6 ms·
Why So Few Resisted Hitler
- molloy 10y agoTo those wanting to avoid the paywall, click the 'web' link under the submission title.
- agumonkey 10y agoDidn't even realize there was one. Thanks a ton. ps: experimental printfriendly.com pdf sharing http://pdf.printfriendly.com/pdfs/1482008632_de749b/download http://pdf.printfriendly.com/pdfs/1482008632_de749b/download pps: reminds me of that article shared on HN not long ago http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2011/09/23/the-milo-criterion/ http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2011/09/23/the-milo-criterion/ limits of system evolution
- amelius 10y agoThis link doesn't work for me, but I must confess that I first clicked the original link. Has WSJ started to block users that try to be smart?
- bsder 10y agoThe web link doesn't work for me on Firefox but does under Chrome. It could be some sort of browser sniffing or ad blocking detection as well.
- jrs235 10y agoRight click the link and open in incognito or private mode. Sites will display the article when coming directly from google if you don't have certain cookies from prior visits. Private/incognito ensures the cookies "dont exist".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smnscu 10y ago1st comment on the article > there are among even the most terrifying of targeted massacres such as during the regime of pol pot or the misery of rwanda nothing comparable to the holocaust. Jewish children were being hanged from windows in the neighborhoods of germans whose neighbors knew the families. the german people eagerly and happily enjoyed herr hitler and his band of sick psychopaths and perverts and lest we forget to mention it, drug addicts. those who stood against these crimes were murdered along with the Jews. beyond everything, it was the automation and the mechanization of killing innocent Jewish german citizens and gassing and hanging 1.5 million little Jewish children with great purposefulness that gives the german inquisition its special ignoble bloodstamp on history. we have the evidence of the smiling laughing hitler saluting audiences crammed together because there were hardly spaces large enough to hold them all. don't use the word comparable. just don't.
- robotresearcher 10y ago> don't use the word comparable. The only occurrence of the string 'compar' in the article: "Mr. Fritzsche [the author of the book described] does not labor this point by comparing the situation with those that came after..."
- dunkelsten 10y agoWhy do jews always think they're such special flowers? There's virtually no difference in the brutality of atrocities compared to Darfur, Armenia or what the IS is doing. The only difference was sheer magnitude and ruthless execution - with uncompromising German efficiency.
- chillingeffect 10y agoSympathy for their genocide over other genocides has numerous causes. Mainly, it's because of American relation to it. We saved them, so we like hearing about it. It also bolsters Christian bias in American politics. Still, it was very bad. We would probably have more perspective as a human phenomenon rather than a European one on it if additional genocides were explicated.
- 10y ago
- mrle 10y agohow could Germany recover so fast after World War 1 ? and build autobanhs, car industry, weapon industry etc.. follow the money and find out. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/sep/25/usa.secondworldwar https://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/sep/25/usa.secondworl...
- bad_user 10y agoWestern Germany recovered well from WWII, with western help of course, but then they recovered from the recession that followed the fall of the Berlin Wall and now they are again the first in EU by GDP. Even with the help received, you have to admit that they are the kind of people that have the resources to recover from disaster. And Hitler, along with a second industrial war, was inevitable. I'll even go as far as saying that we were lucky that Hitler happened, because one can argue that he made a lot of tactical mistakes and in other circumstances the Axis might have won. And I hope we learned something from it, though judging by 2016 I have my doubts.
- lossolo 10y ago"Being a lover of freedom, when the revolution came in Germany, I looked to the universities to defend it, knowing that they had always boasted of their devotion to the cause of truth; but, no, the universities immediately were silenced. Then I looked to the great editors of the newspapers whose flaming editorials in days gone by had proclaimed their love of freedom; but they, like the universities, were silenced in a few short weeks. . . . "Only the Church stood squarely across the path of Hitler's campaign for suppressing truth. I never had any special interest in the Church before, but now I feel a great affection and admiration because the Church alone has had the courage and persistence to stand for intellectual truth and moral freedom. I am forced thus to confess that what I once despised I now praise unreservedly." Albert Einstein
- apsec112 10y agoThis quote is mostly fake: http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/06-01-05/ http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/06-01-05/ The actual history, though, is very interesting. Here's the Wikipedia article on the agreement between Nazi Germany and the Catholic Church: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichskonkordat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichskonkordat
- candiodari 10y agoThey would back out of the agreement later, and the pope also denounced the Nazi and Italian regimes that surround and protected the Vatican. Saying that the Vatican compromised is ridiculous, given that they were willing, with thousands of guns aimed at them, to denounce the actions of the people holding those guns, and even take direct legal and illegal actions to sabotage them, such as providing "fake/real" visas (real in the sense that a state issued them, but with false names, false details, "proof" they weren't Jewish, etc), physically hiding Jews, falsify medical documents (Nazis executed cripples and metal patients first), falsify school records, threaten to shut down Rome in protest, the Vatican escape network, all on an enormous scale. The Vatican was, for years, the only organised resistance against the Nazis. And yes, those guns didn't fire as a result of their actions, or at least, not at the Vatican itself (they did shoot plenty of members of the lower ranks of the Catholic church. They got "the honor" of having their own section inside Auschwitz, with "special attention" of the guards. The rumour is that imprisoned priests physically shivered any time any rumour of actions of the Church made it to the inmates, for that special attention of the guards was sure to follow. Most of the people in there had committed crimes to save people from those camps, knowing the consequences, and less than 20% survived those consequences). Would you be willing to violate the law to save a few people you