, which resonantes with today's world in a similar way.)
- walrus01 10y agoIf you haven't seen this movie you absolutely should. And you need to watch it with your face close to a 60"+ high quality screen and with a good sound system. Do not ruin it by watching it on a laptop or mobile device. The extended shots create a near full immersion experience.
- davis 10y agoOr just watch it on anything you can. I honestly don't think you can ruin this film in anyway. I used to watch it on my iPod Touch.
- walrus01 10y agoBetter than nothing... But in its own way it really needs a high def, surround sound experience to become fully absorbed, and your full undivided attention. Same way if I recommend that someone watch 2001 for the first time or Apocalypse Now Redux (the full 3 hour cut).
- andrepd 10y ago+1 for 2001. Watching it for the first time is a transcendent experience.
- lhl 10y agoAs an aside, for those in Los Angeles, American Cinematheque has been showing a nearly pristine new 70mm (roadshow version) print of 2001 at the Egyptian this month (I saw it a few weeks ago). There are screenings on the 26th and 27th. Also, on the 30th they are screening Lawrence of Arabia in 70mm as well. Lawrence of Arabia was filmed in 70mm 2.20:1 Super Panavision, and is IMO, even more than 2001, worth seeing in 70mm.
- serb348 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKiIroiCvZ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKiIroiCvZ0
- braveo 10y ago
- h4nkoslo 10y agoThe little touches were the best part of the movie - the nihilist industrial scream-metal music, the Islamic militia in the streets, the plausibly crappy vehicles... Incredible movie.
- duskwuff 10y agoFun fact: the "Zen music" from Children of Men is a track by Aphex Twin [1] with a Creative Commons-licensed sound effect [2] dubbed over it. This got quite a bit of attention at the time (e.g, [3]), as it was one of the first documented instances of a major film using CC assets. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltLOrgnfW9w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltLOrgnfW9w [2]: https://www.freesound.org/people/thanvannispen/sounds/9432/ https://www.freesound.org/people/thanvannispen/sounds/9432/ [3]: https://creativecommons.org/2007/01/17/freesound-sample-in-children-of-men/ https://creativecommons.org/2007/01/17/freesound-sample-in-c...
- adzm 10y agoThat really was a fun fact; thanks.
- wildpeaks 10y agoNerdwriter made a great review of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-woNlmVcdjc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-woNlmVcdjc
- Laforet 10y agoOn a lighter note, I had a good chuckle when the article mentioned that the director deliberately avoided depiction of cellphones to avoid creating an unintentional period piece[0]. The last movie I watched in the treatre is Clint Eastwood's "Sully" and I distinctly remember the main character using a chronologically appropoaite Samsung flip phone and that single prop instantly dates the movie to the first decade of the 20th century. Just as much as Pulp Fiction is locked in the early 90s with Vincent Vega pulling the antenna out of his Motorola brick phone in one exaggerated motion, albeit these choices are probably intentional. Some long running manga series take another approach by quietly giving its cast the latest gear despite the timeline moving at a much slower pace.[1] It works until you start revisiting the earlier episodes and get reminded of how old the series really is with its depiction of personal electronics. [0]: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/UnintentionalPeriodPiece http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/UnintentionalPeri... [1]: http://anime.stackexchange.com/questions/77/how-much-time-has-passed-in-universe-in-detective-conan http://anime.stackexchange.com/questions/77/how-much-time-ha...
- lobster_johnson 10y agoConversely, in William Gibson's Neuromancer, there are no cell phones, despite being set decades into the future. Gibson knows a thing or two about seeing their scifi becoming dated, of course. The famous opening line, "The sky above the port was the color of television, tuned to a dead channel" no longer resonates with anyone born the last 20 years or so (although for a number of years, many digital TVs would display blue for missing input). There's also some fun stuff about people physically carrying information (this also happens in short story "Johnny Mnemonic"). For a world where there's a highly connected, super fast worldwide computer network available, people sure travel around a lot.
