6 ms·
At least they could have given a more up to date report on what they are doing. 7 years passed since 2009 and all we've seen is a couple of promo videos with sc
by visarga 10y ago
At least they could have given a more up to date report on what they are doing. 7 years passed since 2009 and all we've seen is a couple of promo videos with scant actual information. We have no idea how they compare to Tesla or other self driving car startups.
- mememachine 10y agosums up google products
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ucaetano 10y ago"how they compare to Tesla" Given that Tesla doesn't even have emergency braking and auto-steering, I'd guess they compare quite favorably...
- wmf 10y agoPresumably one would compare Google's fully autonomous prototype against Tesla's fully autonomous prototype, not what Tesla is shipping now.
- ucaetano 10y agoThen, per the article, Google had its first Level-5 fully-autonomous, no-backup-driver in public streets over a year ago.
- yessql 10y agoTesla will have 100,000 prototypes being trained in shadow mode for a billion miles per year across the globe within a year. Tesla will compare quite favorably
- ucaetano 10y agoThat's a prediction, not a comparison.
- yessql 10y agoThat's a super conservative prediction which has zero growth from current sales numbers in it. Tesla grows has historically grown at about 50% per year.
- ucaetano 10y agoNot talking about the number of cars sold, talking about that translating into self-driving capabilities. And in that sense, it is a very aggressive prediction, given that Google has had fully-autonomous, no-backup-driver, public-road-testing for over a year. So you can say that Tesla is at least 1-years behind. More like 4-5.
- yessql 10y agoTesla is definitely behind Google now, but I'm saying their trajectory is orders of magnitude better, because they are collecting real world training data much faster. Humans show the minimal set of sensors needed for driving, and Tesla have a superset of that being delivered to customers today, which is being used to train their model. They get a lifetime of real world driving experience on those sensors every day.
- ucaetano 10y agoYour prediction is only good as your assumptions: that Tesla can achieve human-like levels of intelligence in under 10 years. That is extremely aggressive. Getting data is the easy part of self-driving.
- Fricken 10y agoOne can scale up the first 99% of an autonomous driving os pretty fast just using pattern recognition, but the devil is in the edge cases. We haven't heard much from Google because they've been programming and validating all the unglamorous little problems that training data and a neural net can't solve alone. 4 way stops, passing motorcyclists and stuff like that, where old fashioned hand coded features are necessary to adress situations in which specific kinds of reasoning is necessary. Tesla has to solve all this boring stuff as well before they can offer comparable capabilities in an AV.
- ddoolin 10y agoTesla models equipped with Autopilot enhancements do in fact have some form of emergency braking (automatic emergency breaking) to avoid rear-end collisions and primitive auto-steer.
- ucaetano 10y agoYes, but they aren't sold anymore. And "autopilot" has been on the market for over a decade, it's OEM off-the-shelf equipment.
- CPLX 10y agoGiven that Google doesn't have a car you can buy I think the jury is still very much out on who is ahead and behind here.
- hellcow 10y agoTesla has lane-assist, adaptive cruise control and a few other goodies. Many auto manufacturers have those things. You still have to manually follow GPS directions. Google/Waymo is actually piloting a car from origin to destination without a steering wheel or pedals. That's a much more difficult challenge. Put another way, no blind person is going to sit behind the wheel of a Tesla and tell the car to take him/her to the supermarket. Google's car actually does this, on real roads, today... and that's amazing.
- mtgx 10y agoTesla already seems to have that, too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3DbrYx-SN4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3DbrYx-SN4 The issue is Google is doing it with (prohibitively) expensive hardware, so we don't know yet if Google's self-driving system works with cheaper Autopilot 2.0-level hardware that the other car makers are going to use as well.
- dgacmu 10y ago"The person in the driver's seat is just there for legal reasons" -- but note just how closely that person's hands are to the wheel, in an obvious state of readiness. That person is 100% ready to take over the car if it messes up. Tesla had the luxury of running test drives until they had a success. This is a different thing than putting a car on the road with no steering wheel and saying bon voyage. The first is a demonstration of a single successful instance (which is probably repeatable on average); the second is a much stronger demonstration of a > 99% success rate.
- londons_explore 10y agoGoogles car only does 25 mph. They might have made that video when they only have a 95% success rate, because in the 5% chance of collision it would be at low speed, with a very light vehicle, and very unlikely to cause a fatality. https://www.aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/2011PedestrianRiskVsSpeed.pdf https://www.aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/2011Pedest...
- 10y ago
- chiph 10y agoI have friends that live in one of the neighborhoods they're testing in, here in Austin (Mueller, if you're curious). And they've said the vehicles have been performing well, with no issues at intersections or dealing with pedestrians or cyclists. It's a new-urbanism style neighborhood, with the houses positioned close to the streets, with lots of on-street parking. I imagine it's a challenging environment for the car.
- fsckin 10y agoYep! Plenty of pedestrians with strollers/dogs/bikes/etc, vehicles stopping in moving lanes for pickups or dropoffs, a mixture of stop signs and traffic lights, one-ways, two lanes, four lanes, divided roads, and the cherry on top: a two lane roundabout, which endlessly baffles drivers here. I'm not sure there's a better spot in Austin to test autonomous cars. That said, they aren't perfect. 1. They wait just long enough at stop signs when it is their turn, which confuses other drivers. 2. They drive well under the limit, causing small jams at peak congestion.
- londons_explore 10y agoThey're limited to 25mph by law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_Electric_Vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_Electric_Vehicle
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoI live almost in the backyard of their facility in Silicon Valley. No issues here either, the vehicles are very well behaved. Of course, how much is that an indicator of their progress, I don't know.
- randomdata 10y agoThey provide monthly reports: https://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/reports/ https://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/reports/ (some more detailed than others)
- rory096 10y agoLooks like that page got killed in the Waymo switch. Archive.org is missing the PDFs, but it looks like they still work if you follow the archived links straight to the URL. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20161016050722/http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/reports/ https://web.archive.org/web/20161016050722/http://www.google... [1] http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/files/reports/report-0916.pdf http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/files/reports/report-09... EDIT: I think I triggered them all to be archived, links in [0] should work now.