6 ms·
The end of cloud computing [video]
- dboreham 10y agoInteresting. I still remember Ben pitching me the idea of cloud services in 1999. I thought he was insane at the time. I retain this as the proof that I can't reliably evaluate a business idea ;)
- joelbondurant 10y agoThank Spaghetti, AWS is making people stupid.
- bhauer 10y agoI can't wait for the traditional centralized cloud to fade out. I've been anticipating a model I call PAO [1] for several years—personal application omnipresence. By that I mean applications that run for you personally and are available on all your devices simultaneously. We've seen gradual movement away from the traditional cloud with several models I call "proto-PAO," such as Microsoft's Continuum. And many applications provide one-off PAO-like experiences by connecting multiple clients to a central server you administrate. But there is so much more to do. I am definitely getting excited, though, that the centralized cloud will likely be replaced in my lifetime. [1] http://tiamat.tsotech.com/pao http://tiamat.tsotech.com/pao
- ra1n85 10y agoI suspect something similar to this will come to pass, as well. The cloud is appealing for a number of reasons. The two biggest seem to be it takes care of the infrastructure and some of the stack. When and if those become trivial accomplishments, I can see a shift.
- tlow 10y agoVery interesting. I've been thinking of a similar application platform from the perspective of design/preferences/configuration. We've seen only a very limited amount of "personalization" like "personalized search" (or cross-device attribution tracking, call it what you will). But I ask you to consider an omnipresent personal user interface. Now I'm thinking a generation after VR (to a stage where we can generate visual stimuli and recognize thought/movement that manipulates it). Wouldn't it be nice if this interface weren't a hodgepodge of Siri/Google Now/Alexa (all linked to their proprietary systems so you can access their walled garden). I imagine a space for middleware dedicated to serving me, not serving me ads.
- edblarney 10y agoThe traditional model may change, but the cloud will only grow. PAO concept seams neat, and actually buy it - it will happen to some degree. BUT - many features are inherently 'centralized' in their nature, and will be service oriented, and thus they will stay on the cloud. I think we'll see more 'cloud/personal' and more 'IoT' - but the traditional cloud will continue to grow quite rapidly.
- braveo 10y agostrangely enough, I've been expecting that as well, but reading your blog post, I differ on how it will be realized. I think it's more likely people will instead carry identities that describe the applications they have access to, and be able to load those on devices for their identity only, down to the point of being able to walk up to a new PC, attaching the identity, and then having access to the apps on that new PC. It'll be a 90% solution that's forced to deal with DRM and safe enough remote execution, but it'll also allow you to access your documents from anywhere with a connection. I know you specifically disagree with the idea of synchronization, but that's more feasible than what you're suggesting imo. synchronizing a document is going to be as simple as saving it into the cloud and fetching a delta at the endpoints. This will necessarily not work for certain types of applications, no one is probably going to try and do actual CAD work on the go, although they may view it. But for most things it'll work well enough.
- lacampbell 10y agoI thought your article was actually much better than the video linked. I had vaguely thought of something similar before but not in as much detail. If you made a follow up post about what you see as other companies moving towards this PAO and posted it here I think it could spark a really good discussion.
- eranation 10y agoVery interesting and while I think the title is a bit "clickbaity" it has some interesting points. He is not claiming cloud computing is going to disappear, he is claiming that due to real-time requirements and amount of data, computing power at the edge will grow, while SaaS and central data analytics will not stop being centralized in the cloud. He claims the cloud won't handle the vast amount of sensor data and I'm not sure he is right, but can't prove him wrong. In any case it seems that cloud providers are already aiming for this direction. AWS has project greengrass for example: https://aws.amazon.com/greengrass/ https://aws.amazon.com/greengrass/
- rmason 10y agoWhile certainly thought provoking I'm not certain that he is exactly correct. What is going to happen is that there will be a lot of devices where a peer to peer model makes more sense. It doesn't mean that cloud computing is going to go away but it will instead change over time. I am more in agreement with the idea that data analysts jobs will grow. Also think that a lot of apps will have their own databases but instead of ignoring the cloud they will need to occasionally sync with the cloud as opposed to real time access. I think that RESTful data services will become more of a commodity and that most developers will need a data service, an authentication service, a telecom service and a payment service (and perhaps a few more) to construct a program. We're not too far off from it happening and the opportunity exists for an ambitious company to offer a Microsoft Office style suite of services to developers. I'd personally prefer it be Stripe or Twilio as opposed to Microsoft or Google that ends up doing it.
- edblarney 10y agoI really don't buy it. In every case he described current devices (cars, watches) - they are increasing in 'cpu/storage' - but they always have been doing this. Is their something that inherently changes the topology? Not really. Cars will be able to id stop signs - which is naturally a local function, just like 'backup cameras' are a local function today ... but some things like messaging, gps services, customer data, big data - it's going to be on a server somewhere. Why would your car need to talk directly to your blender? 'The cloud' has really more to do with local/small/office servers moving into consolidated centres with virtualization. 'Logical organization' has not changed: some stuff on 'servers' , some stuff done 'locally'.