- ronilan 10y ago> although for a number of years, many digital TVs would display blue for missing input I'm sure you are aware that "the color of television, tuned to a dead channel" is not blue - right? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=I3ZAMjpjYfQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=I3ZAMjpjYfQ
- walrus01 10y agoAmericans seem OK with watching extremely violent movies with no message or purpose with 8 year olds... People getting shot in the face in utterly inane action movies.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post nationalistic slights here. Everybody has an endless supply of these things to sling at one another if they get going. Therefore, don't get going. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248373 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248373 and marked it off-topic.
- vectorpush 10y agoI have to admit that the world the movie depicts does seem quite prescient from today's perspective and the cinematography is excellent, especially those long single-shot scenes (and that particular scene towards the end of the film that other comments have alluded to), but I personally didn't find the movie to be as exceptional as others seem to. In particular I felt that the plot sort of meandered a bit throughout the middle section of the film and I also felt that the fertility pandemic theme was somewhat underutilized as a concept. Still, the movie is definitely worth a watch.
- emmelaich 10y agoI also felt it meandered; the message was not enough to sustain the whole movie. It also felt a bit like '28 days'; after about half-way it went low-budget and lost it's way story-wise.
- joelmichael 10y agoIt says fertility isn't an issue today, but it's a little out of touch with today's anxieties; most of Europe and Japan have such low fertility that their native populations are in decline.
- closeparen 10y ago>most of Europe and Japan have such low fertility Their problem is not couples trying to conceive and failing, but people choosing not to have children.
- smallnamespace 10y agoThis is only true of one strongly presumes that conscious decision-making is not at all influenced at all by the body's own fertility. But a fertile body can influence the mind in all sorts of ways -- changing hormones can modify sexual desire, for example.
- future1979 10y agoYes .. in many cases, because they simply cannot afford to have children.
- closeparen 10y agoWell, they clearly can, as many more people in more deeply impoverished parts of the world are having lots of children. Likely, they cannot afford to have children while providing the standard of living (own bedroom, back yard, healthy food, bonding time, good school, college education, etc) they consider the lower bound on acceptable.
- future1979 10y agoI think it is clear that this is precisely what I meant. But thanks for your comment :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mynameishere 10y agoWow, you guys really love propaganda. You do realize that film was propaganda, right?
- ramzyo 10y agoA good reminder to watch a fantastic movie I haven't seen in a long time. I do think the author's premise is a little shoddy though. Broad similarities between the state of the world in 2006 when the film was made and today aren't all that shocking. In 2006 the world was far along the path of globalization set forth through policies developed after the fall of the Berlin Wall and championed by essentially every US president and their allies since. The author does allude to this when he writes "In 2006, all of this seemed plausible enough, but perhaps a little strident, a little over-the-top." I agree that in 2006 most (myself included) probably didn't think that globalization would face the challenges that it does today as quickly and dramatically as it has over the last two years. That being said, that nationalistic and discriminatory behavior and actions can result from decades of globalization and tolerance seems more a reflection of a natural (if not unfortunate) pendulum swing between two approaches on opposite ends of the spectrum. Any particular power of foresight on the part of the screenwriters/filmmakers seems to me like a stretch, although the author seems to insinuate this to be the case. Maybe I'm thinking too much...the movie is really awesome and I need to watch again.
- djsumdog 10y agoSsh. Quiet. Don't rock the boat man. The reality is that the US et. al. allies have caused the war in Syria. Not just funded it or supplied the rebels with weapons. The CIA most likely started all of that, to create the distraction we now have. When I mention this to Americans, they act like I'm all crazy. The CIA caused the 1973 coupe in Chile. There's the Bay of Pigs, the Iranian Contras, MK Ultra, The School of the Americas .. the list is long. It shouldn't be silly or a conspiracy theory to suggest the CIA started the war in Syria in order to cause instability, prop up both ends of the weapon industry and to push American's war interests. America is a bully and the CIA is the secrete hand that is nothing less than a criminal mafia. It fits the pattern like a serial killer.
