10 ms·
I don't like the idea that the whole Internet is running on the servers of a single company. Can't we do something to increase the competition in the "cloud" ar
by adrianN 10y ago
I don't like the idea that the whole Internet is running on the servers of a single company. Can't we do something to increase the competition in the "cloud" area?
- jedmeyers 10y agoAzure and Google Cloud are kind of out there.
- DenisM 10y agoAmazon, Google, Microsoft at the top tier. Three is not too bad. The business is super capital-intensive: you need a lot of cash to pay the developers, and a lot of cash to build out infrastructure reaching both the economy of scale and geo distribution. Apple could you probably join in, if they put their minds to it.
- chinathrow 10y ago> Three is not too bad. The internet was ment to be a fully decentralized system. If you think that only three players are not so bad, then I'd ask you to reconsider.
- onion2k 10y agoThe internet was designed to be a fault-tolerant network that can automatically cope with outages by rerouting traffic around them. That's all. There's nothing to say who should own or operate the system implied in the design.
- gaius 10y agoEconomic failure is still "a fault" if it takes systems offline with it, that other people are using. Not all faults are purely technological ones.
- CalRobert 10y agoIt still drives me crazy that ISP's tell you not to run a server - the whole damn point of the internet is that it's two way. Opening port 80 and hosting a website on a raspberry pi that my buddy around the world could see may not be how the next unicorn operates, but it just feels good in principle.
- speeder 10y agoI am from Brazil, here ISPs do that because they aren't Cloudflare. For example many ISPs explicit write in their contracts that hosting ANY kind of IRC-related content, be it a server itself, or tools, clients, or articles about IRC, will get you banned from the ISP. I believe ISPs do that because IRC in Brazil is script-kiddie magnet, as soon some new IRC-related stuff is up, thousands (I am not kidding) of lamers will DDoS you, and some will try more serious hacks. Similarly in Brazil, hosting games is also frowned upon, usually game hosting companies are owned by major ISPs in first place, that rent their servers to people that want to create a game server, yet, hosting games is necessary too, Brazillians are so good at being assholes that they are frequently automatically banned from other countries (example: Combat Arms, irc server AfterNET, and a couple others have Brazil, or most of Brazillian IPs in their ban table.) Brazil also had the dubious distinction some years ago (I don't know if it still applies) as the leading country in producing "website defacers", so even your port 80 isn't safe. So at least here, sadly I can't complain of centralization, here it is very possible that if you put a website on your raspberri PI, it will take down the entire city internet down.
- grey-area 10y agoThe whole internet is not running in the cloud, even if lots of noise is made by cloud/serverless proponents, it's not the only way to host a website, or even the best in many cases. Many popular sites (like this one) still use their own servers.
- jlgaddis 10y agoNote that HN is behind CloudFlare.
- user5994461 10y agoEasy to say for a micro site that can run everything on a single server, and also get 90% of content cachable by CloudFlare.
- setq 10y agoIt's not. If any of the big three entirely disappeared there wouldn't be a tear shed. It'd be an inconvenience at most and people would suddenly be reminded about portability and lock in. At a microscopic level it's pretty stupid, dangerous and short sighted building your product to conform to any of these providers' services past the PaaS level. I see people with whole business on AWS who are a billing dispute away from weeks of downtime.
- erpellan 10y agoI presume every business who doesn't run all their services on their own servers inside their own building is also just a billing dispute away from downtime. And even then if you don't pay your bandwidth bill you'll still go dark.
- Retric 10y agoAt a minimum using two hosting providers creates redundancy in both location, networks, and billing disputes.
- setq 10y agoExactly. Also it reduces portability risk. Consider if you implement SQS and SES using their native APIs then Amazon shaft you, where do you go? The answer is rewriting everything as AMQP and basic SMTP services, which until you're done, you're down.
- tobltobs 10y agoNo, if you don't use AWS or GCloud specific services you usually can move your business from one bare metal provider to the next without problems.
- jedberg 10y agoOh boy. I take it you've never actually moved datacenters before? Last time I did it in 2007 it took weeks of planning, and the time before that in 1999 it was months of planning. You don't just get up and move. You still have a ton of data to worry about.
