4 ms·
What exactly is preventing someone from doing a big switch? Pure coordination problem? Are there a lot of academics who would be against moving over?
by lordnacho 10y ago
What exactly is preventing someone from doing a big switch? Pure coordination problem?
Are there a lot of academics who would be against moving over?
- ska 10y agoIt's a collective action problem. Some of most prolific publishers are early career academics who need to make tenure, and tenure committees are looking for easy metrics (like "impact factor"). Choosing to publish in a less prestigious journal because it is better behaved can have real negative consequences if you are in a minority.
- pdonis 10y ago> It's a collective action problem. Yes, and one that, while I agree it's not easily solvable by academia, should be easily solvable by governments, who fund practically all of the research that gets published in Elsevier's journals (and those of all the other major publishers). So my real question is not why academia hasn't solved this problem (some fields, such as math and physics, basically have, with arxiv.org), but why governments haven't.
- rcthompson 10y agoProbably because publishers like Elesvier lobby heavily against the government doing anything about it.
- grigjd3 10y agoEffectively, this is a safe move for tenured professors, but not a safe move for anyone else, which represents the vast majority of active publications these days.
- a3_nm 10y agoYeah, but sadly, many tenured academics are not making any such moves either... There is definitely a "pyramid scheme" problem where the need to publish in unethical venues survives because of the needs of non-tenured academics, but it's not the entire story. Add to this the fact that most reviews are probably performed by tenured academics, so if all of them refused to review for unethical venues, it would have a lot of impact. I don't think unethical venues would survive if only non-tenured researchers published there.
- grigjd3 10y ago"Pyramid Scheme" is a fairly apt phrase for academic careers. However, it's not true that reviews are mostly done by tenured faculty. I never ranked above post-doc and I reviewed several papers. I think the real reason for the incredible inertia in the academic world has more to do with the level of competition for jobs. When moving from one stage of your academic career to the next regularly puts you into competition with a couple hundred others for a single position, you look for every advantage. The practical effect of this is that one can easily spend a decade or two of life after college putting in 60-80 weeks as a standard. When you have to be that focused, it's hard to put energy and time into changing the system.
- advisedwang 10y agoThis essentially happend in the linguistics field. The Elsevier journal "Lingua" has been abandoned in favour of Glossa. However it took the Lingua editorial board resigning en masse to really make this happen. Even after this, Lingua is still going fairly strong. Completely dropping a journal requires some researchers to go against their own interest (publishing in a worse journal or not at all). https://www.wired.com/2015/11/editors-of-the-journal-lingua-protest-quit-in-battle-for-open-access/ https://www.wired.com/2015/11/editors-of-the-journal-lingua-...
- alkonaut 10y agoUniversities should just collaborate by banning their researchers from publishing to unserious journals and conferences. Problem solved and researchers no longer face a difficult dilemma. If universities (and on a higher level, governments funding universities) demanded that all research be publicly accessible, that would surely also hurt Elsevier et.al.
- the_duke 10y agoElsevier is a huge player and owns many important journals. It's still very important where you publish if you want to build a name for yourself...
- dkarapetyan 10y agoWhat does ownership entail other than archiving the content and providing access to it?
- rocqua 10y agoIt entails support and financial benefit. The point is not that Elsevier Journals are bad Journals. They aren't. However, Elsevier is a bad publisher, and publishing in these journals enables Elsevier. The author then continues to argue there is actually little personal cost in avoiding Elsevier journals.