5 ms·
Twitter May Have Predicted the Election
- thecity2 10y agoWhere's the "predictive" part? Just visualizing twitter networks isn't actually a prediction.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 10y agoSounds like a "prediction" just like the results you get from training your stock picker on historical data.
- pyromine 10y agoAt least you can break your data in to training and testing sets for stock picking, this is just hey guys we found a correlation. 20/20 hindsight is not a prediction.
- thecity2 10y agoExactly. Furthermore, is this company claiming that they can predict electoral college distribution? Because we all well know that Hillary actually won the popular vote. So in fact the popular sentiment was actually on her side. Any analysis claiming that they could predict Trump's victory without even addressing the disparity between popular vote and electoral college is a fail even before it begins.
- AznHisoka 10y agoactually Google Trends predicted it: https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=vote%20for%20hillary,vote%20for%20trump https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=vote%20for%20hillary... it predicted obama as well in 2012 https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=vote%20for%20romney,vote%20for%20obama https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=vote%20for%20romney,...
- artursapek 10y agoInteresting how Hillary is the only one who was referred to by first name. "Vote for Clinton" didn't register as much as "Vote for Hillary"
- rokosbasilisk 10y agomaybe it was to differentiate her from bill clinton?
- adventured 10y agoShe's the only one that had a spouse that was formerly President and or otherwise very famous. Hillary's campaign and supporters heavily marketed her by first name rather than last name to try to bolster her own political identity.
- EdiX 10y agoMy impression is that this was a choice of her campaign (differentiate from Bill Clinton? make her seem friendlier?). Jeb Bush and Bernard Sanders also had campaigns centered around their first names.
- somebodynew 10y agoI find it odd that you refer to "Bernard" when he's almost universally referred to as Bernie, but simultaneously call John Bush "Jeb". I'm missing whatever the intended meaning of the way you wrote these names was.
- artursapek 10y agoHindsight is 20/20
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- the_mitsuhiko 10y agoHow do these people predict the electorial college?
- thecity2 10y agoThey don't. It's a complete PR sham.
- rm999 10y agoRight now 100% of the comments in here are about "predicting" the election, when the word "predict" isn't even used in the article. Probably an over-eager editor who changed the title. The article itself is about a very interesting network analysis of establishment vs non-establishment behavior. I'd like to see more discussion about the content of the article. edit: downvoted within 1 minute for trying to spur interesting discussion past the crappy headline :(
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thecity2 10y ago“Our analysis was showing something, but our beliefs were different,” says Vishal Mishra, CEO of Right Relevance, which sells a research platform focused on influence. “We thought, how is Trump going to win? But our analysis kept showing us.” He doesn't say "predict". But it is very clearly implied.
- opaqe 10y agoI noticed the establishment v. non-est. behavior as well. How much of this network property is really a predictive signal more than an explanation for "shock" at the results? What are the conditions for it being one or the other?
- Jweb_Guru 10y agoAny global predictor that claims to have accurately determined Trump's victory should keep in mind that he lost the popular vote. Only a state-based predictor can be plausibly said to have been able to make such a prediction.
- anigbrowl 10y agoYeah it really comes down to what you base your hunch on. when I saw the first exit poll saying that many voters had opted for a 'strong leader' I knew it was over even thought he polls hadn't closed anywhere. I have a great many hunches and some facility with visualization of directed graphs and other analytics, but am not clear on how to scrape and normalize the datasets I need.
- th0raway 10y agoI've seen one of those predictors. It looked at an honest signal, captured in a way that would be fairly representative of the population at large. Since the data had some location information attached, you could attach every point of signal to a congressional district. The model was simple, comparing the signal per district, and then building an electoral college map. It didn't nail every state, but it wasn't off by much, and gave Trump a slightly smaller victory than he actually had. I won't mention the signal because I want to keep my job. However I'd be surprised if there weren't at least a dozen companies that have access to some honest signal with such a good sample of the population at large as to be better at predicting the election than any pollster.
- lfam 10y agoIt's interesting to think about where to find this information. Big ISPs have access to these "honest" signals on a large scale.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoCould you elaborate on your point? Im not sure I understand.
- 10y ago
- gumby 10y agoOne thing that jumped out at me from this brief article was that the use of the term "media influencers" -- they certainly weren't influencers in the conventional sense of being gatekeepers.
- luluki 10y agoThis makes sense to me. I saw similar things in newspaper comments sections. I have a weird habit of always scrolling to comments sections of news articles. It gives me an interesting snapshot of a huge range of opinions. On political articles, I consistently saw so many comments from Trump supporters, with some consistent threads of opinions (as well as more fringe or extreme ideas) that just weren't being represented strongly enough in the general media. I also of course saw comments from Hillary supporters and Trump haters. Their arguments and thoughts WERE already being represented strongly in the general media - there was not much new that I learned there. Something that Obama hasn't addressed is just how biased our mainstream newspapers and magazines were in the run-up to the election. As someone living in a highly liberal area (and who is not aligned with Trump's politics - before I get criticized to infinity) I felt I gained a lot of understanding for why people were supporting Trump, not from the dozens of mainstream newspaper articles I read each day, but from comments sections. I view that as a media fail. I was the only person of my peer group who was not shocked about Trump's win. I'd also add - the media strategy didn't work. Marginalizing people's voices and points of view - often people who felt marginalized in other ways (economic etc), strengthened their resolve to vote for the person who DID hear them (which was Trump.)
- anigbrowl 10y agoHow much computing power, work and money is it to produce visualizations like this? I'm handy with cytoscape and DAG concepts but I don't know where to get real time datasets like this, or how to automatically construct them for other forums (eg say I wanted to study the social networks on Reddit or HN). Ideally I'd like to be able to work with something like this interactively although real-time operation isn't too important.