4 ms·
Good points. Regarding how such people come to influence, you have to remember a lot of people, especially in startups, are not hired through a process at all.
by lordnacho 10y ago
Good points. Regarding how such people come to influence, you have to remember a lot of people, especially in startups, are not hired through a process at all.
I worked with a guy for many years who was as described in this article.
He can't code and he can't do any math, despite holding a phd. He can talk about math and he can talk about code, but we're talking excel level skills when what you need is someone with a modern ML level skillset.
He made all the decisions about which trading strategies were worth pursuing and which ones weren't, despite the presence of plenty of more qualified people.
How could this be? First of all, the boss of the fund did not have the skills to judge who could write a trading strategy, and who couldn't. So he was stuck with recommendations from other people who also didn't have this skill, leading to this hire. He also relied on his bias towards people of his own ethnic group, which benefitted this chap we're talking about greatly.
Essentially, broken feedback. Someone who can't judge relying on the judgement of someone who isn't competent but has his ear.
I'm sure this has happened to a lot of folks. Probably you need a somewhat larger organisation for there to be enough informed people to point fingers, and you need some luck for the culture to be such that a complaint would actually come through rather than be suppressed.
- soVeryTired 10y agoI work in finance and I've seen the same thing happen. I guess it's more common than people realise.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- arvin 10y ago> First of all, the boss of the fund did not have the skills to judge who could write a trading strategy, and who couldn't. The Dunning–Kruger effect in action.
- adekok 10y ago> First of all, the boss of the fund did not have the skills to judge who could write a trading strategy, and who couldn't. So he was stuck with recommendations from other people who also didn't have this skill, leading to this hire. Which is why it's important for managers to understand the technology that they're managing. I ran into this 25 years ago. I knew someone who went to an MBA school. He spoke up at a party and said "I now have great management skills and can manage anyone!". My response was "No, because when you have a technical disagreement in the team, as manager, you have to make the final decision. And if you don't understand the issues, you're left deciding based on what, popularity of the engineers involved?"
- user5994461 10y ago> "No, because when you have a technical disagreement in the team, as manager, you have to make the final decision. And if you don't understand the issues, you're left deciding based on what, popularity of the engineers involved?" And you've just done a mistake by forcing a decision. You've got involved for a thing you didn't know and you didn't research. Right now, you're the least qualified people in the room to take that decision. You should have no say in it.