9 ms·
I went to business school (top European) as part of my engineering degree. They actually do make a point of mentioning that there's more than one philosophy of
by lordnacho 10y ago
I went to business school (top European) as part of my engineering degree.
They actually do make a point of mentioning that there's more than one philosophy of management. For instance, in the Germanic world, it's common to promote managers from the ranks of whatever business is being managed, whereas it's a bit of an anglo thing to have a "manager" who is somewhat business agnostic.
But of course there's a problem. If you tell people they need specific experience in the car industry to be a car industry manager, or as a software dev to manage devs, then WTF are you doing in a business school? Especially as an undergrad? You gonna manage the student bar?
So then when it comes to all the case studies, you have to kid yourself that what happened to Betamax in the 1980s is going to be relevant to you in 2016. It's interesting to read all this historical "strategy" stuff, but the students I hung out with (being engineers, technically competent and skeptical of BS) tended to see them as something akin to a history class. Sure there are lessons, but a lot of it is just interpretation and conjecture. Nothing in it with the rigour of an engineering course.
As to why MBAs are useful, it seems it's really a question of signalling. If you pay a few hundred grand in fees, rent, and opportunity cost to do an MBA, you probably have some motivation. And there is some value in generic management; not every line of business requires deep technical knowledge, and those are fine for hiring some guy who's happy to work long hours and fly around a lot. It's a problem for something like software dev though.
- icebraining 10y agoMost people I know with an MBA (which, granted, it's less than 10) got it after working for a few years in some industry (including software). The concept of a business school, and of gaining more general business/management knowledge that you can evaluate under your experience as a professional, seems reasonable.
- wpietri 10y agoExcellent points. > whereas it's a bit of an anglo thing to have a "manager" who is somewhat business agnostic I now see this as a piece of a self-justifying ideology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Managerialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Managerialism A while back I read an eye-opening book called "Confronting Managerialism: How the Business Elite and Their Schools Threw Our Lives Out of Balance". [1] They see US-style management as a primarily a caste system. One of the odd things about business in the US is that most people can't even conceive that there are other approaches to business beyond the standard US MBA dogmas. Even when those other approaches clearly are successful, and even when one's ass is getting kicked by somebody using them. E.g, Amazon, which has been crushing competitors for nearly 20 years by ignoring short-term numbers and focusing on creating long-term customer value. Or Toyota, which went from a nearly-bankrupt company in war-ravaged Japan to the world's dominant car maker using a totally different philosophy of business. Toyota even took one of GM's worst plants as part of a joint venture and made it one of the best ones, but GM couldn't absorb the lessons. This American Life did a very moving piece about that plant. [2] [1] https://www.amazon.com/Confronting-Managerialism-Business-Economic-Controversies/dp/178032071X https://www.amazon.com/Confronting-Managerialism-Business-Ec... [2] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/561 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/561
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Toyota even took one of GM's worst plants as part of a joint venture and made it one of the best ones, but GM couldn't absorb the lessons. This American Life did a very moving piece about that plant. Which was closed in 2010, and purchased by Tesla.
- otoburb 10y ago>>One of the odd things about business in the US is that most people can't even conceive that there are other approaches to business beyond the standard US MBA dogmas. Even when those other approaches clearly are successful, and even when one's ass is getting kicked by somebody using them. I appreciate the comment, but your Amazon example was jarring because it seems that HN does not like Amazon's culture in part due to the dominance of MBAs in the senior management ranks. This anecdata aligns with graduation numbers across some of the top 20 US business schools in 2015, and one would presume this leads to an overwhelmingly US MBA-centric Amazon management style, albeit one that may be different than "other" US MBA dogma.[1] [1] http://qz.com/636539/amazon-is-hiring-the-most-mbas-in-tech-and-its-not-really-close/ http://qz.com/636539/amazon-is-hiring-the-most-mbas-in-tech-...
- wpietri 10y agoYeah, I don't know much about Amazon's internals. I'm pointing more at the way analysts have been saying for 15 years that Bezos isn't focused enough on quarterly profits, isn't returning enough to the shareholders, invests too much in long-term pipe dreams. But Kindle, AWS, and Prime have turned out to be giant competitive advantages.
- aserafini 10y agoThey're not a good example because Amazon is full of MBAs at the middle management and even individual contributor level. But I agree with the general point that 'conventional' business wisdom might not lead you to Amazon's strategy.
- 10y ago