5 ms·
It's pretty scary when a political party has taken a hostile stance to science because it conflicts with their ideology. If anybody hasn't heard of Lysenkoism,
by epistasis 10y ago
It's pretty scary when a political party has taken a hostile stance to science because it conflicts with their ideology. If anybody hasn't heard of Lysenkoism, it's definitely worth reading about:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism
- hash-set 10y agoYeah, Democrats never did that with say, gun control, for just one example! I see a lot of projection going on here. I guess I'm one of those awful "climate skeptics" but with the benefit of having worked on some of the research through a contract I had with the EPA. Like everything, climate change has plenty of truth to it, it's just that it has become such an echo chamber and worse, the Marxists would like to use it as an excuse for global domination--which isn't going to happen. Untie the science from the politics! I'm not sure that's truly possible, but that's what it will take. When half the people studying it are no longer lefties, maybe then we can have real science again.
- whybroke 10y ago>...the Marxists would like to use it as an excuse for global domination... Four post (and counting) on this same topic form the same guy. I wish there were a place where sane (let alone well informed) people could discuss serious issues related to science and not be hammered by screeching ideologues.
- fusiongyro 10y agoWhat sort of discussion are you interested in having that this guy is preventing?
- whybroke 10y agoExcessive comments trigger the 'controversial topic' penalty which drives it from the front page. A conversation requires informed participants. There are few participants on topics that aren't seen. Presumably there is a connection between being skilled and being too busy to look beyond the front page. Or being skilled and wanting to waste time sorting through conspiracy theories for meaty posts. It's almost trivial to suppress any information that annoys a group by starting a emotion driven fight over nonsense. Climate change denial is not an intellectually honest different interpretation that can be cleared up by pointing to yet more data. It is a world view that requires obfuscating data. On the most primative level, trolling will due for that.
- fusiongyro 10y agoOK... so what conversation were you hoping to have, that this guy is stopping you from having?
- whybroke 10y agoThe unstated premises of your one sentence rhetorical is that spam, trolling and elevated emotions do not degrade discourse. This is erroneous. I (if my personal case matters) was hoping to observe a conversation among well informed persons on a topic that I could learn from. Out of intellectual curiosity, the only reason I dawdle on this site. The instant the topic become controversial, that hope disappeared. Thus I expressed my displeasure at that. And instead I am now having a conversation about conversations with a single person in the least efficient way possible. QED the conversation has been damaged.
- fusiongyro 10y agoActually, my premise is that there's not much interesting to say about this story. And you haven't come up with anything interesting to say about the topic of "scientists copying US climate data." I contend that this is because there isn't much interesting to say about it, and you haven't done anything to refute that. The rest is just fruitless handwringing and getting yourself spun up. And this is why I was in favor of the political cleanse, and remain in favor of it.
- whybroke 10y agoWhat if, regardless of the likelihood of deletion, there were no harm in making backups and one obstacle was funding? Would not a post to a site frequented by members of the scientific community be beneficial? And is not the very belief that backups are necessary, founded or not, very interesting in itself? Particularly interesting to the scientific community, many members of which frequent this site? A community devoted to science and technology is going to end up completely vacuous if it forbids anything that might upset the new populist order. Certainly the most important topics will quickly disappear. For example, climate change and hacking by certain state actors are out are already out, both are clearly important and relevant.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> > It's pretty scary when a political party has taken a hostile stance to science because it conflicts with their ideology. > Democrats never did that with say, gun control, Correct; the anti-science position on that (to the extent of actually blocking science from being done for fear that it might contradict their policy preference) is taken by Republicans, much as is the case with climate science.
- dekhn 10y agoInterestingly, there has been a recent surge in studies of evolution form the Lysenko perspective in the field of epigenetics. It does appear there are some situations which are better explained by it than by darwinian evolution. That said it doesn't justify what the Soviets did.
