11 ms·
Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from Alphabet’s X
- pyrmont 10y agoTitle should be updated to clarify the spin out is from X, not Alphabet as a whole: (see correction at end of the OP) http://www.recode.net/2016/12/7/13875208/google-x-self-driving-spinout-alphabet http://www.recode.net/2016/12/7/13875208/google-x-self-drivi...
- dang 10y agoUpdated. Thanks!
- mikebay 10y agoThink to have a car, that Google is tracking all time (just for your own security) haha - What a "Orwellian" dream life we gonna have. Cannot wait google to go on medicine also. Then we all can use pills from google. But what will happend to your car, your medicine and your home, if you dare to be opinionated away from mainstream ? - what a nightmare!
- kuschku 10y agoThis is written very confrontational, but worth a discussion, so I vouched for it: Google has been known to lock users out of all their services if they are believed to have violated the ToS of even one service. Having self-driving cars from Google integrated into the same ecosystem could have serious repercussions for users, so is this wise? Do we need legal changes, or should Google just change their model for locking out users? Forcing companies to serve users isn't really an option either, but Taxis have to do that — how can we solve these issues in a realistic way?
- adrianN 10y agodon't leave all the research to private companies. fund public research, make results free, increase competition.
- kefka 10y agoWe do fund public research. It is then considered the "property" of the university, which is sold as IPR to the highest bidder to make money for the university. It is also summarily locked behind academic paywalls but there are some solutions to that (icanhazpdf , scihub). We just fail on everything else in that sentence: make results free, and increase competition. Things might change if those laws were revoked, turning public universities back to the public, and then funding them appropriately. 30% tax funding is not "funding"... Let the privates do what they want.
- dexterdog 10y agoIs there a truly private quality university? When I say private, I mean one that is not considered a non-profit and thus pays no taxes on the piles of money it rakes in.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Having self-driving cars from Google integrated into the same ecosystem could have serious repercussions for users, so is this wise? Do we need legal changes, or should Google just change their model for locking out users? Break them up, and force the patents to be openly available for a nominal fee (like the patent on the transistor once was). Refuse to license a self-driving car for street use if a centralized firm, rather than the car's owner, can decide how it's used.
- jayjay71 10y agoI'm curious what their first product will be and when it will be available. Chris Urmson stated the goal was to release a self-driving vehicle by 2020, after pushing it back from their original goal of 2017, and this was just before he left at the beginning of the year. Since then Google also lost its lead software engineer on the project who left to start a competing company and he also took another senior employee with him, and Google lost several more key members to Otto (which is now owned by Uber). This space has become super competitive and it will be fun to watch what happens. I still think it will be many years before we see a fully self-driving car (where no driver is needed at all). I think the best way to do it is to redesign cities to specifically accommodate self-driving cars. Honestly though that might be something other countries such as China and Singapore are much more reticent to pursue.
- drcross 10y ago>I think the best way to do it is to redesign cities to specifically accommodate self-driving cars That will never happen. The car has to drive itself on existing infrastructure or not at all.
- paulsutter 10y agoWhere "never" means "early in the transition?" Once self driving cars are widespread, changes are certain even if gradual. Gradual examples include increasing density by replacing parking lots with buildings, relaxing zoning requirements for parking with new residential units, etc
- kuschku 10y agoWhere would you park the self-driving cars then? Considering in most cases > 80% of cars are on the road at the same time during rush hours, you can't save much with self-driving cars — not more than with a well-working transit system already. So you'd need huge parking areas somewhere still. And the "increade density, reduce parking requirements" — if you do that, you can just improve transit, and get the same advantage. But that doesn't happen. People want to own a car, have it always available, and don't want to share. Self-Driving cars provide no advantage there.
- boltzmannbrain 10y agoCurious to see the this team's approach relative to the TBD Chris Urmson company... https://twitter.com/theAlexLavin/status/808230259078402048 https://twitter.com/theAlexLavin/status/808230259078402048
- MichaelMoser123 10y agois this a sign that they are preparing for GA ? What is known about the status of the project? (i asked this in a previous submission https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13130017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13130017 , asking again as the topic hit the front page) Maybe this is related to the new laws in Michigan that allow self driving cars - http://fortune.com/2016/12/09/michigan-self-driving-cars/ http://fortune.com/2016/12/09/michigan-self-driving-cars/ . Now they have a potential market - doesn't matter how large, they count on it that other states/countries will follow.
- jessriedel 10y agoGA?
- MichaelMoser123 10y agogeneral availability (released to the public); please excuse my parlance.
- rasz_pl 10y agoNo, it means they are killing the project.
- ghaff 10y agoIt's probably too early to make that sort of assumption. That said, I can easily see the day coming when Alphabet decides that 100% autonomy or bust is looking like a very long horizon play without any clear path to productization on Google's part. Which could lead it to either shut things down, redirect them to a more modest play, or figure out some partnership/licensing agreement (though the latter certainly hasn't been in its DNA to date).
