3 ms·
As far as I can tell, the quote given by fapjacks is saying that the reactionless drive is impossible. Note that it is in a paragraph that begins "The other maj
by mannykannot 10y ago
As far as I can tell, the quote given by fapjacks is saying that the reactionless drive is impossible. Note that it is in a paragraph that begins "The other major kind of shonky coverage covers mythical propulsion..." (I had to look up 'shonky', but it is consistent with the above reading.)
- Daneel_ 10y agoCorrect - Casey believes that the drive is impossible, given our understanding of physics. Given his background and credentials, I'm happy to defer to his opinion on the matter, over my own optimism. Both he and I are firm believers of the scientific method though, so if researchers can show it experimentally then that's where the fun really begins. To my knowledge, the experiments until now have been fairly poor, with barely significant results (on the edge of noise).
- fapjacks 10y agoBut that's not what he's saying, now is it? He is dismissing it entirely as "impossible". Care to point me to the part of the scientific method which says "Feel free to dismiss outright things that don't make sense to you"?
- daveguy 10y agoEverything in science starts out impossible. It doesn't even get considered in science unless it has a chance of being impossible. Then it is up to the scientist to demonstrate that it is possible and explain how it is possible. Edit: The 1) demonstrate and 2) explain parts are critical and it's not science unless you have 1). Preferably 2) also. EM has neither to match the magnitude of the claims until they can push something across the solar system and back (such that loss of mass is ruled out and the propulsive effect is without a doubt not instrument error).
- jack9 10y ago> EM has neither to match the magnitude of the claims until they can push something across the solar system and back That is hyperbolic. Pushing something around in orbit is sufficient to move forward (pardon the pun).
- daveguy 10y agoGood point, but it would need to accelerate and decelerate in orbit enough to confirm that mass loss isn't driving it.
- avmich 10y agoI think, given the structure of phrase, we can assume some irony there - not only baseless dismissal. EM drive remains pretty controversial, and does present significant problems with explanation, and as an extraordinary device requires extraordinary evidence. So it could be conceivable not to focus too deeply on a remark which isn't the main point of the article.
- Daneel_ 10y agoI think he's just expressing a healthy degree of skepticism, with a touch of hyperbole for flavour. He's likely just a bit sick of being asked his opinion on the drive until there's further experiments and research conducted on the matter. I'm not dismissing your interest and excitement in the topic either. I'd love for it to be functional, and for us to learn new information on the way our universe works. The bar for entry is set particularly high on this, that's all :)
- paulmd 10y agoUnfortunately - even if you had some weird results that didn't fit the prevailing theorems, publishing would likely destroy your professional credibility. See: Fleischmann/Pons and their publications of abnormal results that others speculated might be related to cold fusion, the decades of slander and defamation of them as quacks (despite the fact that they themselves had not claimed anything of the sort), and their recent vindication. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/its-not-cold-fusion-but-its-something/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/its-not-cold... HN discussion: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/its-not-cold-fusion-but-its-something/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/its-not-cold... > Perhaps most surprising is that, in the formative years of atomic science in the early 20th century, some scientists reported inexplicable experimental evidence of elemental transmutations. In the 1910s and 1920s, this research was reported in popular newspapers and magazines, and papers were published in the top scientific journals of the day, including Physical Review, Science and Nature. The experiments, using relatively simple, low-energy benchtop apparatus, did not use radioactive sources so the results defied prevailing theory. Several researchers independently detected the production of the gases helium-4, neon, argon, and an as-yet-unidentified element of mass-3, which we now identify as tritium. Two of these researchers were Nobel laureates. To think that our current models adequately explain every phenomenon in the universe is truly the height of hubris. They can't even explain every phenomenon that has been observed on Planet Earth, let alone universally. Of course extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof - but we do a tremendous disservice by disincentivizing scientists from ever reporting a novel finding that disagrees with the prevailing theories.
- fapjacks 10y ago
- freshhawk 10y agoIf we can't call perpetual motion machines "impossible" then what can we call impossible?
- omegaham 10y agoI'm pretty sure that fapjacks believes that the reactionless drive is possible, and all of the "No, this is silly" folks are just contrarian deniers who are holding back progress. Gotta love starry-eyed futurology people.
- f0urtyfive 10y agoWoah there horsey, you're basically sticking anyone that thinks reactionless drive might be possible into the crazy conspiracy theory category, and there are plenty of people that are interested in honest reproducible research on the topic. Just blanket suggesting that it is in no way possible without any evidence is no better than blanket suggesting it is possible without any evidence (well, it's a little better, since the laws of physics are on your side, but...)
- fapjacks 10y agoRight. That's the spirit of my original comment. There are obviously people here with some serious investment in their own educations and egos that think this thing is impossible. Yet, here we are, peer-reviewed evidence[0] mounting. [0] http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.B36120 http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.B36120
- Symmetry 10y agoThat, and that the amount of energy you put in to produce a unit of impulse with a theoretical EM drive is 10 times larger than the amount of energy required to produce that same impulse with a Hall effect thruster. For the journey to Mars that means the EM drive would tend to be much slower in practice even if it worked.