6 ms·
How a Hydrogen Fuel Cell Engine Works
- avmich 10y ago> 2. Hydrogen molecules activated by the anode catalyst release their electrons. Can somebody describe how - and why - oppositely charged particles get separated?
- agumonkey 10y agoSince I'm no chemist I don't get the details, but the thin platinum anode "forces" Hydrogen to split into H+ to go through it, while electrons cannot traverse and thus will flow to the other output... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_cell#Types_of_fuel_cells.3B_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_cell#Types_of_fuel_cells.... Very tricky system.
- avmich 10y agoThank you. My question is about how that "forcing to split" works. An example of how a catalyst works can be presented in terms of energies. If a set of atoms (like, two atoms of hydrogen) can be in several different states (like, as a molecule or as two separate atoms), and there is an energy barrier between those two states, then the system "sits" in a potential hole. In order to get to another state, it has to increase energy to overcome the barrier. Catalyst can help with that, providing a new path between two energy states which doesn't require that high jump in energy. However, when initial state (the molecule) has much lower energy than the final state (two separate atoms), catalyst doesn't help. There can't be a "low energy path to the top of the energy mountain". Here we don't have splitting of neutral molecule into neutral atoms... but I'd still listen to an explanation.
- wuschel 10y agoHi, I am afraid I won't dig into this now due to time reasons (I have to go back and read up stuff), but I just would like to give a remark regarding the concept you have sketched out: The different states you describe do not have to be on different energy levels. A catalyst provides an alternative reaction mechanism that might have a different activation energy. It can result in a molecule of similar energy state, and, yes, you can have a reaction towards an energetically higher state. I am sure there is many a publication that models the electronic transitions that occurs when gas molecules react with metals. Funky stuff, which involves number crunching with models of atomic/molecular orbitals or bands, and even more funky spectroscopic real time measurements of reactions. Chemistry has gone a long way since alchemy, and there are many abstraction layers to get through if you want to have an explanation that would satisfy a physicists. At the end, you will move from empirical knowledge towards a world of quantum chemistry/physics. That is the beauty (or curse) of the discipline that is chemistry. Now, if you are curious how such a thing works, I suggest look up the "Wilkenson catalyst" (a Rhodium based catalytic hydrogenation agent) as an example. It gives you an idea how organometallic compounds work at various levels of depth.
- avmich 10y ago> and, yes, you can have a reaction towards an energetically higher state. Where does that extra chemical energy come from? Other degrees of freedom of a molecule? In general, I'd expect the reaction H2 -> 2H+ + 2e- not to be anything like dominant. It's the separation of charges which is the source of energy of the cell, and the energy is released along the path of those charges recombining. Or am I missing something here? > there are many abstraction layers to get through if you want to have an explanation that would satisfy a physicists. Yes, I'm interested in the actual physics of the process, not in the net chemical result...
- maxerickson 10y agoOxidation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alkaline_fuel_cell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alkaline_fuel_cell
- avmich 10y agoYes, I know the name of the process, but the level of details usually provided - including in this article - isn't quite enough for what I'm looking for.
- cowardlydragon 10y agoIt magically gets the free hydrogen from a bearded white man in the sky... Then you add platinum which you get from the contract with the devil.
- audunw 10y agoHas anyone tried to calculate roughly how cheap and energy dense batteries have to get before hydrogen fuel cells become uncompetetive for small/medium vehicles? I figure, hydrogen's technological downside is a fuel that's hard to store and handle (can't fill a portable tank and carry around like with gasoline, can't fill at home like with batteries). Pure battery's downside is shorter range and longer time to "fill". Hydrogen's economical downside is a more complex system with more parts to assemble. Battery's downside is the cost of large amounts of batteries. In both cases it seems that hydrogen has the upper hand in the short term, if they solve the cost of the fuel cell itself. But in both cases it seems to me like pure batteries have downsides that are likely to improve over time. It would be interesting to know where the break-even point is, given we have a cheap fuel cell. I'm worried that the hydrogen fuel cells are a bit of a blind alley for cars. Heavy trucks and cargo ships is another matter though. But then maybe biofuels aren't so bad if we can just combust them cleanly enough.
- pjc50 10y agoSurely this is the other way round: plug-in electric vehicles are starting to take off on batteries, having the upper hand in the short term. While hydrogen hasn't quite taken off because of the handling difficulties. I think it's more likely we'll see a renewables-to-methanol/ethanol solution than a hydrogen economy. There are various proposed processes for this, including the USAF's nuclear-to-jetfuel one which claims $6/USgal amortised cost.
- maxerickson 10y agoButanol! It has better energy density than ethanol and absorbs less water than ethanol and is not as good a solvent as ethanol (so engine parts last longer).
- ryao 10y agoRenewables to methane probably makes more sense. Methane is cheap and easy to produce. Using it skips the additional step of methane to methanol conversion. There are already plenty of methane powered cars on the road in Europe and a few on the road in the US. Renewable production of methane is already being done at scale by BioSNG in Sweden. This claims that it is not yet competitive with untaxed natural gas from fossil fuels though: http://www.biosng.com/fileadmin/biosng/user/documents/reports/The_Economy_of_Large_Scale_Biomass_to_Bio-Methane.pdf http://www.biosng.com/fileadmin/biosng/user/documents/report... Presumably, the taxes in Sweden are sufficient to make it feasible.
- JATOimpala 10y agoAre people actually amenable to driving cars carrying substantial quantities of pressurized hydrogen and oxygen? It's a bomb on wheels.
- Pigo 10y agoI never considered that. Surely it'd be illegal if a car crash would cause a massive explosion.
- achamayou 10y agoThere's no pressurised oxygen, only hydrogen, the oxygen is extracted from ambient air as needed. If you work out a safety valve system that's good enough (which has presumably been done, since Toyota Mirais are driving around where I live), rapid release should be reasonably safe. Hydrogen is much lighter than air and will evaporate quickly. It's not as safe as diesel, but no worse than gasoline, or even large Lithium batteries.
- spsgtn 10y ago700 atm? I would never drive with a tank of any significant size held at that pressure.
- baldfat 10y agoI have a friend who has been working on Hydrogen and fuel cells since 1999. He told me in 2001 that it was never going to happen for cars and that fuel cells just are not going to pay off except for a few instances that aren't really clear. 2016 he says the same thing. Fuel cells will never be the fuel for cars and no clear viable application. The issue is that you can't just go with hydrogen into a magical filter and split the hydrogen atoms and get energy without it costing multiple more then gas or electric.
- lagadu 10y agoHuh. I always just assumed that hydrogen cars were internal combustion engines, in which they filled a combustion chamber with H2 and burned it off. I'm surprised it's nothing like that. Today I learned.
- alirazaq 10y agoInternal combustion engines tuned for hydrogen fuel also exist. However the benefit of a fuel-cell vehicle is being able to recharge the batteries with the fuel-cells, regenerative braking, or at a charging stations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_internal_combustion_engine_vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_internal_combustion_e...
- eip 10y agoRIP Stan Meyer
- jgamman 10y agoGoogle for the fuel cell handbook from the DOE. Last I looked it was a clear intro. Wrt charge balances and driving force you need to remember this is a 3 phase system- h2 splits, ions migrate, charge balances by electron flow. Product is steam that wafts away so it is reasonable to think of a fuel cell as a battery with replenishable fuel. It's been a long time. I walked away from fuel cells in '02 or so. Nothing has changed and battery tech has completely owned any large scale opportunity