5 ms·
Still no violation of Lorentz symmetry, despite strongest test yet
- jameskilton 10y agoRelevant piece of information as to why this is important: > "Furthermore, so far, it has been impossible to conciliate in one common theory these two aspects of physics. To succeed in this quest, almost all unification theories predict a breaking of Lorentz symmetry."
- cdetrio 10y agoHmm, does this relate to the article from 6 days ago about the inability to find proton decay? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13201065 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13201065
- eln1 10y agoLorentz invariance appears naturally in practically all theories with waves - its violation would be a huge surprise. To see it, understand STR, the perfect model is sine-Gordon: just many coupled pendula - we get particles ("kinks") with rest mass, which are created/annihilated in pairs, the mass grows exactly like in STR and is released while annihilation ... while moving these particles undergo Lorentz contraction (speed is limited by speed of massless waves) and oscillating particles ("breathers") slow down (time dilation) - exactly like in STR. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sine-Gordon_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sine-Gordon_equation "Universe model with a drill" ;) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nl5Qq5kUbEE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nl5Qq5kUbEE Animation of kink-antikink annihilation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_defect#Images https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_defect#Images
- hansen 10y agoThere are lots of non-relativistic models using waves. Nothing special about them. The most compelling argument for relativity is causality. You can reconstruct spacetime – up to conformal transformations – just from the causality relations. I can’t even imagine what physics would be like w/o causality.
- eln1 10y agoIf you restrict the speed of propagation of interactions (of massless waves), you nearly automatically get STR ... like in sine-Gordon model - speed of massive kinks becomes limited, and kinks are being contracted to zero while approaching this limit.
- dcudjejxice 10y agoCan you please explain or provide a link? This sounds fascinating.
- hansen 10y agohttp://aip.scitation.org/doi/abs/10.1063/1.523436 http://aip.scitation.org/doi/abs/10.1063/1.523436 ED: This is the starting point of the Causal Set [1] program. Don’t ask me for details, I don’t know any. But the wikipedia article looks interesting. Seems they are trying to figure out how causality restricts models with some level of discreteness. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causal_sets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causal_sets
- cyphar 10y agoThis was covered in my undergraduate (second-year) SR course. The idea is that if you accept that Maxwell's equations apply in all inertial frames (speed of light is constant) and that causality is conserved in all frames, the result is that Newtonian mechanics requires adjustments for effects that are called "special relativity".
- valarauca1 10y agoGR does not imply causality nor does it enforce it. In fact GR works in a non-causal universe without a problem. 2 very sensitive measurements conducted within the past year seem to suggest (if GR is true), that we are in a universe that lacks causality. 2/3 LIGO detections imply one of the merging pair of black holes should be a naked singularity. GR allows naked singularities. It models them fine. GR just stops being globally deterministic. If you look up the history of GR some mathematicians in 50's made some really weird proposals for non-causal universes that would appear locally causal. But there isn't a way to test this. So it is more pure mathematics or philosophy then physics.
- monochromatic 10y agoSRT?
- eln1 10y agoI've meant special relativity.
- noobermin 10y agoI feel like this is a common misconception amongst some physicists. Lorentz invariance doesn't "appear naturally" in modern theories depending on how you develop it. Usually, one chooses a lagrangian that yields a lorentz invariant action and so all physical laws and thus solutions are lorentz invariant consequently. Lorentz invariance is a fundamental assumption...upheld by experiment. Those theories will then admit solutions (usually linearized ones (read quantized)) that appear as waves.
- tzs 10y agoIs there a conservation law associated with Lorentz symmetry, the way there are conservation laws associated with other symmetries in physics (conservation of energy from symmetry under translation in time, conservation of angular momentum from symmetry under rotation, conservation of linear momentum from conservation under translation in space, and so on)?
- moefh 10y agoLorentz symmetry is associated with conservation of center of mass, see [1] (Note that it's actually talking about Lorentz symmetry without rotations (called "Lorentz boosts"), because rotations are associated with another conservation, as you mentioned.) [1] http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/12559/what-conservation-law-corresponds-to-lorentz-boosts http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/12559/what-conser...
- raattgift 10y agoThat's true for the Lagrangian written down in the excellent answer at stackexchange, but the equivalent Lagrangian of the Standard Model Extension (SME) (which is what is the topic of the Bourgoin et al. paper) is filled with additional terms. For example, a minimal SME photon Lagrangian is developed in section II. A. of Kostelcky and Mewes @ https://arxiv.org/abs/0905.0031 https://arxiv.org/abs/0905.0031 The difference between a minimal SME (mSME) and the full SME is that the latter admits terms of any mass dimension greater than two, while mSME requires power-counting renormalizability (in order to be an effective field theory) so mSME admits only terms of dimension four. As a result mSME can only have a finite number of Lorentz invariance violation parameters, while SME can have an infinite number of them. The bright side is that mSME can represent locally the Lagrangian in the physics.se answer you link to with a fixing of parameters; the dim side is that in general one does not want to do this a priori, precisely because the mSME is a tool to investigate whether the Lorentz SO(3,1; R) group is an exact feature of nature at every point, rather than postulating that it is (as the Standard Model does, and indeed as Special Relativity and General Relativity do). For example, SME is useful for dealing with things like this: https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Bumblebee_models#/Lagrangian https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Bumblebee_models#/Lagrangian where the non-matter term might not reduce (via GL(4, R)) to the groupoid of local coordinate transforms on the manifold and the local SO(3, 1; R) Lorentz group on the orthonormal frames (tetrad formalism) which are the symmetries of General Relativity. The point is to find out under what conditions any such model does vary from General Relativity. (We already have a good EFT for GR itself, and the result of the Bourgoin et al. paper is that it remains good.)
- raattgift 10y agopreprint: https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.00294 https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.00294