- epistasis 10y agoAs somebody in the field, that is a gross mischaracterization of epigenetics. There are a few examples of adaptive epigenetic modifications, but they are interestinf curiosities, not the the main results of the research. And of course epigenetics fully embraces all of genetics.
- dekhn 10y agoMy PhD is in biophysics; I've worked with genomes for about 25 years. Are you saying this paper is wrong? http://biologydirect.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13062-016-0111-z http://biologydirect.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s130... because Eugene Koonin is a highly respected geneticist (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Koonin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Koonin) who is generally scrupulous. I hardly consider his conclusions "interesting curiosities", rather they appear to be fundamental biological processes. Also, most things people call interesting curiosities end up being important. For example, when I was a postdoc my advisor helped discover the importance of nonsense-mediated decay. In 1 year the field went from "lunatic fringe" to "OMG this is a major process".
- epistasis 10y agoThanks for linking to an actual paper. I think there's been some confusion on the term, as well as some disagreement on emphasis. I'd make a few distinctions: 1) my comments were on Lysenkoism, not Lamarckism. There is a world of difference, in terms of one being the political negation of genetics, and the other being a "competing" theory of genetics. There is essentially nothing about Lysenko's views of, say, agriculture, that have passed into epigenetics. I would agree that epigenetics of course explains some Lamarckian evolution observations. 2) Though epigenetics is the source of lamarckian evolution, for example in this sentence: >Going further into epigenetics (an important source of quasi-Lamarckian mode of evolution), The study of epigenetics only rarely gets into Lamarkian phenomenon. The modification of histones and DNA methylation, the meat of epigeneticsm, is largely studied as sources of differentiation and gene regulation. The inter-generational passage of information is a very small subset of the body of work. Just to make sure that I'm not biased by my primary field (cancer), I went to scholar.google.com and went through the first page of results on an "epigenetics" search. I would stand by assessment that Lamarkcian evolution is one of the curiosities explained by epigenetics, rather than being the focus of much research. 3) Inheritance of adaptive traits by the microbial immune system (at least that's how Crispr regions were described to me before Crispr/CAS9 captured the imagination of the world) are pretty cool. But there are all sorts of interesting adaptations like that; if we view cancer as a population of individual cells evolving to compete against normal somatic tissues, we see both epigenetic and genetic mechanisms of inheritance among cell generations. I would definitely agree that its a spectrum of evolutionary behavior, but of the examples that we commonly see in the world, the Lamarckian examples of evolution are a minority. 4) As far as going from "lunatic fringe" to "OMG this is cool" I had the same experience with Crispr/CAS9. An archael researcher had been going on about it in hushed terms about this process for probably 18 months, without me understanding the significance, but then all of a sudden everybody's like "genomic DNA modification just got easier!" 5) I consider epigenetics, and gene regulation in general, to be of the utmost importance in the study of biology. Given the choice between getting the DNA of an organism or the RNA, I'd take the RNA any day. Edit: I should add that I've had the Waddington landscape as a computer desktop background image for more than five years. https://www.google.com/search?q=waddington+landscape&safe=active&client=safari&rls=en&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi018-hifLQAhVDu7wKHQrHCasQ_AUICCgB&biw=1205&bih=1352 https://www.google.com/search?q=waddington+landscape&safe=ac...
- r_smart 10y agoLook up Jonathan Haidt's discussion on science denial and political ideology. It's not just for conservatives / Republicans. Everyone does it.
- epistasis 10y agoNever said it was, and In fact I encounter all sorts of science denial from the left. However these people have no sway over the party and the party leaders disagree. At this moment in time, the leadership of one party is actively hostile to the pursuit of truth, and they must be held accountable instead of it bein whitewashed with false equivalences.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Everyone does it. Like, say, acting out of internalized ethnic bias, everyone does it, but not everyone does it equally, and that everyone does it to some extent is no reason not to call out the KKK (or their anti-science analogs) as a particular problem.
- r_smart 10y agoAnything to get a reference to Hitler or the KKK in, eh?