10 ms·
American Firms Want to Keep Older Workers a Bit Longer
- ryandrake 10y ago> With 10,000 baby boomers turning 65 each day, businesses are scrambling to find ways to slow an exodus of the most experienced employees and ensure that they pass along their knowledge before they leave. Knowledge transfer should be baked into the day-to-day culture of work, not something desperately scrambled for during someone's last week. Those few companies with meaningful training and mentoring programs know this. > The plant [...] has an apprentice program for millennials, but there’s a shortage of Generation X workers. “We’ve got a big gap in the middle, so we have to keep talented people in their 60s a little longer,” Here we go again with the "shortage of workers". In one article it's tech workers. Here it's GenX workers. A "shortage" of a good is pretty meaningless if you don't mention the price you're offering to pay for that good. Unless they're saying they literally can't find qualified GenX workers at any price--That would be a real shortage. Otherwise, maybe you need to just offer a little more money to find skilled mid-career workers nowadays. With so many people under-employed or out of work, it borders on insulting to claim there's a shortage of workers.
- Avshalom 10y ago>Unless they're saying they literally can't find qualified GenX workers at any price--That would be a real shortage Pretty sure they mean they have plenty of 60 years who have been working there for 40 years and plenty of 20 year olds who just started but not a lot of 40 year old with 20 years experience to keep the transfer of knowledge smooth. which unless some one has a time machine is a thing you can't find at literally any price.
- taprun 10y agoThis reminds me of agile. Look at the short term, do what you need to achieve those objectives. Oh, the long term matters now. Ooops, I'll add get some "20-years experience guys" to the next sprint.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 10y agoPresumably there are people with industry experience, just not experience in your particular company, and they would easily integrate (there are of course exceptions). It then again becomes a matter of how much are you willing to pay to attract them. Additionally, you could pay extra for a substandard 30 year experience person or an excellent 10-15 year person to fill those gaps. This is supply and demand.
- kaspm 10y agoBased on some of the other commenters, depending on the industry there may NOT be people with industry experience because of the layoffs and hiring ramps of the 80s and 90s at certain types of companies, people in the middle never gained the 20 years of experience in that field
- madengr 10y agoExactly, I'm the rare 45 YO in sea of 20 and 60 YO, and those two groups do not get along.
- noonespecial 10y agoIt reminds me of the Porsche 911 shortage I'm facing around here. I've been to dealer after dealer and I just can't find one who'll sell me one. I've got the $33k that I'm told an average new car costs and am ready to buy today... but nothing. You can't say shortage without factoring price. For enough money (probably not even that much compared to what I've seen business waste on frivolities) there'd be a line of retirees looking to get back into the biz.
- yarou 10y agoMy father used to tell me stories about the days when India was heavily aligned with the Soviet Union. Apparently, there would be approximately 5 people to stamp your visa. The excesses of socialism are never lost on me, because of this story.
- yarou 10y agoI'm sorry, I meant socialism is a great system where everyone is equal! In fact it's so equal, that I want you to have sex with my wife.
- dang 10y agoYou've posted many uncivil and/or unsubstantive comments to HN, and we've had to warn you about this more than once before. I actually just banned your account for this, but on reflection, decided to unban you since many of your comments are also the civil, substantive kind. The latter are the kind we want here. Would you please restrict yourself to those? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- yarou 10y agoSorry dang. I now realize that not everyone can appreciate my unique take on satire.
- 10y ago
- linkregister 10y agoI feel it's a cycle of mistrust. Companies don't want to spend as much time training junior workers or apprentices because they often leave shortly after achieving proficiency. But this lack of perceived loyalty comes from a rational viewpoint. After the shift in business culture in the 80s, where workers were laid off in bulk even if the company was in good financial health, workers woke up to the new reality. (To be fair, the era of the "company man" only encompasses half a century, so it's not necessarily a right or natural phenomenon) I remember in the 80s and early 90s it was common for a salaried worker to stay at the same company for decades. Since the 2000s, it appears to be less prevalent. The solution would appear to be to make conditions good and wages competitive for the newly-trained junior workers to improve retention. However, some industries risk their competitiveness with labor costs above a certain level. I wonder how much of the shortage is due to the intransigence of capital versus true limits for competitive pay. I suspect the former for almost all specialized positions experiencing shortfalls, such as pilots, machinists, CNC operators, and millwrights. For unskilled labor I suspect that the wages cannot climb much higher without harming profits or risking competition from overseas.
