20 ms·
Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max”
- daxorid 10y agoSimilar predictions of catastrophic global winter were made by Carl Sagan regarding the Gulf War oil fires. In what way is this model any better?
- finid 10y agoOil fires! Are you kidding? We actually sent them to fight those oil fires. Who will be fighting nuclear fires when nukes start flying?
- coldtea 10y agoIn the sense that this talks about a devastation 10000s of times worse than some oil fires.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoNot really. This talks about a devastation of: > A limited, regional nuclear war between India and Pakistan in which each side detonates 50 15 kt weapons could produce about 5 Tg of black carbon (BC). [1] That's 5 million metric tons. The footnote on the Wikipedia article [2] says the oil fires produced: > 16,000 metric tons of actual soot is produced from 220,000 metric tons of oil burned every day. They started doing this in January and they didn't finish putting out the fires until November, or almost 300 days. But let's use 200 days as a reasonable approximation, given that some of the fires were out earlier than that. Multiplying 16,000 by 200 gives 3.2 million metric tons of soot, so the nuclear war soot is about 1.5 times worse than the oil fire soot. Also, consider that humanity has actually performed some 520 atmospheric nuclear explosions (including 8 underwater) with a total yield of 545 Megaton [3]. And yet this 0.75 Megaton conflict is going to plunge the world into winter? I'm not buying it. [1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2013EF000205/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2013EF000205/full [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwaiti_oil_fires#cite_note-37 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwaiti_oil_fires#cite_note-37 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_weapons_tests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_weapons_tests
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ggreer 10y agoFor those who are curious: Here's Sagan's original prediction.[1] I'd also recommend reading the Gulf War section of wikipedia's article on nuclear winter.[2] Sagan later admitted he was wrong, but only because smoke from the oil fires didn't reach the stratosphere. 1. http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1991-01-23/news/1991023131_1_kuwait-saddam-hussein-sagan http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1991-01-23/news/1991023131_... 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter#Kuwait_wells_in_the_first_Gulf_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter#Kuwait_wells_in...
- stuff4ben 10y agoReading that I'm left thinking that perhaps nuclear war wouldn't be so bad, well except the billions dead and the radioactivity. But we don't have to worry about global warming and water scarcity so we have that going for us.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoCan we try to reproduce Nuclear Winter in case of runaway global warming? Seems that we do have the emergency brake here. Won't even take nuclear weapons - introducing soot into higher layers of atmosphere doesn't seem to hard. However, this will decrease carbon dioxide consumption by plants and might allow unsafe buildup in the atmosphere.
- eksemplar 10y agoProbably not a lot, but a fallout game set in a lush and/or winter landscape would be awesome.
- humanrebar 10y agoThere is a school of thought that suggests that if we've already hit the climate change tipping point, we should put more efforts at this sort of terraforming-type approach instead of playing the long game by slowly curbing emissions.
- arethuza 10y agoWe could call it "Operation Dark Storm"...
- doikor 10y agoHow do you make the soot stay in the higher layers? Soot partly is a problem now. It lands on the ice/snow and makes the ice melt much faster (due to being black/brown)
- im3w1l 10y agoHow much would reduced solar flux screw with plants? Could the natural ecosystems take it? Would our harvests shrink?
- wmeredith 10y agoSnowpiercer has a pretty, uh, critical take on going this route. (It's also highly factionalized, not hard sci-if by any means.)
- adrianN 10y ago
- jakozaur 10y agoTrue, volcanic eruptions in the past caused temporary much colder temperatures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer
- kerbalspacepro 10y agoAnd mass starvations, just from blocked sunlight and decreased crop yield due to sunlight decrease.
- grive 10y agoA somewhat less popular cultural reference could be The Road from McCarthy. Human scavengers roaming what's left, true, but mostly famished and trying to find food before anything else. Maybe this time is the time we will renew the fear of nuclear annihilation. With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence, and is already considering a common nuclear deterrence. Depending on its implementation, this could mean the end of the non-proliferation treaties. Time to watch Threads again.