- dmourati 10y agoMade me think of the difference between the Central Nervous System (CNS) vs Peripheral Nervous System (PNS). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peripheral_nervous_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peripheral_nervous_system
- redwood 10y agoso will the internet be more like a mammal or an octopus? :)
- clusmore 10y agoSo we started with centralized mainframes, because it was too expensive for everybody to have their own computer. As hardware improves, computers become cheaper and more powerful and then everybody can have their own, and we move to a distributed model. Then as internet speeds improve, it becomes practical to bring all the compute back in to centralized data centres and communicate with them over the internet from small, less powerful devices. Then as the hardware improves again, the small devices become powerful enough to perform their own computation. In the talk, he says that the reason we need to do the compute "on the edge" is because the latency between the cloud is insufficient for real-time devices. So what happens when network speeds improve again (better fibre infrastructure, LiFi, etc.)? Will we bring the compute back in to centralized data centres? Will we continue to bounce back and forwards forever, as network and hardware technology leapfrog each other? Is one model better than the other?
- jaredklewis 10y ago> In the talk, he says that the reason we need to do the compute "on the edge" is because the latency between the cloud is insufficient for real-time devices. So what happens when network speeds improve again (better fibre infrastructure, LiFi, etc.)? Will we bring the compute back in to centralized data centres? Will we continue to bounce back and forwards forever, as network and hardware technology leapfrog each other? Is one model better than the other? Well, for one thing, a lot of the examples such as self-driving cars, drones, and any wearable clearly don't allow for use of fiber. Lifi may have some use cases, but again I don't see how Lifi could help something like a drone or self-driving car. But another point is availability. Wireless connections can drop in and out and our vulnerable to being slowed down by increased demand. Not to mention that the centralized service itself may fail, due to catastrophic power failure, DOS attacks, or any number of other reasons. If that centralized service or choppy wireless connection is providing you with your todo-list or family photo album, its probably not a big deal to have occasional outages. If the system is making decisions for self-driving vehicles, that will be an unmitigated disaster. Even if it is only enough logic to help an unconnected car pull over to the side of the road, a self-driving car needs to be able to operate offline, so one way or another, these cards will need powerful computers inside. And of course, distributed nodes can also fail. A single car's computer may fail, and that's not good. But the AI of every car in an entire area failing simultaneously because power to the local radio tower goes out is going to be way worse. The other thing, is that as we have with processing speeds, we will eventually hit limits in bandwidth. Using bandwidth efficiently will become a larger priority (as scarcity increases, so will the cost) and the centralized model clearly has a drawback in terms of bandwidth usage. So, all in all, I don't think it's just a pendulum that swings back in forth forever, but that the future will be a hybrid, but heavily distributed world out of necessity.
- YZF 10y agoIt's an interesting thought experiment but I tend to disagree overall. I don't think a self driving car is a data-center on wheels. It will not have 100(!) servers built in it. It will have one (or two for redundancy) PCBs with just the right enough of processing power in whatever form makes sense, multiple cores, ASICs, etc. (which would be less than 100 server worth). I would agree that the more compute cycles will move out to the edge. This is already have been happening with smartphones and will continue with other intelligent devices. The more computers we have in our environment the more the overall portion of cycles move to the edge. The depiction of a smartphone as a dumb terminal isn't that accurate. A smartphone can and does do a lot of things locally. My bet is there is a lot more compute power in all the phones today than in AWS EC2. (though maybe not compute $'s) The comments on machine learning don't make sense. There is a lot more data for machine learning in the aggregate of all the devices so it will naturally happen in some centralized location. While there can be some machine learning in the edge machine learning is a lot more effective on the aggregate centralized data. So data from the edge will get pulled to central large scale systems. The result of this learning can be pushed back out to the edge to be applied (e.g. in the car). EDIT: He later on modifies his statement about machine learning happening in the edge and rather some "selection" of the data will be used for machine learning in the cloud... Still doesn't quite add up.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoThe edge is limited by power constraints. Only so much computation you can do before your phone melts.
- tomc1985 10y agoMan I'm not even old and history is already repeating itself. Whatever. Down with the cloud!
- miguelrochefort 10y agoThe solution is obvious. Cache not only data, but functions as well. I should be able to download entire systems on local devices (a cache hub, a router, a personal cache hotspot, a smartphone), and have them work offline if necessary. However, this will require a new computing paradigm altogether, powered by a new language. This kind of seamless caching demands a language with superior semantics (API auto-discoversbility) and logic-programming influence. I imagine some kind of predicate store should do the job.
- IanCal 10y agoDo we really need a new language for this? We already have things that run on both server and client, javascript being the obvious one, where there's already a blending of computation for webpage rendering happening (pre-rendered on the server then the code for updating sent to the client).
- redwood 10y agoDid you see AWS's announcement the other week? AWS Lambda functions running on embedded IoT devices.
- _pdp_ 10y agoIs cloud dead? No! Will it die? Probably not because not everyone wants to deal with some of the complexities involved with building the hardware and networks required to achieve near perfect resilience. What will certainly going to happen is that we will see more devices online and many of them will be IOT. ESP8266 can be bought for at little as the cost of a double espresso. The hobby electronics industry is booming in the face of Arduino and Raspberry Pi. It is happening.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoHas anybody dared to research if EPS8266 contains a backdoor? Its origin and mass deployment makes me more than nervous.
- _pdp_ 10y agoWe will reach a point eventually where it will take a lot of investment to deduce if a hardware component contains backdoors. The firmware of the ESP is opensource through.
- zpallin 10y ago"Edge intelligence" is not going to happen in place of the cloud, simply in addition to it. When storage gets smaller in form factor, maybe we will be storing 100s of TBs in a car, but there will still be a data center storing 100s of PBs.