4 ms·
Healthy food does cost a lot more. Fruits and vegetables cost much more per calorie than flour, oil and sugar. A $6 bag of apples has less calories in it than
by maxerickson 10y ago
Healthy food does cost a lot more. Fruits and vegetables cost much more per calorie than flour, oil and sugar.
A $6 bag of apples has less calories in it than a loaf of Wonderbread.
$2 of broccoli has less calories than a $0.30 can of soda.
- lintiness 10y ago... and a $2 bag of celery will consume your stored calories for you! edit: is hn the no joke zone?
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoRe your edit - yes, pretty much. Some humour does win upvotes but it's rare.
- tedajax 10y agoNot to mention the fact that most healthy food is much more perishable and needs to be replenished more frequently.
- jcater 10y agoI think this is the bigger issue. I'd agree that buying healthy options at the grocery store does not have to be more expensive than junk food (or even cheaper), but that's assuming you can plan ahead well enough to not throw away the fresh food once it spoils. Granted, that's a matter of habit, but a hard habit to overcome if you're not used to it. I rarely shop in the middle of the grocery store, except for staples, but I still manage to throw a bit away a week later.
- mrob 10y agoIf you have access to a freezer this isn't a problem. Frozen vegetables are generally better than fresh, because they're picked in peak condition instead of early for better shelf life, and they come pre-cut so they save time. They're usually cheaper too. With the exception of onions which are cheap and have good shelf life fresh, almost all the vegetables I eat are frozen.
- mtw 10y agoHealthy food does not cost more and comparing them by calories is restrictive. If you use the satiety factor, it is possible to eat healthy and spend less. For example, eat oatmeal instead of sugary cereals for breakfast, eat bananas as snacks instead of chips or others, eat beans or brown rice instead of hamburgers for lunches and dinners. Drink water instead of buying diet or sugar beverages. All these (oatmeal, bananas, beans) are healthier and not necessarily more expensive.
- humanrebar 10y agoYou're not factoring in costs in attention, logistics, and (for many people) willpower. "I'm hungry. The bananas are black and we ran out of oatmeal Tuesday. Do I want to do some chores (cook) and then eat rice and beans in an hour or do I want to get a double cheeseburger on sale?" Drinking water and eating less is (for most Americans) much healthier and much cheaper, though.
- pc86 10y agoWhere are you getting soda for $0.30 a can?
- xyclos 10y ago1972
- maxerickson 10y agoWalmart sells a 24 pack of Coke for $8. https://www.walmart.com/ip/Coca-Cola-Cola-12-fl-oz-24-pack/26542540 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Coca-Cola-Cola-12-fl-oz-24-pack/2... Faygo or their store brand will be all the much cheaper.
- jrs235 10y agoI can find soda for $0.30 a can lots of places. When specials are running it's possible to purchase four 12 packs for $11, three 12 packs for $10, a 24 pack for $6, etc. All of these end up being less that $0.30 a can... some even with sales tax included.
- cschneid 10y agoThat's $3.50 / 12pack - which is probably the average around here (non-sale price of $4, sale of $3, or best at $2.50). This is pepsi line at a Krogers, so name-brand product & store.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWow, that's cheap. Name brand soda (specifically I'm talking about Coke) is $6/12 pack normal price here. I'm not sure who buys it at that price though because it goes on sale all the time. The most common sale I see is 3 for $9. Generic soda is obviously much cheaper.
- nitwit005 10y agoYou're comparing a rather strange selection of foods. The cheapest foods per-calorie are the things you see the poor of the word eating: rice, corn meal, beans, etc. You can buy a massive bag of rice for almost nothing, and some countries subsidize that further. When people talk about the poor living on a dollar a day, they're serious. You may notice that the poor eating those foods, and not dramatically more expensive items like soda, aren't getting fat.
- calvano915 10y agoThis is precisely the issue. Calories are important but it's micronutrient adequacy, variety, and balance that matters as much, and arguably more so, in terms of what is healthy. We shouldn't be measuring cost based on calories alone, and we should account for the costs to health from empty calories. From my experience, the significant cost in healthy foods is the time to prep and cook them. I keep it simple by steaming frozen veggies and can eat that repeatedly, but most people prefer a lot more variety in their diet at least in respect to healthy foods.
- rhinoceraptor 10y agoYou can also pad out the calories of vegetables with some fat/oil. It might also help you absorb the fat soluble vitamins.
- pasquinelli 10y agoif you're pricing calories, then yeah, but considering how much unhealthy eating is excess calories then i'm not really sure what we're talking about. a serving of apple will make you feel fuller than a serving of wonderbread. a serving of broccoli will make you feel fuller than a can of soda, at least after you burp. the fact that you've consumed fewer calories in the process is actually the main health benefit. i grocery shop for a family of four. my experience is i can buy as much as i like in the produce section without having much of an effect on the bill, but i have to be careful with meat. i used to be more fretful with fresh fruit, thinking it was really expensive, but the more of that i buy the less of the more expensive stuff i need, and no one's going hungry around here. you're right that bread and the like are cheap, but there's only so much of that a person can eat. when you're talking about the cost of food, that's a fact that needs to be accounted for.
- baldfat 10y agoA banana or apple are MUCH cheaper then a floor, oil and sugar "with fruit" bar. $1.87 Chicken breast or thighs and some spices and vinegar is MUCH cheaper then any pre-processed crap. Take Hamburger Helper you pay $2 for the box and $4.5 for the ground beef your at $6.50. I can cook something with rice a ton cheaper.
- maxerickson 10y agoPasta costs $1 per pound when it is on sale and has 1600 calories per pound. Chicken breast has about 500 calories per pound. So it's 5x the cost per calorie of the price someone would pay if they were shopping price hard. Meat is basically off the table entirely if you are working on keeping price low. Bananas are super cheap though.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoA pouch of instant noodles cost $1 and is a filling meal that I make in the microwave. Honestly, if it wasn't bad for me I'd eat that all the time. That's what I ate growing up.
- sedachv 10y agoA packet of Maruchan ramen with two cans of beans/peas is the most optimal meal I have been able to come up with considering satiety, minimal preparation and clean-up time and effort, and nutrition. Less than $2, years of shelf-life in almost any conditions, and no facilities other than hot water needed.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThere's basically a 10 hour window where a banana actually tastes good. Otherwise it's over ripe or under ripe. That's the reason I never buy bananas.