3 ms·
>Keep this in mind anytime a leader in a country with a high rate of corruption says he sincerely wants to clean things up, but those lower down are stopping hi
by kahrkunne 10y ago
>Keep this in mind anytime a leader in a country with a high rate of corruption says he sincerely wants to clean things up, but those lower down are stopping him from doing so. He is just plain telling a lie.
Doesn't this kind of contradict what you said before, though? The leader needs to allow corruption lest he is overthrown (usually by those lower down such as the military, not the public), so in essence those lower down are preventing him from cleaning up.
There really is no winning here - being a leader means pandering to the people below you, because if you don't they can just get rid of you. In a democracy this problem is partly solved by switching leaders often and dividing the power of the underlings over the entire population, but the dynamic still very much exists. And of course, in a country with no democracy it's many times worse (and very difficult to establish a democracy).
Don't automatically assume that dictators always have bad intentions - they are trapped in a system too.
Of course that doesn't mean that China isn't doing a bad thing here, I was just speaking generally.
- nercht12 10y agoAh, such is the nature of communism - eyes watching each other. China could use a Gorbachev (ok, so the situation is more complicated than that, but still...).
- woodandsteel 10y agoYes, you are quite right that the dictator is trapped by the system, and I should have explained that. But the dictator still lies, because he doesn't explain the system, but instead falsely tells the public he really is trying to eliminate corruption and that those below him are simply refusing to follow his orders. That is what Putin, for instance, is saying. As for China, this has been the system for a long time. Xi Jinping says he is trying to fix it, and seems to be making some progress, but I not sure how things are going to go in the long term. My impression is that clean government usually requires a strong civil society that supports it, and in China that is resisted as threatening the central authoritarian government.