- WalterBright 10y agoI read in the newspaper that Boeing has a skills gap with their machinists. The skilled older ones are retiring, and the younger ones aren't experienced enough. There are few in the middle. What happened? When they had layoffs, the machinist union rules specified the ones with the least number of years of service got laid off first. This left Boeing with a very unbalanced workforce.
- madengr 10y agoYep, same with my aerospace employer. Massive layoffs in the early 90's, and the young ones were let go due to union seniority. Now there is a sharp bimodal age distribution from the mass hiring to replace the retirees.
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoSeems like unions benefit just the insiders and seniors. One reason why I am skeptical when people say unions built the middle class. Employer competition probably does more for that than unions.
- analog31 10y agoKnowledge transfer should be baked into the day-to-day culture of work, not something desperately scrambled for during someone's last week. Those few companies with meaningful training and mentoring programs know this. In my observation, it's very few companies. Also, I don't think it's as easy as just saying it should happen. For one thing, hiring has changed. A lot of tech workers from my generation tended to be fairly multi-disciplinary, but as a company matures, they tend to hire from standardized skill sets such as the mainstream branches of engineering. Case in point, I'm 52, and I was hired kinda by accident because I had a connection and was in the right place at the right time. Nobody ever asked for my skill set. My knowledge is based on having a pretty good understanding of optics, electronics, mechanics, math, computation, and so forth. But we haven't ever deliberately hired anybody like that, so there's nobody whom I can even transfer my knowledge to. My job involves solving a lot of really weird problems under pressure, such as when a production line goes down and nobody knows why. I kind of thrive on it, plus it's a niche that I was able to carve out, to make myself employable without a mainstream engineering degree. But I can't think of why somebody would even want to learn my job. The best thing to do with us old guys, is let us keep working, to do the stuff that you don't want to burden the bright young kids with. Here we go again with the "shortage of workers". In one article it's tech workers. Here it's GenX workers. A "shortage" of a good is pretty meaningless if you don't mention the price you're offering to pay for that good. Indeed. A labor shortage is the same as wage inflation. Show me the money.
- Spooky23 10y agoGreat point. I'm in my thirties, my boss when I started was a mainframe systems programmer for years. They had critical business process on an unsupported platform and this guy and a colleague wrote a pretty decent TCP/IP stack for it. They also were experts in some random business processes that were ridiculously important. They were jack of all trades. When I got there they had moved into monitoring and management and were reasonably capable NT and HPUX performance guys. Now there's literally a platoon of BAs, java programmers and others maintaining the successor system.
- analog31 10y ago
- yummyfajitas 10y agoWith so many people under-employed or out of work... The concept of "under-employed or out of work" is pretty meaningless if you don't mention the price you're willing to take for that work. Unless they're saying they literally can't find work at any price-That would be a real shortage. Otherwise, maybe you need to just accept a little less money to find work nowadays. The price argument works both ways.
- ryandrake 10y agoI actually agree with you to an extent. We need to start talking about this in terms of a market that can't efficiently set a price--not in terms of a "shortage of workers".
- maverick_iceman 10y agoWhat if that price is below minimum wage?
- cmdrfred 10y agoOr below the cost of living? Why bust your ass to live in your patents basement anyway?
- randomdata 10y agoPrice is the measure of where a buyer and seller agree. If sellers are rejecting bids because "Why bust your ass to live in your patents basement anyway?" then the price could never be that low.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoIt's obviously implicit that "for the amount of money we're willing to spend."