- Pxtl 10y agoI'm often disappointed in Fantasy/SF settings that completely ignore the most critical question "what the hell do people eat"?. It's one of the most basic functions of life, but because we're blessed to be removed from the frustrating process of avoiding starvation, so many works just ignore the question altogether when discussing a "life is hard" setting.
- tannhauser23 10y agoI'm reading "Farnham's Freehold" by Robert Heinlein which is basically a thought experiment in how to build a pioneer-like society in a post-nuclear war world. It's not a great book, honestly, but it has a lot of material on building shelter and finding food.
- hguant 10y agoFarnham's Freehold was the book that made me lose a lot of respect for Heinlein. I started reading him as a 13-14 year old - books like "Have Space Suit, Will Travel", "Farmer in the Sky", and "Starman Jones" - and ate them up. I got older and my dad recommended "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" and "Starship Troopers"; I really liked reading him alongside Asimov, who did such a great job of going into __how__ people/societies would exist in the future; Heinlein was much better at going into the __why__. The ideas he put forward in "Starship Troopers" and "Stranger in a Strange Land" formed the basis for some of the best conversations I've had with friends. However. Farnham's Freehold was just ubermensch porn coupled with some really weird racism. He used more hackneyed "I can do everything" stereotypes than an Ayn Rand novel, which is something he was always guilty of but it really came to a head here. The multiculturalism and openness that was so explicitly prevalent in Starship Troopers, Stranger, and Harsh Mistress (the main character of Starship Troopers is a bisexual South American) vanishes, replaced with this weird fear of black people - "they seem nice, but they'll turn on you when they get the chance" is the message the Joe character imparts. Just a very weird book.
- grabcocque 10y agoMad Max is not a post nuclear world.
- mamadrood 10y agoThe first one no, but the other 3 are set after a nuclear holocaust.
- dozzie 10y agoWell, the first one assumed that almost all oil suddenly disappeared, there were no industrial grade methods of producing it from coal, and no alternative propulsion methods were available, all at the same time. Which is silly, if one thinks about it, but still good enough to establish a background story.
- VLM 10y agoSeneca Curve / Cliff is the concept that the higher the technology level, the more horizontal the growth curve and the more vertical the decline curve. The decline rate of frack'd well is pretty staggering. I'd have to look it up to be sure but I'm pretty sure we've passed the point where the majority of wells that have been frack'd are now no longer producing. Same story with horizontal drilling decades ago etc. If we're not at the technology level today where the decline rate could be extremely sharp, we're certainly working toward it via ever higher technology in that field.
- dozzie 10y agoAre you sure that we have no technology at all that would produce gasoline from heavier fractions of oil? I think we have, only they're not as cost efficient as simple distillation, which can rapidly change if lighter fractions become less available. As far as I know, we neither exploit nor track the deposits of heavier oil.
- astrodust 10y ago
- berntb 10y agoPlease explain to me -- how could 50 measly “Hiroshima-size nuclear weapons” (in TFA) have an effect multiple factors of ten worse than Krakatoa, with ca 200 MT...? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krakatoa#1883_eruption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krakatoa#1883_eruption Edit: Also, all the fire bombed cities in WW II should at least be in the neighborhood of a large fraction of 100 small nuclear devices. Then we have this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwaiti_oil_fires#Oil_fire_smoke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwaiti_oil_fires#Oil_fire_smo...
- 6d6b73 10y agoSomethings very fishy here.. The US alone detonated over 1000 nukes, yet nuclear winter is nowhere to be seen.. (thankfully)
- a2tech 10y agoIf you read carefully you'll see the article says its from the ensuing fires-not directly from the fallout of the weapons themselves.
- PeterisP 10y agoWW2 non-nuclear devastation was larger than 100 hiroshima sized bombs, with explicit firebombing burning so many cities to the ground - we have seen the effect of enormous fires, and it doesn't come close to what is described.