don't like knowing there's an 80 percent chance it'll cost you your life ? But yes, they're a European state and they will negotiate and talk to whatever government comes to power anywhere in Europe. They even hosted Hitler's ambassador (and used him to protect Italian Jews). As a leader of an organisation, would you be willing to organize crimes against the government if it did things you believe unjust ? Would you be willing and able to have an organisation continue those crimes when it's people were being executed ? I don't think any of us can imagine what running organisations like the Catholic church, or any other resistance on the mainland, must have been like. Here's a more complete summary: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/anti-semitism/piusdef.html http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/anti-semitism/pi... It is very easy to sit in 2016 and say that everyone saw it coming and anyone who didn't respond, did so out of cowardice or outright malice. This isn't true. Self-preservation was by far the main driver of most people's actions. Why did "so few resist Hitler". Here's a video from yesterday : http://deredactie.be/cm/vrtnieuws/videozone/programmas/journaal/2.47879?video=1.2846435 http://deredactie.be/cm/vrtnieuws/videozone/programmas/journ... (seems to be censored on youtube, or at least, I can't seem to find videos with the massive crowds cheering his "I killed those dumb criminals" statements. The -many- videos showing Duterte's people arriving on motorcycles to people's homes dragging men and women out of their homes, sometimes leaving behind crying children, are disappearing fast. Here's a video with some -shocking- imagery about what's happening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atuqx5Ubr5o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atuqx5Ubr5o watch it, because all these videos become "not available" within a few days) The socialist international celebrated the membership of the Nazis to their organisation in 1938 and were unwilling to kick them out until 1940. Or should we point out that members of American academia were publishing articles in New York in support of the Nazis in ... april 1941 (a time when rumours of the holocaust would have known far and wide, even if the scale and cruelty was still hidden, the article in fact mentions and dismisses the rumours as not something leftists would do). The exact authors were leftist, but let's not kid ourselves, it doesn't matter, because both left and right on the American side were mostly in favor of leaving Europe be at the time. Or perhaps we should point out that the leader of islam, the Mufti of Jerusalem, Mohammad Amin al-Husayni, at the time organised a few extra Jew-hunting SS divisions manned by muslims for the Nazis (21st Waffen Mountain Division of the SS Skanderbeg, 13th Waffen Mountain Division of the SS Handschar, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HfLvP2jTVq8&bpctr=1482035683 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HfLvP2jTVq8&bpctr=1482035683 ) ? Islam, the organisation, recruited for the SS ! They recruited Jew-hunters knowingly. They did this, incidentally, when they already knew about the holocaust (even if of course it wasn't officially confirmed at the time). This [1] is an islamic SS division logo. I feel also obliged to point out that the leader of islam did this partly to protect muslims in Yugoslavia, partly to gain political control of Albania and parts of Yugoslavia, and ... partly to eliminate Jews. A lot of things happened because of alliances with the Nazis. At least 4 Northwest European universities (most, but not all, of the atheist ones) have their existence to thank from an alliance between them and the Nazis. At least one university has it's existence to thank to vehement disagreement with the nazis (a set of professors so unwilling to even talk to the nazis that they left their university when the Dean did talk to the nazis and worked for free for years to create a new university - and yes, they were French Catholics (and beggars, for the last 2 of those years). And no, that was not their only motivation, just the main one). The dutch state, including several parties currently in power, were allied with the Nazis. I believe it's 3 current ministers were mentored by people who personally allied with the Nazis. For decades, several Kapo (let's just say that means particularly bad collaborators) held high offices in the Netherlands. More telling is that this is not of any real concern to the population. Similar things can be said about the Austrian, Swiss, Italian and even Greek states, and ... About the US government, IBM, with explicit permission from the US government (they asked), provided the system that did the bookkeeping for the holocaust. They even programmed the rules for deciding if someone was sufficiently Jewish to be sent to the gas chambers. Yes, seriously, IBM was the organisation that made, for millions of people, the decision if they were to be ethnically purified for being "too Jewish" or not. They didn't make the rules, but they executed them. You are trying to push an absolutist moral view upon a situation where people needed to compromise with adversaries with an army that were willing to commit mass-murder to push their point. You'll find that there are people and organisations you work with today that owe their social/financial position to the Nazis directly and indirectly. Furthermore, you are demanding a moral standard that just isn't reasonable. Some of the people mentioned above did what they did because the alternative was death. Yes, after the war anyone that wasn't willing to sacrifice their own life to sabotage the Nazis was persecuted because of that. This is not a reasonable standard, and let's not pretend it is. But frankly, the Catholic church behaved incredibly better than anything else in Europe in the runup and during the war. They put themselves above religious differences. Were they perfect ? No. Wasn't possible. But they helped far more than anyone could expect of them and they paid an extreme price for providing that help. Tens of thousands of catholics, priests, monks, and volunteers were executed because they participated in resistance organised from within the catholic church. Most of those would have been aware of the risk of being executed, and can therefore be said to have willingly sacrificed their lives. Hundreds of thousands of members of the Catholic church resisted the Nazis, at risk of their lives, and did not get caught. The Vatican saved more lives than all other organisations put together, by between one and two orders of magnitude. And, as illustrated above, the same can NOT be said of either states, other religions, political parties, including many that still exist today. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13th_Waffen_Mountain_Division_of_the_SS_Handschar_(1st_Croatian)#/media/File:13th_SS_Division_Logo.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13th_Waffen_Mountain_Division_...