- cc439 10y ago>Unless they're saying they literally can't find qualified GenX workers at any price- That is actually the truth for many niche skilled labor positions. Manufacturing plants are starving for a lack of experienced E&I (electronics and instrumentation) technicians but they can't even attract the next generation despite offering ~$25/hr to apprentices. Being an E&I tech in a chemical plant is a dirty job but not in a back breaking way. Someone willing to take the apprenticeship will be making ~$35/hr plus as much overtime as they want since the shortage isn't likely to dry up anytime soon. The only logical reason why younger generations are refusing to consider these jobs is that they know what their ultimate income cap is going in to such a position. The next, and usually only, rung on the ladder is that of maintenance manager and there can only be one manager for their team of ~5+. Their proven skillsset is also less transferable to another role at another company like those of a typical office drone. Therefore, ~$75,000 without overtime is about all they can ever aspire to without channeling an entrepreneurial spirit that just isn't part of most people's psyche. That said, the career ladder of an office drone is nothing like what it used to be. Most of the people sacrificing that stable F~$75,000/yr as a skilled laborer will earn less over their lifetime as they'll eventually get stuck one rung under somebody who likes to kick down.
- monkmartinez 10y agoInteresting take. Most government positions are pretty flat as well, but come with decent incentive packages to make up for the perceived lower pay. For example; insurance, civil service rules, unions, pensions, stable working hours, etc. Now let's talk about railroads, utility companies, and other "blue collar" work that requires an apprenticeship. First of all, layoffs happen quite often and seniority determines who is laid off. Not horrible and expected in a wide range of professions, but my neighbor is laid off way more often than I would be comfortable with (Union Pacific). Such is the ebbs and tides of business. Then there is the rampant nepotism and other forms of preferential treatment to even get these jobs. To work for the Electric company, you had better know someone that is a respected IBEW member who will vouch for you. Same goes for the natural gas utility and just about all the people I know who work for utility companies in my city. I say all that to say, these are still dead-end jobs unless you are lucky enough to pass the subjective management tests. Like you said, there is an upper limit on the wages you can earn without overtime. That sucks because you are going to absolutely destroy your body working most of these jobs. Why settle for that? The outcome is predetermined... additionally the work may be boring as shit after 10 years or so, then what? If I had to do it all over again...
- ntumlin 10y agoCan you give some examples of companies that do have good training and mentoring programs in tech?
- Spooky23 10y agoThe new business model of efficiency at all costs means that hiring has been lean since the 90s. At my employer, that means that the good senior people are in their 50s and 60s and retiring away, being replaced by 20-30 somethings. The people in their 40s are left behind as they got stuck in the middle too long.
- vacri 10y ago> Here we go again with the "shortage of workers". In one article it's tech workers. Here it's GenX workers. A "shortage" of a good is pretty meaningless if you don't mention the price you're offering to pay for that good. Unless they're saying they literally can't find qualified GenX workers at any price--That would be a real shortage. Otherwise, maybe you need to just offer a little more money to find skilled mid-career workers nowadays. By that rationale, there's no food shortage in Venezuela. "There is food, people just need to offer more money for it."
- owengriffiths 10y agoActually yes. The food shortage is because the government is preventing people offering more money to bring the market into balance.
- tpp 10y agoTrue. Maybe the ones complaining are the companies that aren't as attractive to GenX as much as they were to baby boomers.
- jimwalsh 10y agoThere's a gap there because the firms didn't want to pay the GenX generation after they got trained. They hopped on to the next company and progressed their careers. Take better care of your employees, pay them their market value, factor in some work-life-balance, and they will stay.
- madengr 10y ago"A shortage of gen-x workers" is exactly the case at my facility. I'm 45, which is the valley in the bimodal age distribution. People are either in their 60's or 20's, and those two generations do not get along.
- driverdan 10y agoWhy is there a shortage? Are you underpaying people?
- dxg732f 10y agoMost of the really experienced people at companies I have worked for where surprised when I asked about what they did and why. They somehow assumed someone else was supposed to be training me. They were the only ones who knew answers to particular questions I had. They were shocked and sometimes didn't believe me that I asked everyone but them first. I don't blame these experienced workers for not sharing their knowledge, someone should have told them, though, that they are expected to do it, there are no systems in place at most places. Most companies seem to believe that knowledge transfer just happens magically,or should.