- Ygg2 10y agoI assume that if they go out in urban areas, they'll raise a lot more dust and cause fire that raise more dust. Also it's not 50, it's 100. 50 bombs for India and Pakistan each.
- imglorp 10y agoSo it seems nuclear winter occurs not from the bombs but from the smoke from all the fires they would cause. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter
- mrob 10y agoDoes the whole world really look like that in Fury Road? I haven't seen it, but in the original I don't recall any suggestion that it's global, or even that there was a nuclear war. It was just collapse of society in Australia, which is mostly desert or semi-arid climate.
- roel_v 10y agoThat was always one of the weird things in both the original and Fury Road to me: there are sort-of hints that there are lush (or at least non-desert) lands within a few days, or weeks at most, driving. Why do they spend all their time wasting fuel by driving around in small local circles?
- DanBC 10y agoThose lush lands might just be rumours, and people are trying to find them but just finding more desert. Or those lush lands are highly desirable, and thus heavily fortified.
- justinator 10y agoMainly, because that's where you go, if you're a bandit. The first movie showed a relatively normal city, bordered by a no-mans land. Max + family vacationed on the coast. The last scene, before Max drives out into the desert is basically in a forest. Max's job was to keep the bandits out of the relatively normal area of civilization. The third movie showed a paradise hidden from most people, cut off by a lifeless desert. It was only by using a plane that they were able to get to a former city with enough resources to build families, again. It sounds like there's islands of habitable land, and difficult if almost impossible distances between them. No one knows what's happening outside their sphere, except rumors.
- crooked-v 10y agoTrying to make all of the Mad Max timelines fit into a single-generation timeline is hard at best. Think about the kind of timescale needed for those War Boys to exist as an entire subculture, or for the Green Place to be populated and well-known before withering up and disappearing. The only way it makes sense to me is to consider it happening over generations - and yet in the first movie, the collapse of society is still only in progress.
- coldcode 10y agoI assume a worldwide nuclear war would be an extinction level event. Perhaps roaches will inherit the earth, but I doubt humans will.
- arethuza 10y agoI don't think that was ever really the case - there was a vast amount of over targeting where the same location would be hit tens or even hundreds of times (notably Moscow - apparently due for ~400 warheads in the worst days of the Cold War).
- dbg31415 10y agoI have to imagine the only way to really get nukes dropped on you, is to have nukes aimed at someone else... or have a large standing army. Or basically be a threat in some way. It's not like someone says, "I want to kill all the humans..." they presumably just want to destroy their enemies and threats to their safety. With that in mind, these nations are probably fucked... but that's only a fraction of nations. * List of states with nuclear weapons - Wikipedia || https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_with_nuclear_weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_with_nuclear_we... Russia has, generously, an 8k nuclear arsenal (but only about 2k of those are considered active). If they sent everything they had ever built at Texas, they'd still barely be able to drop one bomb per every 30 square miles... Assuming they were all Tsar Bombs... that might take out one state. * NUKEMAP by Alex Wellerstein || http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ I think there are a lot of rural places in the US that would be mostly safe from being directly targeted and potentially far enough away to also avoid fallout. And also... like all of Canada. Who's going to waste nukes on Canada? * US States: Area and Ranking - EnchantedLearning.com || http://www.enchantedlearning.com/usa/states/area.shtml http://www.enchantedlearning.com/usa/states/area.shtml And let's not forget these are all government contracts to build the nukes were awarded to constituents as kickbacks or were built by the lower bidder -- and many are very old at this point. I have to think the failure rate is more than 0; so unless they're doubling up likely there will still be places targeted and still left unscathed due to delivery or ordinance malfunction... or just human malfunction, "Golly Gee, Sarge, I meant to target New York, but I typed in New Braunfels instead because of the auto-complete." Just for fun: * Tom Lehrer - Who's Next - with intro - YouTube || https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRLON3ddZIw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRLON3ddZIw