- ramzyo 10y agoIt's no secret that foreign intelligence agencies of all nations, not just the CIA, can't fully decouple their charters (effectively to simply gather information to paint a clear picture of what's going on in the world to help inform national security decision makers) from the reality that their directors are appointed by partisans with agendas. This has been a contributing factor to bad things happening in the past, many of which you mentioned, many of which involved the CIA, and many of which occurred during the Cold War. But to suggest that the policies and practices of that time are standard operating procedure now, and that the CIA is orchestrating destabilization efforts in Syria for profit, is to disregard public information concerning the evolution of the role of the CIA in US foreign policy since the end of the Cold War. That nations back certain players in international conflicts to advance their own agendas (like the proxy war in Syria now) isn't equivalent to intelligence agencies of said nations deliberately destabilizing regimes for profit or other nefarious ends. That nations (at least the military industrial complex within nations) generally profit from war does not necessarily mean that all war is started for profit. I will concede, however, that I believe this played an outsize role in the decision to invade Iraq in 2003.
- dang 10y agoThis is off topic in so many ways. HN is no place for political and ideological battle, regardless of the politics you espouse. Please don't post like this here. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248463 and marked it off-topic.
- moron4hire 10y agoIt's an old movie. If he spoiled it for you, it's your fault. Vader is Lukes father. The Titanic sinks at the end. Lost was all a communal dream while everyone on the flight died together.
- user837387 10y ago>>Lost was all a communal dream while everyone on the flight died together. Noooooooo!!!. You've just spoiled it for me. No I'll never work up the courage to watch the series. I've tried watching the first episode several times but I just find it so boring. It looked like a good TV series and really wanted to like it but I just could not get through the first one. I found some of the characters obnoxious. Now you've ruined it for me. Hope you are happy. :)
- snowwrestler 10y agoDon't worry, the spoiler is wrong. Just don't read my other post...
- andrepd 10y agoYou must be fun at parties.
- tree_of_item 10y ago1. It's from 2006. 2. Why is it the reader's responsibility to watch every single film to be released, ever?
- snowwrestler 10y agoWrong about Lost... In fact the whole point of the final was that the stuff on The Island was real, and it was the most important time in all of their lives. Which is why they all end up together in a sort of timeless purgatory, even though they died many years apart.
- nindalf 10y agoThis is unacceptable. There's no reason to ruin all of these movies and shows, especially since this thread is about something else entirely. In any online community centred around works of fiction, this would be a bannable offense. I'm flagging your comment for this reason. And no, not everyone knows about Vader. I have a friend who watched Star Wars for the first time last week just before we dragged him to Rogue One.
- iiiggglll 10y ago> The one aspect of the film that doesn’t seem to be coming true is its central premise. The idea is that no human beings have been born in the last 18 years, so when Theo meets Kee, an African woman who is miraculously pregnant, he has to protect her from the various groups who want to exploit her condition. Obviously, we know that this infertility pandemic hasn’t happened: in Children of Men, the youngest person on the planet was born in 2009. But even as a concept, this particular one doesn’t resonate with our current anxieties, because overpopulation is more worrying than population decline. It's not really about population -- it's about having no future, which is something a lot of people constantly worry about.
- duaneb 10y ago> It's not really about population -- it's about having no future, which is something a lot of people constantly worry about. One thing the movie (unintentionally) got right was how absurd this is. It really ruined the movie to me, TBH, because it was laughably implausible. Reproduction is what life does best. I'll obviously have to watch again for the world building....
- knz 10y agoAnd yet fertility rates are declining in many nations. Science fiction often takes current events to their extreme outcome for the sake of social commentary (Black Mirror being the latest example).
- stephengillie 10y agoHuman fertility itself isn't in decline. Fertility and human births are conflated in the US government definition, implying that we are somehow losing the physical ability to reproduce. What's actually happening is that our society is getting so complex that our agency of reproduction is impaired. It's entirely social; it's all in our heads.