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI have yet to hear Google has solved the main reason their Self-Driving Cars aren't practical: That every road they drive on must be precisely mapped ahead of time, at a much higher fidelity level than Google Maps/Street View is normally done nationwide. Tesla and other self-driving developers are working without the luxury of a worldwide mapping database, and while not perfect, their products more or less could work on any road, because they're based on input from the sensors. But Google cars are dependent on input from Google servers, which means, where that data is lacking, the cars can't drive. If they're looking to run some sort of business to start making money, I could maybe see like an Uber-like service across very small geographic areas they have mapped. But the narrow fence around the area you can practically drive with one makes it useless to sell as a consumer vehicle.
- chucknelson 10y agoSource? I thought Google's cars used many sensors as well and weren't just a "follow this high-fidelity map and hope it's correct!" technology.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoIn fact, Google has the most expensive set of sensors on any self-driving prototype out there, AFAIK. They spend about $150k per car on sensors. But almost all the technology they've shown is about detecting people, dogs, other obstacles, on a largely unchanging setting. As of late 2014[0], Google engineers admitted the mapping required for their cars to work wasn't feasible at a nationwide scale, and that if they didn't know to look for say, a stoplight, on their maps, they'd run right through it. (Looking for arbitrary red lights is probably a hard problem too.) That's two years ago, yes, but they've announced nothing, technologically, in this field in this time (please comment if you have an additional source relating to the mapping of the roadway for a Google car), despite tons of PR about the number of miles they've driven or what cities they were driving in, with the same technology they've already had. Also bear in mind, almost all of Google's senior talent in self-driving cars has left Google X. So if they were having trouble with this problem in 2014, their newer, less experienced people now, probably are having more difficulty in 2016. [0]http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2014/10/google_self_driving_car_it_may_never_actually_happen.html http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2014/10/...
- zitterbewegung 10y agoEveryone comments about full self driving cars to consumers. Automating trucks would be much more trans-formative than cars .
- ghaff 10y agoMaybe someday. Automation could be a significant safety win for the highway given tired drivers today and could increase utilization as well. But I strongly suspect that there are too many reasons to keep a human present and in the loop (at least relatively near-time) to dispense with drivers entirely. In addition, societal issues of unemployed drivers aside, are the economics of having human drivers really such an impediment to shipping goods economically today? At least in the US, rail is mostly used for long distance shipments which is effectively automated--to a first approximation.
- nojvek 10y agoI wouldn't call myself a truck driver but I drive enough on highways to feel the problem. Highway driving takes its toll on the driver. You're usually on a single lane, maintain distance from car before and follow speed limit. Just lane following and adaptive cruise control and make this journey a lot less tiring.
- ghaff 10y agoAbsolutely. A lot of people are fixated on the (IMO many decades out) "Johnny Cab" whereas there are potentially significant safety and driving comfort gains just from autonomy with, say, a 1 minute handoff time for limited access highway driving. And that seems much more achievable over the next decade or so. (And even the sort of features you can buy today in luxury cars are pretty nice from what I see.)
- faitswulff 10y agoAutomating trucks could also be simpler over long, boring stretches of highway than navigating complex city streets, lights, and cross-traffic, especially via brute-force - simply mapping the entire highway in high detail.
- kenoph 10y agoWhen I see news about self-driving cars I can't help but think about car DoS, ransomware and hijacking. Not that this doesn't apply to "normal" cars, but I suspect that "intelligent" cars will have Internet connection and, at some point in the near future, inter-vehicle communication in order to cooperate better. We already have a PoC smartlight worm.
- user5994461 10y agoPut a physical button to enable/disable the network connectivity. That will limit the damages. Add a hard firmware reset button as well.
- mille562 10y agoPlaying devils advocate: - If the hack/virus was already installed, a network shutoff won't help much. - If a car is 10 years old with 10 years of safety updates/patches, resetting to the original firmware might not be a viable solution. But there needs to be a failsafe way of knowing the running software has not been tampered with.
- jjawssd 10y ago> - If the hack/virus was already installed, a network shutoff won't help much. Master battery disconnect which auto locks all brakes > - If a car is 10 years old with 10 years of safety updates/patches, resetting to the original firmware might not be a viable solution. But there needs to be a failsafe way of knowing the running software has not been tampered with. Plug and play ROM modules?
- niels_olson 10y ago> Master battery disconnect which auto locks all brakes probably want to separate those. Kill the engine at 80 mph, you can coast to stop. If you lock the brakes at 80 mph, you immediately lose most of your control, and, since you killed the battery, you lost traction control and probably ABS. And you risk blowing the tires.
- elmar 10y agoSelf-Driving Cars Will Improve Our Cities. If They Don’t Ruin Them @rmchase https://backchannel.com/self-driving-cars-will-improve-our-cities-if-they-dont-ruin-them-2dc920345618 https://backchannel.com/self-driving-cars-will-improve-our-c...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]