5 ms·
I wonder how long till somebody either buys them out, or they die out. It is a shock to me and a shame. I've always appreciated game engines as a programmer kno
by giancarlostoro 10y ago
I wonder how long till somebody either buys them out, or they die out. It is a shock to me and a shame. I've always appreciated game engines as a programmer knowing full well the amount of work regular software takes, their engine still astounds me. I hope the best happens, it would be a huge shame to see those developers be lost. There has to be a company out there that would benefit from such engineers. Maybe Valve, Microsoft, Apple? Google even? I say big players because it would put them in a competitive area of the gaming industry. Just thinking aloud. I hope for the best for those employees, and I hope this is a lesson to us all that money should be managed wisely, regardless of if you're running a company or your own personal finances.
- spangry 10y agoThe specific skill set crytek game engine devs have is increasingly in demand, which will continue to grow. Specifically, the ability to write highly optimised code (mostly C++) to parallel process large amounts of data on GPUs. If I were running one of the machine learning divisions in MS, Google et. al. I would be combing through linked-in and firing up the headhunters right about now. The alternative is, of course, company acquisition. You're not really buying the IP in this case (although its a nice side bonus), you're 'buying' the dev talent in one big company-sized package.
- pitaj 10y agoI doubt those employees will have any issue finding work. Gaming is an expanding industry.
- golergka 10y agoGame engine building is not an expandibg specialization inside that industry though.
- Yuioup 10y agoThe technical skill and talent required for complex game engines should be more than enough for any job in programming.
- merb 10y agoI wouldn't say that. nearly 70%-90% of the market barly need that much knowledge to the hardware than a game engineer needs. The knowledge they need are extremly different from that of a game engine engineer. I mean CV gets to be a thing more and more where these people are probably useful, but that is not the biggest market (yet).
- syllogism 10y agoSome should be able to just move sideways into ML. Fundamentally, they know how to squeeze great performance out of a GPU. That's not something many developers know how to do. Probably only ~100 of those jobs across Europe at the moment, though.
- gaius 10y agoProbably only ~100 of those jobs across Europe at the moment, though Are you including finance, aerospace, etc, all the big floating-point users, in that total?
- merb 10y agoAerospace is not performance critical, at least not the overall industry. There are parts that are important, but a lot of them are not. I watched a talk where a company used clojure for diagnostics (board metrics and faults (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iUC7noGU1mQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iUC7noGU1mQ) for maintanenance).
- gaius 10y agoEveryone's playing the flops/W and flops/U game tho'
- golergka 10y agoActually, it could even be harmful. If an engineer has a habit of working on fundamental, slow-moving, hard-problem projects, I wouldn't hire him for a project with almost no hard engineering, but a lot of quick iteration and good knowledge of product space — i.e. almost any gameplay programming job, for example. It's just a completely different world.
- doctorpangloss 10y ago> Maybe Valve, Microsoft, Apple? Google even? I believe Amazon uses CryEngine for Lumberyard. Amazon must have given them a deal so bad that they end up bankrupt if the software isn't adopted. More cynically, it's a deal structured to ruin them and make them cheaper to acquire. I don't think that's the case though.
- duskwuff 10y agoThat is, assuming that anyone actually uses Lumberyard/GameLift. (Do they? Can anyone name a nontrivial game?)
- izym 10y agoNontrivial games take time to make.
- Lievelingsduif 10y agoWhile yes it takes a lot of time to make a game the indie scene isn't interested simply because of unity's dominance. The AAA scene is using their own engines or the unreal engine. While you can switch engines when creating a new game the incentive isn't there when you either already have licenses for the unreal engine and a small army of programmers who have mastered it. People were expecting a shit to Unreal when they decided to make it free for education/take a 5 % cut. This shift hasn't happened...
- duskwuff 10y agoFair point. Still, it's been nearly a year. Has anyone so much as announced a Lumberyard game, even?
