5 ms·
Why not though? What's wrong with it? In the case where the employee is wrong then nothing happens besides, maybe, some negative news stories if it's leaked. Th
by onion2k 10y ago
Why not though? What's wrong with it? In the case where the employee is wrong then nothing happens besides, maybe, some negative news stories if it's leaked. That's reasonably controllable. On the other hand though, if the employee is actually correct, then the employer is protected from any claim they were informed about the illegal activity if employees don't use language that says they think wrongdoing is going on. Should employees work under threat of breaking rules designed to protect their employer if the employer is breaking the law? I don't think so.
- meddlepal 10y agoAs an engineer coming from a family of lawyers... engineers think they understand the law, but really they suck at it and when that shit does end up in court it looks really bad because it comes out in discovery.
- onion2k 10y agothat shit does end up in court it looks really bad because it comes out in discovery. That's exactly my point. I'm asking whether or not an employer should write a contract that specifically states the employee should modify their behaviour to ensure things aren't discovered later - namely that the employer knew (or at least "was informed") that illegal things were going on. I don't think they should. If my employer wanted me to sign something that said "If you see things happening that you believe might be illegal, please keep quiet about it because you don't understand the law" I think I ought to say no.
- sangnoir 10y ago> namely that the employer knew (or at least "was informed") that illegal things were going on The problem is engineers lack a good grasp of how the law works compared to lawyers - sometimes the action is not illegal, but it will still looks bad after discovery. Leading to unnecessary settlements not as a matter of law, but of optics. "If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him." > "If you see things happening that you believe might be illegal, please keep quiet about it because you don't understand the law" That's not what they are saying - they are saying don't use email to do it. I mean would you appreciate it if your startup's first employee sends an email stating "We are infringing on these 18 Microsoft patents" on the record?
- tremon 10y agosometimes the action is not illegal, but it will still looks bad after discovery So, are we discussing ethics or legality? If Google's official policy is one of "we like to skirt the law well into looking-bad territory, and that is fine" then they really need to abandon their "do no evil" motto.
- FordPrefectAO 10y agoIt was abandoned long ago
- oh_sigh 10y agoHow is it skirting the law? It seems more like "We (like everyone else) like to win court cases we may be in, and engineers providing unneeded or unfounded legal opinions over email makes it harder to win cases" Your inability to understand this goes to OPs point about engineers not understanding law. I'm guessing you're an engineer(or at least - not a lawyer)
- sangnoir 10y ago> So, are we discussing ethics or legality? No. I'll make an analogy: Engineers hate it when sales make commitments on behalf of engineering. Can you not imagine how lawyers might dislike engineers making legal commitments? When dealing with people outside of the org, lawyers want from engineers what engineers want from sales - be vague and don't create obligations you do not fully understand. It is still perfectly fine for a sales guy to privately point out a bug - just don't shout it to the customer.
- onion2k 10y agoCan you not imagine how lawyers might dislike engineers making legal commitments I think it takes a lawyer to believe "pointing out when the company you work for is breaking the law" is the same as "making a legal commitment", as if laws only apply if you acknowledge them. I'm realise that is essentially how the world lawyers live in works, but I think it sucks and I wouldn't want to sign a contract that forces me to be a part of it.
- Angostura 10y agoAnd without it, the company can imply say "We deny that either Mr Doe or any other member of staff told us this was happening"
- fleetingmoments 10y agoIt's about the language used. You can absolutely cover yourself without directly implicating the company. Don't say "we're violating this and this patent", because even if you're technically not, it would look bad if that email were to come up in a patent lawsuit.
- eeZah7Ux 10y ago> engineers think they understand the law, but really they suck at it Especially true when it comes to licenses.
- smallnamespace 10y agoNot just the PR hit, it also looks terrible in court.
- debatem1 10y agoEngineers love to talk about legal issues as though they were lawyers. It turns out that with very few exceptions engineers are not lawyers. Now, saying things that aren't true in a discoverable medium is basically never a good idea; but drawing legal conclusions in one without having any real idea if you're right is the kind of bad idea that can cost your company a bunch of money. I'm sure the policy is aimed at cutting that kind of problem, rather than stopping legitimate whistleblowing etc (which is protected anyway).
- jay_kyburz 10y agoYes but everyday people are expected to know the law and obey it. You don't need to be a lawyer to know that assaulting somebody or driving dangerously is against the law. If you know your company is "assaulting somebody" or something obviously illegal, I think you have a duty to let superiors know so that something can be done to fix it. People are both employees and citizens and sometimes must choose between the company and thier own society at large.
- cjmcqueen 10y agoYes, you do have duty, but not in email. Full disclosure, I'm a Googler. And, thankfully every verbal complaint or concern I've made has been addressed and resolved.
- IshKebab 10y ago> but not in an email Sure, that benefits Google. But some people care more about ethics and don't want Google to get away with potentially illegal actions.
- skybrian 10y agoIt benefits you as well, unless testifying in court about some careless thing you said in email is your idea of fun.
- sangnoir 10y ago> Why not though? What's wrong with it? One of the reasons is jury trials: such emails are discoverable and Google has first-hand experience with this in Oracle v. Google. Oracle brought an email sent by a non-lawyer technical Googler[1] and used it as evidence that Google knowingly infringed on Oracle's copyright. Googles lawyers had to go to great pains to deflect that line of attack (including asking the guy if he was a lawyer on the stand as Oracle's hostile witness). Even if the email is wrong, it still looks bad to someone who does not understand the nuance of law, like members of the jury. 1. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/05/apache-e-mails-shown-in-court-say-android-ripped-off-oracle-ip/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/05/apache-e-mails-sh...
- the8472 10y agoWell, then maybe not the speech between employees is the problem but jury trials or the discovery therein. If lawyers are just fishing to soundbites and that leads to companies hassling their employees that's a flawed system.
- josho 10y agoThis is corporate policy to protect the corporation. It is power gone too far. People need to know that it's ok to speak up when something wrong occurs. For example, If I were to see Jimmy stealing some GoogleBot servers then absolutely the company would want me to inform them about Jimmy's actions. Communication is largely done by email. So, there is no problem reporting illegal activity by email. But, that's not what the corporation is fearful of, they are afraid of Jimmy's department which is infringing Big Corp.'s Patents. If I see this and email the company then the company has to respond with an inquiry to their lawyer and investigate, otherwise this could come out later in a court trial and cause financial harm. So the company doesn't want people to do what they believe is right. Oh sure, we can still report it verbally. But, that's absurd to have a policy that says email is fine for all communications except for anything that could potentially be detrimental to the company. What if I was harassed at work, I'm not supposed to say anything about that in email, it all has to be done face to face? I hope this case wins, I hope that folks here understand that it's important to do what's right and not to do what their corporation tells them is right.