6 ms·
How Albuquerque helped its homeless population and saved money in the process
- tomsthumb 10y agoThis and the similar initiative in Utah are the kinds of governmental problem solving I really like to see. More effective services for the populace in the form of helping people better their lives while at the same time benefitting society at large and being less expensive than traditional approaches. I count myself reasonably liberal, but these type of solutions have largely popped up in traditionally conservative places, which is a pleasant surprise and makes me take another look at my understanding of the spectrum.
- ianai 10y agoI think this has more to do with the nature of Albuquerque than republican/democrat. This as someone who grew up there. I now live in Las Vegas. The two cultures are very different. There's a lot of hostility in LV in a general sense that isn't there in Alb.
- tomcam 10y agoI'd like to hear more about this.
- Avshalom 10y agoAlbuquerque is deeply Catholic. Catholicism, Latin American Catholicism in particular is very big on social/economic justice, charity, 'works theology' Albuquerque (NM as a whole really) is quite poor and it's a lot easier to convince poor people to help poor people.
- mcone 10y agoI lived in Albuquerque for nine years (2003-2012). The Catholicism is certainly part of it, but it's more complicated than that. One gets the feeling that it's a more egalitarian city than other US metro areas. I didn't feel like it was that racist of a city, certainly nothing compared to Pittsburgh, where I now live. And there are very few establishments that are designed exclusively for the wealthy. The Frontier restaurant near UNM is a great example of what I'm talking about. You would regularly see news anchors, professors, doctors, etc. dining there in the same room as people who were homeless.
- komaromy 10y ago> And there are very few establishments that are designed exclusively for the wealthy. This is an excellent description. Some people still flaunt their wealth, which is true everywhere, but I feel a sense of the city belonging to everyone that lives in it. Of course, that's my view as a fairly well-off white male who's never experienced anything close to homelessness. People from different circumstances may have different opinions.
- ianai 10y agoYou can still find those places in Alb and the rest of NM. They have a hard time establishing a real presence though, as there really aren't so many people there. It still needs more industry/business. Something to pull the average income up and employ everybody.
- ianai 10y agoHow come you left?
- batbomb 10y agoFor the most part, there's also very little geographic separation between the poorer parts and the richer parts, unless you end up east of Tramway or north of Paseo. This does tend to mean a bit more property crime, but for the most part people are relatively accepting of that. There are still parts that are a bit scary (south valley, south of central especially around Zuni/San Pedro) but it's not that scary if you are from Abq. As for the racism, a lot of that goes back to the makeup of Abq historically and today, with an extremely diverse (and distributed!) population that most places can't match.
- smelendez 10y agoI think they're also places with cheap land reasonably near the city center (look at some of these housing prices: http://www.zillow.com/albuquerque-nm/home-values/ http://www.zillow.com/albuquerque-nm/home-values/). I don't know where you could easily build tiny houses or any other kind of new public housing anywhere near NY or SF.
- saryant 10y agoLook at the efforts San Antonio has been making over the last decade to help the homeless mentally ill. They've gone from having virtually no system in place to being on the vanguard: https://apps.bostonglobe.com/spotlight/the-desperate-and-the-dead/series/solutions https://apps.bostonglobe.com/spotlight/the-desperate-and-the...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- devoply 10y agoMost problems that have hard line solutions, i.e. drugs and crime, have much cheaper alternatives which are usually much less hard line and much more humane. This also includes a lot of hard line management theories about how to get the most work out of workers. Better and more humane treatment of people usually leads to better and cheaper results... and better overall outcomes. These are usually arrived at by idealists and dismissed by rationalists and supposed realists.
- gaspar 10y agoIt is mind-boggling that one of the richest countries in the world and definitely the most powerful one has such a big problem with homeless people. My first impression when I came to US 4 years ago and in CA specifically was the amount of homeless people. I have not seen so many even in my home country that has a LOT of illegal immigrants. So far I have not seen any progress, at least in the state of CA. Does anyone know if those people are doing that by choice, is the system "punishing" the people that made a bad choice maybe in the past and lost everything, is it something else ? I have heard that it is very difficult to find a new job once you reach that level, not because you don't want to, but because of formalities (e.g. no home address, etc). Is that true ? It is not fair for people to not be able to sleep under a roof or to not be able to have food and clean water (see Africa), and at the same time to have so many technological advances and to have so many millionaires/billionaires that care only about their pockets.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoIt's just a very hard problem to deal with, and places like CA attract homeless people from other places, because they have good services. The US lacks a comprehensive national plan to deal with homelessness. Part of the problem is that even when services exist, they're often fragmented and hard to administer. That's what led to ideas like "Housing First", where they've found just providing a home for a year fixes most homelessness problems (particularly when combined with other services). Having a home gives them a base to operate from to organize the rest of the services, finding a job, etc. Part of the problem is that the US doesnt have a good plan for what to do with crazy people. We had a lot of problems with long-term institutions, but when we shut them down, we didn't actually start a new solution. We just left them on the streets. Part of it is just social myth that people deserve their caste. If the homeless don't deserve their place in the increasingly vitrified social system, then perhaps the wealthy and powerful don't either, and so a large amount of anti-poor propaganda has been generated in the US by the elite.