- thinkloop 10y agoWater shortages is a weird topic. The article focuses on finite underground aquifers, but how much world water consumption depends on that (I actually would like to know)? From what I gather many (most?) cities have water "systems". Dirty water is flushed, evaporation and human processes clean it, then we drink it on the other end. It's a continuous renewable cycle. We are reusing the same molecules, not consuming a limited resources. In many cities, water is nearly unlimited. The system just has to be able to cycle enough for the pipes to be full at any given moment. Some places like California have too much demand, for the rate at which their water cycles, so they have to be careful. But places like NYC or Chicago have nearly unending supplies of sewage to process. The amount of water on earth today is the same as 4 billion years ago. It doesn't disappear, it just gets dirty. The water problem is actually an energy problem. There is more than enough water on earth for probably a trillion people. The problem is it's salty, and desalination is extremely energy intensive. If we figure out cheap renewables, or fusion, or just have to pay a greater percentage of our salaries for water, we're really not going to run out. I know tfa talks about nuclear holocaust but I wanted to discuss regular water issues/fears.
- maxerickson 10y agoUse of sewage for potable water is still pretty rare. New York City famously has tunnels up into the mountains for most of their water supply. One of them was featured in Die Hard III, where it was used (while under construction and dry) to smuggle dump trucks full of gold. Chicago draws water from Lake Michigan and discharges sewage into (artificial) headwaters of the Mississippi.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoFolks in upstate New York hate NYC for the water supply. Much of the economy of the "southern tier" region is crippled by the requirement to keep water quality pristine (NYC being one of few cities that doesn't significantly process incoming water), and to manage water flows (including that of the Delaware River itself) to optimize the reservoirs, at the expense of fisheries and stuff.
- JohnStrange 10y agoAs far as I know, the post-nuclear world is most accurately described in the 80s UK movie "Threads". It's the bleakest and most depressing movie I've ever seen, like a never ending nightmare. Don't watch it, unless you like being in a bad mood for days.
- jjgreen 10y agoSheffield was actually just like that in the early 80s (but with more hippies).
- tezza 10y agoNext he'll be saying the Zombies / Infected arent right in Walking Dead / 28 days. This is a work of fiction, no ?
- Symmetry 10y agoIf any of you want practical advice on how to rebuild after a nuclear (or other) apocalypse let me recommend The Knoweldge by Lewis Dartnell. It's interesting if you're just interested in the history and theory of technology, even. http://the-knowledge.org/en-gb/the-book/ http://the-knowledge.org/en-gb/the-book/
- Dowwie 10y agoWell thank goodness for this revelation. My addiction to water would have made me quite resentful of those who control it.
- ptaipale 10y agotl;dr: Sensationalist but unconvincing. This is because of statements like made here: >“But global warming would be over.” Why? “Because CO2 production would stop with the destruction of civilization.” Man-made climate change, and the drought conditions that come with it, would cease. I find this is just ignoring reality. CO2 content in atmosphere is the result of a balance in the world. It's a result of processes that bring more CO2 there, and process that remove it. There's plenty of CO2 production that happens without civilization. And almost all of CO2 removal is not the result of civilization. The balance is not quite solid, but it is there. The man-made climate change is about changing that balance (and the balance with some other gasses like methane). Annual man-made CO2 emissions are however only a small portion of the total CO2 currently in atmosphere, and of total CO2 removed. Even if civilization wouldn't make any CO2 emissions, the CO2 content of atmosphere would not go to zero. For CO2 levels in atmosphere, there is an annual fluctuation of about 3–9 ppm which is negatively correlated with the Northern Hemisphere's growing season. [1] Thus, a far more important factor in the CO2 balance of Earth after a nuclear winter would be how vegetation and seawater plankton survive. If large areas of forests were destroyed, and if seas would be poisoned, then the conversion of CO2 to oxygen and absorption of carbon to plankton would change drastically. The impact of that would be vastly larger than the CO2 output of any human industries. Climate change would not be over because of lack of civilizsation; climate change would be unpredictable because we wouldn't know what are all the things that blew up in the air and what impact they have. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmo...