- user5994461 10y ago> Most companies seem to believe that knowledge transfer just happens magically,or should. Put more experienced with less experienced workers working together and it does happen magically.
- dxg732f 10y agoI think in my case it did, I did learn from the experienced workers but that was apparently not the norm there. I hope you are right that that is what happens most places.
- Clubber 10y agoI wonder how much of this has to do with the dot bomb in 2001. It washed a lot of my generation (GenX) out our technology.
- JoeDaDude 10y agoI've often thought that after a certain age, instead of getting some percent increase in salary, it would be preferable instead to work some percentage fewer days or hours. Seems like the idea is finally catching on. I hope I get to enjoy it when the time comes.
- greenhatman 10y agoThis makes a lot of sense. Or take some kind of consulting position, where you just advise and help the newer people grow into more senior positions.
- mooreds 10y agoI have always said that when I get to "X" income, I'd rather have more time than more money. Of course "X" changes over time, but I have definitely hit it before. This is what consulting/contracting lets you determine, but I hear you, it'd be nice to have the option coupled with the safety and job opportunities of employment.
- jwatte 10y agoIf salaries go up, shortages go down (both on silly and demand side)
- randomdata 10y agoShortage is defined as a situation where price cannot rise, such as the government setting a price ceiling. If price can rise then a shortage is impossible.
- cauterized 10y agoSo if right at this moment the world had only enough doctors to care for half the population, regardless of the price, that wouldn't be a shortage of doctors? If there were a severe drought and only enough food to keep half of us alive, but prices weren't capped... That wouldn't be a food shortage? If there are only 10,000 people in a field who are under the age of 70 but have at least 20 years of experience, and the industry needs 50,000 of them to function efficiently - that's not a shortage of experienced skilled workers? Not everything is a commodity. Not every commodity experiences a drop in demand as the price rises. Some things are needs that people continue to have demand for even if they can't afford them due to shortages. Even commodities have limits to their production. And some things can't be produced quickly enough to address a short or medium term shortage. Markets aren't magic. They have inefficiencies and externalities and logic limits. Econ 101 deals only in simplifications and spherical cows. And people with specific skill sets aren't spherical cows.
- randomdata 10y ago> So if right at this moment the world had only enough doctors to care for half the population, regardless of the price, that wouldn't be a shortage of doctors? Doctors may not be the best example. Where I live, at least, the government really does set a price ceiling for doctors, so a shortage is very much possible. Ignoring that, simply not being able to afford a doctor does not mean there is a shortage of them. That means you cannot afford a doctor. Which is a problem in its own right, but not a problem defined by shortage. Not all problems are shortage problems. > If there are only 10,000 people in a field who are under the age of 70 but have at least 20 years of experience, and the industry needs 50,000 of them to function efficiently - that's not a shortage of experienced skilled workers? No, because as price rises, that 50,000 number will decline. There is only so much money willing to be spent. At some price point, businesses will only be able to afford 10,000 people and the demand will be met exactly by the number of people available to work. Or if the job really requires 50,000 people absolutely, they will decide it no longer needs to be done, leaving the the need at 0 people. > Not every commodity experiences a drop in demand as the price rises. How can that be? Not everyone has the same resources available. Like the businesses above, as price rises, some can no longer afford the good or service. That takes them out of the market. Demand does not simply mean what you want to have. Price is always a component. Like that great earlier comment here about Porches, there isn't shortage of Porches because every poor man who admires the car can't afford one. They are simply not in the market for one in the first place, no matter how much they dream about owning one. > Markets aren't magic. Nobody said they were. The scenarios you point out, where price is able to rise, are something, but not shortages.
- oxide 10y agoRecently I've heard two different stories about this exact problem. Two specialized trades, two experts of their crafts about to retire, and two companies unsure how they'll replace them. I wish I remembered more details about the experts themselves, I believe one was a specialized glass worker.
- Inconel 10y agoOne of the people you might be thinking of is the glass blower who is retiring from Caltech. http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-caltech-glassblower-20160613-snap-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-caltech-glassbl...