- Manglano 10y agoAn ignorant person will always choose to commit an act of violence towards another to protect against uncertainty. To resist this urge and live with uncertainty is a form of wisdom.
- danharaj 10y agoIt's easy to succumb to the nihilism in the face of fascism because it is an ideology that is unencumbered by truth or meaning. People like to think that if they could just have a conversation with a fascist and reason with them that they could convince them otherwise. When all the reason in the world does not stem the tide of fascism, one becomes disillusioned with the ideals of the enlightenment. Fascism is the antithesis of the enlightenment: fascism is the full embrace of the stupidity of violence and domination. It is rooted in that fundamental basis of social order which few examine critically. We all would like to believe that our civilization has gone far beyond the point where it is brute violence that decides social truth, and when fascism rises it lifts with it the veil that allows us to entertain such fantasies. When all of the things we were taught are the basis of society seem to be completely worthless in the face of fascism's brutality, how could we but not feel helpless and passive? Here's an excerpt from Sartre's Anti-semite and Jew [1]. I think it's illuminating: The anti‐Semite has chosen hate because hate is a faith; at the outset he has chosen to devaluate words and reasons. How entirely at ease he feels as a result. How futile and frivolous discussions about the rights of the Jew appear to him. He has placed himself on other ground from the beginning. If out of courtesy he consents for a moment to defend his point of view, he lends himself but does not give himself. He tries simply to project his intuitive certainty onto the plane of discourse. I mentioned awhile back some remarks by anti‐Semites, all of them absurd: "I hate Jews because they make servants insubordinate, because a Jewish furrier robbed me, etc." Never believe that anti‐ Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti‐Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past. It is not that they are afraid of being convinced. They fear only to appear ridiculous or to prejudice by their embarrassment their hope of winning over some third person to their side. In order to resist fascism one has to have the conviction to fight for something that fascism seeks to destroy. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Anti-Semite-Jew-Exploration-Etiology-Hate/dp/0805210474 https://www.amazon.com/Anti-Semite-Jew-Exploration-Etiology-...
- autocorr 10y agoOne thing I found surprising after researching Hitler's rise to power was that he in fact did not achieve a large majority of seats in the Reichstag before seizing power or was overwhelmingly popular. In the 1932 German Federal election, the last free and fair before Hitler took power, the Nazi party only achieved 33% of seats in the Reichstag [0]. Hitler and the Nazi party also gained power within the framework of the Weimar Republic (ie not a direct military coup). My understanding is that this was possible because the communists did not view the Nazi's as the primary threat, but rather the moderate socialist parties, and also some very poor judgement by the Nationalist-Conservative party to form a coalition with the Nazis. With that coalition, the Enabling Act was passed giving Hitler dictatorial powers, and things snow-balled from there. I know this is kind off-topic, given that the article is about this guys new book, but I've been diving more into modern history after studying mostly ancient and world history. Perhaps some other knowledgeable people can point to good resources on WW2 history? On WW1, I found "The Fall of the Ottomans", "The Sleepwalkers", and "The Guns of August" very insightful, but there are just so many resources for WW2. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_federal_election,_November_1932 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_federal_election,_Novem...
- ivan_ah 10y agoThis was on HN recently, not a history book but interesting insights about corporate power and deals with the Nazi party https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-supermanagerial-reich/ https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-supermanagerial-reic...
- c54 10y agoOut of curiosity to the way HN works -- why was this post flagged?
- euyyn 10y agoI guess the "no politics" ban is still in effect?
- grzm 10y agoPolitical Detox Week is over. It was terminated early, but would have been over by now regardless. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13131251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13131251
- grzm 10y agoLikely users flagging it because of the low likelihood of, on balance, decent discussion. High likelihood of flame wars.
- twoquestions 10y agoTrump supporters may also feel this story is directed at them personally, and feel offended.
- tumbas 10y agolatin heretics were doing genocide for 10 centuries it is same to them as telling kind words once they rounded up free masons across europe they just did like they always did now there is more mass media so it is different why do people don't resist Obama or Merkel or British now