- sqeaky 10y agoI think the bigger point is that in the face of nuclear annihilation CO2 doesn't matter. Just maybe the particles launched into th atmosphere, the radioactive fallout and the death of the human race are more important than CO2
- ptaipale 10y agoThe death of human race would mainly come via climate change. No nuclear war will directly kill all people, nor will radioactive fallout of even an extensive one. But if the climate would get really much colder, then the human race might be in danger. For the majority of existence of anatomically modern human being (50 000 years to 200 000 years, depending on definition) the world population has been less than 5 million people (the population of world 10 000 years ago). I think it is quite likely that a similar population could be maintained today, with today's technology, by building artificial environments, running on nuclear power and other modern technology. Think of Caves of Steel. Major powers surely have done some preparations towards that. It would be what was attributed to Stalin having called "statistics", of course [1], but it wouldn't be the extinction of the human race. [1] http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/21/death-statistic/ http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/21/death-statistic/
- finid 10y agoWhat worries me is that even today, there're nut jobs on our side (and I'm sure on the other side also) who believe that a nuclear war is winnable. During the very brief Russian-Georgian war, some folks under Bush (Bush disagreed with them) actually toyed with the idea of bombing Russia. And we're still baiting them in Syria.
- pmoriarty 10y agoYou might enjoy a movie called "Seven Days in May": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_days_in_may https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_days_in_may
- JoachimS 10y agoWhat is wrong with dressing up in old rubber tires, driving around in sand buggies with flame throwers?
- astrodust 10y agoThe EPA might want a word, which is presumably why they've got to go.
- mxfh 10y agoMaybe the only larger swaths of lands not carpet bombed with nuclear payloads are arid areas, devoid of any current human population. After the nuclear fallout these would be the only areas where sustained human life would be possible. Even a recovering climate wouldn't change much about that.
- mordant 10y agoI've been to Ground Zero at both Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and I've spent a lot of time in Nevada - and I'm just fine. People grossly, grossly overestimate the long-term effects of fallout. The main negative effects of nuclear warfare would be infrastructure destruction and the collapse of food/medicine distribution - fallout wouldn't even register. At the height of the Cold War, a full-on strategic exchange between the US and the USSR wouldn't have ended human civilization. Things would've been unpleasant in parts of North America and Eurasia for a time, but all these extreme scenarios that are sensationalized wouldn'tve come to pass. Look at Chernobyl - it's essentially a thriving wildlife reservation, now.
- mxfh 10y agoConcerning Chernobyl, maybe humans societies adopt a new threshold against thyroid type cancers, but it's still not considered safe for humans. Hiroshima is not the reference for later generation nuclear bombs, which were magnitudes above them by payload and blast energy and different in isotopes emissioned. Bikini Atoll is still uninhabited as it deemed unsafe even though the population was originally re-relocated. Problems might also arise from incomplete reactions which might happen with cheaper, less sophisticated bombs or intentionally with dirty bomb types meant for scorched earth tactics or to maximize economic impact due to radiation related sicknesses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikini_Atoll#Return_to_Bikini_Island https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikini_Atoll#Return_to_Bikini_...
- avar 10y agoYou grossly overestimate the relevance of your own experience to the discussion of modern nuclear weapons. Those explosions were all either airbursts, purposefully designed to avoid fallout, or very low yield weapons when compared to modern weaponry. All of which is of very little relevance to discussing modern nukes intended to cause fallout.