- smallnamespace 10y ago
- gojomo 10y agoI love this film and at a certain level, it is plausible (and even natural) that in times of existential fear, societies lash out against outsiders/immigrants. And yet I have economic quibbles! In an actual fertility collapse, a highly-developed country like the UK would have an immense surplus of infrastructure, housing, machinery, etc – capital – compared to the dwindling number of new, young workers. Immigrants (of all ages, cultures, and skill levels) could become incredibly economically valuable. In comparison, reliable 'guard labor' to try to hunt and confine immigrants would become very expensive. Compare, for example, the depopulation of the 'Black Death' in Europe in the 1300's. For those who survived, wages and opportunity grew, and attempts to enforce older rules which bound people to undesirable situations collapsed. Wikipedia suggests that "[p]lague brought an eventual end of Serfdom in Western Europe": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequences_of_the_Black_Death#Impact_on_peasants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequences_of_the_Black_Deat...
- edblarney 10y ago"societies lash out against outsiders/immigrants." It's not as one-sided as that. Many of the immigrants in the book are essentially 'terrorists', there was a funeral march by a group that is essentially Hamas in the film. Hamas are point-blank terrorists, though they are also a political group. A 'world on fire' with millions of people flooding into the 'small, stable area' definitely represent a threat to that stability at least on some level. It's more nuanced take. Almost everyone is a good guy / bad guy, and there is a lot of violence ... in that state, it's hard to have an easy moral compass.
- bananash 10y agoim already talking about this vaccines are little ufos (that cause cancer, breast cancer testicle cancer and vagina cancer specifically). and a host of other birth mutations. article with ~25 graphs (disease rates post vaccine boom 1975) coming soon. if you dont want to wait google '4chan/sci/ archive' and search that archive ' Vaccines are devolving people?' additionaly the sperm count avg has bombed since 1975 when they 4x'd the vaxx rate every 5 years
- mavdi 10y agoYou sound clinically insane.
- bananash 10y agowell debate me on video or fight me boxing in real life or stfu. nerd. im totally sane. (and a good boxer and great debater, and engineer. and f* you) google lobotomobile, then go get one plz
- 467568985476 10y agoHow would fighting someone make your ideas valid?
- dang 10y agoWe've banned this account for violating the site guidelines.
- dang 10y agoPersonal attacks are off-topic regardless of how someone sounds. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248599 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248599 and marked it off-topic.
- w-ll 10y agoSlightly OT but pertains to "Children of Men" The scenes where main character Theo Faron (Clive Owen) is on the really nice buses, and there is classical music playing in the background, while outside the window there is so much poverty really resonated with me. I've lived in SF going on 6 years now. My apt complex has private buses that run from here to FDi in the morning and evening. The route sometimes changes but a lot of the time we would go thru the heart of the TL. I'd be half asleep comfortably siting on this Bauer's bus, usually listening to something like Aphex Twin's Select Ambient Works, so not the classic music, but still I would sit there in this amazingly privileged situation and look out the window to all this poverty and despair. It constantly reminded me of this movie. I worked at Apple for a while, and the same thing, yet instead of my apt complex, it was dozens of Apple buses, shuttling 1000s of people for all over the bay area, and again on the way i'd see so much that really made me think about the current affairs of lots of things that's going crazy in our small little part of the world. I've since left Apple and joined to a small startup near Union Square/FDi area. I still live in the same apt complex, and they still have the buses running every 15-20 min in the morning, but i don't ride them any more. I walk the 2 miles everyday to and back from work, and I love it. For so many reasons I love it. One big reason is I don't want to be shielded or sheltered from the real world going on around us. I don't want to deal with the shit on the sidewalk or the craziness that exists in between my spot and my work, but i also don't want to pretend it doesn't exist and try and ignore it. Sometimes it can be very annoying, hell even scary. But also, A few times it's been amazing rewarding to help someone for 5 minutes. All sorts of little things, I've helped people that can't get their wheelchair from the street onto the sidewalk, or helping the elderly man trying to pick up a heavy box of fruit delivery for his corner store I walk past. I've had to explain this to some friends that live in apt complex. They take the bus daily and asked why I don't ride it any more, and again it all comes back to the bus scene from Children Of Men.