- csydas 10y agoTo be fair, smaller providers are incredibly numerous in virtually every country. For obvious money reasons, they can't compete on price and available spec against the big three, but support tends to be the money maker for smaller companies, as knowledgable and accessible support technicians is a pretty valuable selling point for these companies. The business I work for provides software/service for thousands of these providers, and I see them all over the place in Europe, Russia, China, and so on. Have not seen it as much in the US, but my support focus is mainly Europe, so it might just be I don't get to see it.
- angry-hacker 10y agoIndeed. In smaller countries there are numerous providers from shared to dedicated hosting and people are using them. The whole Amazon lock in is a thing of Silicon Valley and the largest companies.
- idlewords 10y agoAt a minimum, we need a viable cloud service that's not headquartered in the United States.
- tajen 10y agoIs OVH viable?
- razakel 10y ago>Is OVH viable? Yes. They're getting silly amounts of finance each year. Plus, the CTO/founder is opposed to Internet surveillance.
- user5994461 10y agoOf course. It's an older and more established company than AWS.
- openplatypus 10y agoservers.com
- pouetpouet 10y agoOVH competes well on price. Ikoula has great perf. Gandi also has some offers. Aruba cloud also.
- CalRobert 10y agoWell, there are projects like this - https://sandstorm.io/ https://sandstorm.io/ - which make it easier to host things on your own hardware (or on cloud providers, but still...)
- Zarath 10y agoThere are some blockchain applications attempting to tackle some of these problems. Check out Maidsafe, Storj, etc.
- fermigier 10y ago"I see a market for maybe 5 computers"... said no one ever. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_J._Watson#Famous_attribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_J._Watson#Famous_attrib...
- eva1984 10y agoGoogle is not running on AWS, and they are pretty much 40% of the whole internet.
- yoodenvranx 10y ago> Can't we do something to increase the competition in the "cloud" area Yes, we have to change our mindset back from "Let's put everything (apps and data) into the cloud" to "Let's only use the cloud as _one_ of many ways for data storage and data synching. Everything else is done locally and on private servers". This whole trend of web-apps is really bad for free software because it creates a dependency on 3rd party servers. Just imagine you could only use Emacs or Vim if you are connected to the internet... We have to get rid of the idea that the default form of software is supposed to be a webpage. Make software local again and therefore reduce the influence of large cloud providers.
- chillydawg 10y agoBut why? It's convenient for the end user and connectivity is only going to get better. Pining for the days of desktop apps for everything isnt going to get you very far.
- pjmlp 10y agoIt works on mobiles, factory and robot control systems, integration with external devices, and all use cases where HTML 5 is just a poor UI/UX.
- BoorishBears 10y agoA huge part of it is you can hire an HTML 5 developer to give you something with all the eye candy users have come to expect for much cheaper, and much less effort, than the native equivalent. Now we even have Electron so you can package your own version of Chrome and reuse your web devs. It's practically a self feeding cycle at this point, people aren't going to coding bootcamps for WPF/C#, they're going for HTML/CSS/Js, because people hire for that with much less fanfare. And people hire for that with less fanfare because HTML/CSS/Js is so ubiquitous. And with the shift to HTML/Js everywhere "who needs WPF but stuffy business types?" *Replace WPF and C# with GTK,Qt,C++,C, etc. as needed.
- 10y ago
- _andromeda_ 10y agoI'd bet AMZN will hit a trillion $ market cap. You could buy it now and make roughly 3 times your investment in 10yrs or less. They (Bezos & team) are so so impressive.
- zimbatm 10y agoPromote tools that are compatible across clouds. The biggest contender is Kubernetes right now because Google is behind it. Anyone who adopts it is in a better position to move off of Amazon. Google has a better infrastructure and pricing but lags behind in terms of capabilities so that's their strategy. The worst thing you could do is use Amazon Lambda. Pretty soon the platform will become the application. It ties all the Amazon product in a big ball of vendor lock-in.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]