- lgleason 10y agowait, Mad Max is not a documentary ;) With a full scale nuclear exchange we would have a nuclear winter for a the first few years (when the radiation would be the highest). This is an interesting read that looks at actual US government procedures following and exchange. It's a bit dated, but was written during the height of the cold war. https://www.amazon.com/Day-After-World-War-III/dp/0670258806 https://www.amazon.com/Day-After-World-War-III/dp/0670258806
- fritzw 10y agoThe whole article and not one mention of radioactive fallout? The radioactivity from a thermonuclear bomb spreads through the regional atmosphere and remains in contaminated soil for centuries...
- ComputerGuru 10y ago> So why the clear, blue skies, George Miller? Perhaps the once smoke-filled air in Max’s world has already cleared. But Robock predicts that process would take around 30 years. Why, then, does Max still look so young? I think they accidentally a word. 30 years == young.
- bagacrap 10y agoMax was already an adult at the time of the apocalypse.
- ComputerGuru 10y agoThanks, I thought they meant the world of Mad Max.
- smitherfield 10y agoIt's worth noting that nuclear winter is just an educated guess about what would happen; we obviously don't have any data on how a large-scale nuclear exchange would affect the climate, and there may be other climatic effects that are harder to predict. I'm skeptical that we would see much effect from an exchange of 50 weapons; the year 1962 saw 178 detonations.[1] [1] https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/nucleartesttally https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/nucleartesttally
- reitoei 10y agoBig difference between dropping a nuke on a remote atoll in the middle of the pacific to a dropping one on a densely populated city.
- saiya-jin 10y agoin long term effect on the planet or overall human population, not much difference
- enraged_camel 10y agoYou also aren't considering the strength of the nukes. Back in 1962 nuclear bombs were relatively low-yield (especially those used in tests). Today, a single nuke can decimate the entire DC area. http://www.nucleardarkness.org/nuclear/highvslowyield/ http://www.nucleardarkness.org/nuclear/highvslowyield/
- mordant 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba The trend in nuclear weapons has been for lower yields over the last 45 years or so. The reason is that advances in CEP precision due to better guidance systems means than huge yields are no longer necessary in order to ensure destruction of the intended target(s). 'Nuclear winter' is a completely unsupported theory pushed by Carl Sagan and the Union of Confused Scientists. Recall that these same people pushed 'the coming Ice Age' in the 1970s, 'global warming' until even their jiggered data was so obviously wrong that they renamed it 'climate change', and also predicted 'nuclear winter' effects from the burning oilfields during the first Gulf War - which never materialized, of course.
- justinator 10y agoSo why the clear, blue skies, George Miller? Perhaps the once smoke-filled air in Max’s world has already cleared. I'm not sure which Fury Road the author saw, but there are many scenes where there is little daylight coming through, for a variety of environmental reasons.
- ChemicalWarfare 10y ago>> “Because CO2 production would stop with the destruction of civilization.” except CO2 produced by "civilization" is at around 3-4% of the total atmospheric CO2.
- ben_w 10y agoYou're off by a factor of ten. Preindustrial was ~280ppm, current is ~400ppm, so we're responsible for about 30% of the CO2 in the air right now.
- Lio 10y agoNo one seems to have mentioned When The Wind Blows. http://m.imdb.com/title/tt0090315/ http://m.imdb.com/title/tt0090315/ It's a gentle little film I saw as a kid. It left an impression. :(
- anigbrowl 10y agoI remember it well and share your gloomy response to it.
- ucaetano 10y agoDid they forget Mad Mx takes place in the Australian Outback? It currently isn't so different than the Mad Max version...
- philip142au 10y agoThis hasn't been thought through enough, with nuclear reactors not maintained by people they will melt-down and pour out lots of radiation on top of that produced by the bombs. A lot of life will be destroyed.
- dTal 10y agoIsn't Mad Max the film where paper is the most highly prized commodity, but everyone smokes cigarettes? It's easy to forget that the vast majority of popular speculative fiction is utter bollocks and could never happen. I wish we had more "plausible" sci-fi.