- icelancer 10y agoI worked in a gated, enclosed, guarded community in a Central American country with a bunch of expats - British, Canadian, American - and saw nothing but abject poverty outside of our small enclosure. Everything was delivered. McDonalds, Pizza Hut, local food, drinks, newspapers, groceries... We had transportation to the local office and I saw much the same as you, but in way worse conditions. It affected me just the same as you. I didn't last very long before taking a remote assignment and going back home.
- grondilu 10y ago> But even as a concept, this particular one doesn’t resonate with our current anxieties, because overpopulation is more worrying than population decline. Yet there are demographers who very much worry about it[1]. They sometimes call it the "demographic winter". The decrease of birth rates is already observed in most developed countries, and it does not turn into population decline mostly because of immigration, so this kind of reflects to what is described in the movie, even if the movie shows an extreme version of it with a supernatural element (the sudden halt of worldwide fertility). 1. https://books.google.com/books/about/Essai_de_prospective_d%C3%A9mographique.html?id=ngTV_W5-UMMC https://books.google.com/books/about/Essai_de_prospective_d%...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- roryisok 10y agoWhatever you might argue about it's prescience, Children of Men is one of the best films of the last decade. The writing, directing and acting are all stellar. It has some of the best single take shots ever filmed. There's a 20 minute running street battle at the end with tanks and explosions that is shot in a single take. It's also one of those rare occasions where the movie is far better than the original book. Book is ok, film is outstanding.
- Reason077 10y agoAbsolutely agree. It's a masterpiece on many different levels.
- pavelrub 10y agoThe reasons you consider it to be such a good film probably have more to do with cinematography than writing, acting or directing. The beautiful shots are a direct result of Emmanuel Lubezki being the DP - the same style can be seen in Birdman, Gravity, The Revenant, and some of Terrence Malick’s films.
- alexandersingh 10y agoWhile the cinematography is a master stroke, it's not enough to carry a film seeking some level of depth. I feel Children of Men succeeds because all of its elements - the direction, acting, art direction, writing, score, editing & cinematography - come together so well. There are many films that get some of these elements right, far fewer nail all of them.
- roryisok 10y agoThe cinematography is excellent, but the performances and writing are top notch, even without the fancy tracking shots or singles takes. Best performance of Clive Owens career, he's wasted in everything else. The rapport between himself and Caine is marvellous. Ejiofor is subtly menacing, more desperation than outright evil. Even the smaller roles are well cast and executed. Charlie Hunnam is almost unrecognisable as the dreadlocked villain Patric. Peter Mullan does a fantastic turn as the brutal Syd. The writing took the source material and squeezed far more emotion and drama out of it than was in there. Throwaway lines hint at so much untold story. There's a scene where Theo goes to visit his cousin to try and get travel documents. He has Michelangelo's David in the hallway of his office, and he talks off-handedly about "that thing in madrid was a real blow to art" or something. There's this whole backstory in there about the UK government trying to salvage the artworks of europe from the decay of civilisation, but we only get a hint of it. Perfectly understated. Always stayed with me.
- m-i-l 10y ago"...Cuarón’s most effective decision was to shoot so many scenes on the streets of London, without adding much except graffiti, litter and all-round squalor." Actually, I lived around the corner from one of the locations in the film, and remember the film crew coming in and cleaning up the pretty disgusting real filth (human excrement, used needles, etc.) and painting over the real graffiti, replacing it with cleaner pretend filth (scrunched up newspapers and the like) and safer pretend graffiti.
- Upvoter33 10y agogood thread. however, amazing to me that the word "woman" only occurs once in the discussion (to date). To me, that movie is about the destruction (or perhaps, near destruction) of the world due to the things that "men" have created (wars, poverty, etc.), and how only perhaps a woman can save them all from it.
- glbrew 10y agoI'd say "v for vendetta" is the closest.
- chasingtheflow 10y agoBut in Children of Men, England is the last country to keep functioning...