14 ms·
There is a difference between being aware events are happening, and researching because I need to make some decision. By your logic, everyone is misinformed bec
by matwood 10y ago
There is a difference between being aware events are happening, and researching because I need to make some decision. By your logic, everyone is misinformed because there is literally an infinite amount of news and sources now. Even when you thought you were informed, you were just as misinformed as anyone else as there was no way you had ready everything.
Regardless, what I was really getting at is following the 24 hour news cycle treadmill is a pointless game. It is far better to get summaries and dive deeper when something interesting comes up and/or you have time. At no point did I talk about drawing conclusions. For those, of course you have to dive in a little deeper and even then you have to be aware those conclusions are only valid until the next bit of information comes out.
Learning to summarize and understanding the limitations of that summarization is a learned skill. We all do it every day.
- barrkel 10y agoYou seem to suggest that being informed vs misinformed is a binary state: that people who consider themselves more informed are also misinformed because they haven't read everything. Being informed is a probabilistic game. Every news source is from a particular perspective, with some bias and some error. But unless they are all ultimately controlled by a conspiracy, or have systematic bias / error, consuming more news sources will increase the amount of correct information one has about the world. There is a definite trend towards being more informed when consuming more news sources, particularly if they are from different ends of the political spectrum but with high reputation for accuracy. Whether being informed is useful to the average citizen most of the time is another question entirely. News as entertainment, hyped headlines, the continuous need for updates that drive 24-hour news - I don't think these things are good for anyone. They always search for sensationalism, always look for a hook that drives an emotional response, outrage, anger, fear, nationalism, racism, bigotry - they appeal to our worst impulses.
- matwood 10y agoI agree with you. I was mainly playing devils advocate with the if you can't read some very large amount of news, it's better to read none. Even then, the sources you pick have to be varied as you say. Reading solely MSNBC or FoxNews for 12 hours a day is not the same as multiple sources.
- nicky0 10y agoMost news sources filter, oversimplify and in some cases actively misrepresent the world to the extent that after consuming a typical news bulletin, you are less informed than you were before. Or at least, more misinformed than informed. Weekly newspapers such as The Economist and The Week are better-than-average news sources.
- jdietrich 10y agoYour third paragraph really contradicts your second. There is indeed a systematic bias in the news media - the preoccupation with rare, sensational, controversial and emotive stories. I would argue that this is one of the fundamental causes of misinformation in modern society. The news media conditions us to be fearful and suspicious, to believe that things are only getting worse. No newspaper would ever run the headline "Majority of People Safe and Prosperous" or "Dems, Reps Agree on Most Things". Nobody would ever read a newspaper that gave an accurate depiction of the world around us, because it would be dismally boring. That's the big lie of the 21st century.
- barrkel 10y agoI think you can triangulate. It's 24-hour news in particular that needs to exaggerate; the bias isn't wholly systematic. Different media sources focus on the fears of different subsets of people, so they'll exaggerate different things. I think these things cancel out too.
- BeetleB 10y ago>There is a difference between being aware events are happening Going off another tangent, if I ever write that essay, I plan to address this point. Why do people follow the news? How much do they need to be aware? For most people, over 95% of the news they are aware of are useless to them. They don't make any (direct) decisions based on them. So why the need to be aware? (Not asking you personally, just bringing up the point in general). (However, while they do not make any decisions, they do draw conclusions much more often, and this can be reflected in where they spend their money, and who they vote for). >By your logic, everyone is misinformed because there is literally an infinite amount of news and sources now. In the pure sense of the word, sure. But the curve is not linear. The shape of the curve is a bit like a shifted sigmoid. If you read a little, you know a little, and much of it may be false. As you read more, you'll hit a threshold where your knowledge goes up dramatically, as well as your ability to remove the false things you heard earlier. When you go even beyond that, the curve becomes very shallow again. You could read forever and keep learning more, but the marginal gain (in knowledge) is minimal. Likewise, the marginal gain in reading just a small amount is minimal as well. >It is far better to get summaries and dive deeper when something interesting comes up and/or you have time. Let me ask you this: Think of the times you did dive deep (and I mean very deep - not just a few hours on a topic, but following every bit of news on it for months). Now compare your knowledge on the topic with the person who only heard it through the NPR sound bites. How often is that person misinformed when you listen to them talk about it? In my experience, it was "often enough". I don't want to say "more than 50% of the time" because I didn't do a thorough study. But it was often enough that I don't kid myself about my knowledge when I listen to NPR news summaries. I have to assume everything they're telling me could be wrong. >At no point did I talk about drawing conclusions. I hope you've asked yourself why you listen to the news. (Again, no need to tell me if you don't want to, just something you should ponder for yourself).
- matwood 10y ago> I hope you've asked yourself why you listen to the news. News comes is a lot of forms. There is gossip, national, world news, and everything in between. Then there is industry specific news carried on sites like this one. I like knowing some amount world news because I like to have perspective on the rest of the world (traveling is another thing I try to do often for the same reason). I also have some family members in the military, so updates on the worlds hot spots is a nice to have. National news is much more likely to impact my day to day, so it's nice to have some idea what's going on. This can be anything from what is currently happening in NC, to the latest economy numbers. I have to admit though, the vitriol on both sides of the election has been one of the driving factors in cutting back on my news post election. Then there is industry specific news and news from sites like HN. Reading random summaries about topics on HN does often help me in my day to day. Many times a problem has come up, and I remember reading about something that may solve the issue. That summary reading becomes a jumping off point for a deeper dive into some new tool or process that may solve problem. > Now compare your knowledge on the topic with the person who only heard it through the NPR sound bites. How often is that person misinformed when you listen to them talk about it? Misinformed or underinformed? Knowing that Aleppo is a city in Syria where there is an ongoing refugee crisis, but not being able to articulate the details of all the players in the battle is underinformed. That's different than thinking there are US troops fighting Russian troops in Aleppo which would be misinformed. I also know that NPR is not going into depth on any topic, but they tend to deliver whatever current facts are out there. Do they have to edit and possibly leave out some facts/stories? Sure, but I do not think they are delivering fake news or anything of the sort. I would love some sources showing NPR purposely reporting non-factual information. Of course, since it comes out ~hourly, it would certainly be possible to report something that was thought a fact at that time, that then later changed. This has gotten a bit long, but I would enjoy reading your essay if you ever get to writing it.