- tcj_phx 10y ago> places like CA attract homeless people from other places, because they have good services. California's winter weather is more survivable than most parts of the country. > Part of the problem is that the US doesnt have a good plan for what to do with crazy people. We had a lot of problems with long-term institutions, but when we shut them down, we didn't actually start a new solution. We just left them on the streets. Institutions were replaced with drugs. In 'Anatomy of an Epidemic' [1], Robert Whitaker says that before the drugs were available, many people were able to recover enough to get out of the institutions. The book makes the case that commonly-used psychotropic drugs take an episodic illness and make it chronic. [1] https://www.madinamerica.com/anatomy-of-an-epidemic/ https://www.madinamerica.com/anatomy-of-an-epidemic/ This HN submission was from 2 days ago: Psychiatrists Must Face Possibility That Medications Hurt More Than They Help (scientificamerican.com) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13186201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13186201 This has been my observation of the system... My friend was doing well until they got hold of her.
- coldcode 10y agoHopefully next year the Federal and State money won't vanish. This is the kind of problem best solved locally, but it still requires money from somewhere.
- ilaksh 10y agoCan we really not afford to provide very small homes (like tiny home villages) to all of the homeless (rather than just the most likely to die)? I think the biggest issue people would have with that is that people might take advantage. Certainly some would. But would there be so many that we couldn't sustain it, or that it would not match the benefit of having very few homeless? It seems like there is just a very tiny amount of money available for these types of efforts. I really wonder why that is.
- webaholic 10y agoThat's called the projects.. check them out
- closeparen 10y agoWe tried this. It went poorly. [0] The currently favored approach is to require developers of new (usually luxury, since that is the only kind of apartment building that gets built) apartment buildings to provide a percentage of units at far below market rents to people on a lottery/waiting list system. But there aren't nearly enough such units (or units of any kind) to take care of everyone. [0] http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-35913577 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-35913577
- Broken_Hippo 10y agothe biggest fear with some of this is that we tend to build public housing and then it turns into some sort of slum with heavy police presence. While I agree tiny housing is usually better than no housing at all, I fear for what it will become in medium to larger cities. If there is a way to mix in these small properties into an area and have mixed-sized housing, I think this would help the issue greatly - but the logistics and politics to make neighborhoods such seems too high of a bar in most places.
- internaut 10y agoWhat I notice (since we're talking about 'Projects' it seems relevant) is that there is a very low take up of the Tiny House concept among the black population which mostly inhabits social housing schemes similar to the Projects. The next smallest group is working class whites but this group is still influential in the movement. This is curious because a self built Tiny House is very affordable. You can build one of these for less than 10k: https://www.tinyhomebuilders.com/images/products/simple-living-tiny-house-exterior-1.jpg https://www.tinyhomebuilders.com/images/products/simple-livi... This is important because any social housing policy designed to decrease poverty requires a large amount of 'buy-in' or goodwill by the residents or it shall fail. There is of course the question of land for THs, but that thorny issue has already been overcome by most Tiny House people in a variety of ways I won't list here, although I admit it is a serious concern. I went in search of a black person who lived in a Tiny House. She had immediately understood the nature of the question and said a bunch of things on the subject, what stood out is that you might be able to sell the idea of being frugal, minimalist, eco-friendly, outright home ownership i.e. autonomy, practicality and economy to the majority white population that makes up the Tiny House movement e.g. poor students and downsizing retirees, but selling the same ideas to the black population is a very difficult sell. http://tinyhousetrailblazers.com/2016/07/where-are-all-the-black-people-in-the-tiny-house-movement/ http://tinyhousetrailblazers.com/2016/07/where-are-all-the-b... She said while many of the whites are coming from the suburbs i.e. been there, done that, the American Dream for blacks remains to have a big house with its associated trappings. That is when they know they have 'made it'. It follows that a re-imagining of the American Dream is necessary for the black population, just as has been happening for the people in the Tiny House movement, but different. Where I don't concur with Miss Pearson, is that I think this is regression. For individuals it is a good adaption, yes, but the net affect on a society is indeed regression. Big Questions need to be asked about why that's happening.
- snarf21 10y agoThis is such a hard problem to solve and there will only be less and less money for it. It is a good approach to start helping people to help themselves, rather than saying "we'll help you AFTER you fix your hardest problems yourself.". This makes no sense and doesn't work. As shown here and in other cities (http://gladwell.com/million-dollar-murray/ http://gladwell.com/million-dollar-murray/), leaving homeless until they get so bad that they need ambulance and ER services is VERY expensive. In our local town, the major hospital group did an experiment. They took a look at the top 50 patients that used the most of their ER and other services. They hired people whose job it was to make sure they stayed on track, got them to appointments (rides and public transport are big issues), made sure they stayed on their meds and followed treatment plans. It was a great success. They used ~70% of the resources that they used before. BUT, the hospital made lots of money on the use of those services, the experiment cost the hospital almost $1M!! It was not continued as hospitals exist to make money not help people. So let's say a city takes a stance to be progressive and helps their homeless and (largely) gets them back on their feet. Pretty soon everyone in the surrounding areas hear about all the help and services and now one small town is dealing with all homeless that can get to this town. Smaller towns only have so much money to invest in an effort such as this. Additionally, what all jobs can you find to give all these people at $9/hour? There are only so many things you can have them do before you start cutting municipal jobs to create work and putting others on unemployment. I saw a program several years ago where people that came into some of these programs, were set up with social security disability (especially those with mental issues and substance abuse issues) and give them a home base to get other program support. At least this uses federal resources and doesn't put such a strain on the local municipal budgets and resources. This is a completely solvable problem but it takes a tremendous commitment of will. The other issue is that homeless don't vote. It is a problem that has to get fixed because it is the right thing to do, there is little political gain or public outcry in most cities. It is more expedient to work on issues like creating blue collar jobs and healthcare because of the public opinion payoff. Just my two cents.....