4 ms·
>For me minimalism is about how do I get what I need/want in the least amount of time and as little waste as possible. That's not what minimalism is for most p
by BeetleB 10y ago
>For me minimalism is about how do I get what I need/want in the least amount of time and as little waste as possible.
That's not what minimalism is for most people. I want a lot of things. More than I have time for. Minimalism is about figuring out the marginal value each of those provides and eliminating all but the top x percent.
It's about reducing the stuff you feel you need. Your approach sounds more like you are not doing that.
>I find the 5 minute NPR news briefing podcast from the latest hour is great.
Sorry for changing the topic, but as a former news junkie, I've long wanted to write a lengthy essay on how/why to read the news. If there is one thing I would want people to get out of that essay, it is that when it comes to news, the path of moderation is the one that will make you the most misinformed.
There's so much misinformation out there that the only way I could get an idea of what was going on was to spend many hours a month reading up news from multiple sources, and potentially multiple analyses. Only then would you get a fuller picture. Any given single story was highly likely to be missing or misreporting key information. And certain stories would not be covered by some organizations but covered by others. By listening to a given news outlet, you have no idea what important stories are not being told.
I did this for several years before calling it quits (too much time for not much personal value). But I knew from my past experience with dealing with people who only "scanned" the news (or listed to the news summary on BBC/NPR) that they tended to be quite misinformed. So the only option was to more or less quit altogether.
Even then, a few months later, I found myself having opinions on current events. Why? Because I still randomly scanned newspaper headlines while walking or listened to NPR broadcasts while driving. I had become the misinformed person.
The person who doesn't follow news altogether tends to be less misinformed. They are certainly ignorant, but they have fewer faulty notions.
These days, have I really gone cold turkey? Not really. I do still read/listen to it. But I do it while refusing to draw any conclusions.
Long story short: If you want to follow the news, either do it wholeheartedly or quit. No middle ground in this world.
- matwood 10y agoThere is a difference between being aware events are happening, and researching because I need to make some decision. By your logic, everyone is misinformed because there is literally an infinite amount of news and sources now. Even when you thought you were informed, you were just as misinformed as anyone else as there was no way you had ready everything. Regardless, what I was really getting at is following the 24 hour news cycle treadmill is a pointless game. It is far better to get summaries and dive deeper when something interesting comes up and/or you have time. At no point did I talk about drawing conclusions. For those, of course you have to dive in a little deeper and even then you have to be aware those conclusions are only valid until the next bit of information comes out. Learning to summarize and understanding the limitations of that summarization is a learned skill. We all do it every day.
- barrkel 10y agoYou seem to suggest that being informed vs misinformed is a binary state: that people who consider themselves more informed are also misinformed because they haven't read everything. Being informed is a probabilistic game. Every news source is from a particular perspective, with some bias and some error. But unless they are all ultimately controlled by a conspiracy, or have systematic bias / error, consuming more news sources will increase the amount of correct information one has about the world. There is a definite trend towards being more informed when consuming more news sources, particularly if they are from different ends of the political spectrum but with high reputation for accuracy. Whether being informed is useful to the average citizen most of the time is another question entirely. News as entertainment, hyped headlines, the continuous need for updates that drive 24-hour news - I don't think these things are good for anyone. They always search for sensationalism, always look for a hook that drives an emotional response, outrage, anger, fear, nationalism, racism, bigotry - they appeal to our worst impulses.
- matwood 10y agoI agree with you. I was mainly playing devils advocate with the if you can't read some very large amount of news, it's better to read none. Even then, the sources you pick have to be varied as you say. Reading solely MSNBC or FoxNews for 12 hours a day is not the same as multiple sources.
- nicky0 10y agoMost news sources filter, oversimplify and in some cases actively misrepresent the world to the extent that after consuming a typical news bulletin, you are less informed than you were before. Or at least, more misinformed than informed. Weekly newspapers such as The Economist and The Week are better-than-average news sources.
- barrkel 10y agoThat's why you don't just consume one news bulletin. If you're getting all your information from a single source, you're an ideologue, or will become one.