- doctorpangloss 10y agoI believe the game Streamline, released November 18th, is built with Lumberyard and makes use of its Twitch integration. This game's studio had support from Amazon. https://steamdb.info/app/252850/graphs/ https://steamdb.info/app/252850/graphs/ The game was free until November 18th 9am PST, so the current active ~100 daily players is more representative of its success.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 10y agoPlenty of Microsoft execs/share holders who'd be glad to see the back of Xbox and games altogether.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Fr0styMatt88 10y agoWhy? Games are an insanely huge market and Xbox seems to have been amazing at keeping the Microsoft brand relevant in the consumer space.
- argonaut 10y agoGames are a huge market but it's also extremely competitive and difficult to build a lasting advantage over your competitors. It's all hits-driven, so in many respects competing is closer to running a Hollywood studio than a tech-driven or even sales-driven company. Contrast this to a group like Windows or Office where Microsoft knows they will be making billions of dollars off of it over the next 10 years, even if they also know it's in decline.
- ak217 10y ago[citation needed]
- ajeet_dhaliwal 10y agoIt was fairly well reported especially a couple of years ago but since Nadella looks like he's decided not to sell it it's quieted down now. One article among many: https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2014/5/6/5686380/bill-gates-comments-on-potential-microsoft-xbox-sale https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2014/5/6/5686380/bill-...
- ak217 10y agoCool, thanks for the citation. Didn't know that. I wonder why Microsoft isn't trying harder to make Xbox a home automation hub/Alexa competitor, or push it as a VR platform.
- unsigner 10y agoWhy would anyone buy them out? They've demonstrated time and again their inability to ship actual games. Their tech, once almost without peer, has long been matched and surpassed by Unreal and Unity. Their authoring tools are far behind. Their IPs (Crysis mainly) can sustain a 50-100 person studio maybe, but not the global empire they tried to build. Valuable employees have left over the years (see: the new Doom) and this wave of articles does not inspire confidence about the rest. The Yerli brothers should shut the whole thing down, keep the Crysis IP to themselves, hunker down for a few years, then try a nostalgia-driven Crysis reboot with a 20-person team on top of somebody else's tech.
- tormeh 10y agoTheir engine is still king. Unity is not even in the same league or market segment. Unreal is close, but I think they're still behind, at least graphically.
- optionalparens 10y agoFormer game engine dev and for a long while, proprietary engine programmer here.... Crytek focused too much on pretty graphics and not enough on anything else that is important to the larger experience of developing a game. Shiny graphics and cool fringe features are nice, but an engine is supposed to help you get a game done faster and without reinventing wheels. Building an engine to be the wheels for other people is hard. Most of the time you build an engine, you make it work well for a specific game or subset of games you make. It seems like everything in an engine should be and can be generic, but that's not really true. Once you try to make things super generic, you start to make tons of sacrifices either for the sake of makings things easier or at least repeatable. The issue is that as you move farther towards abstractions away from the original problems, you complicate everything and the end result is actually often less productivity (more steps, more hoops, etc), less performance, or even having to drop features altogether. Specialization is often looked at as something terrible in programming by some people (my code should be reusable!), but it really can make a huge difference in performance and features-specific contexts like games. There's also a difference as well between building an engine for yourself and selling one. If anything, I'd argue that Crytek may have done a pretty OK job for the former, but egregiously failed doing the latter. If you're selling an expensive game engine, you need to do at least some of the following: * Provide reasonably understandable source * Offer good support, especially in English * Stable, highly adaptable tooling * Wide support of popular formats * Clean, adaptable, fast asset pipeline * Community support and interaction * Cross-platform tooling/compilation options * Integration points for custom code, middleware, etc. * Ability to patch/fork the engine itself within reason when needed * Avoid huge amounts of allocations * Use fast or safe allocators or provide the ability to do so * Provide useful feedback during debugging, logging, tracing * Plug-in system/replaceable parts * Offer a scripting language and/or support for popular ones * Tools to prototype quickly if necessary * Create one or more games that is understandable to demonstrate features, but is still comprehensible * Support modern asset formats * Provide decent, predictable, hardware support * Ensure a stable experience I'll let the reader interpret which of those CryEngine does wrong. Some versions of CryEngine actually do some of these things well, but the problem is that relative to other options like Unreal, everyone I know has found it hard to justify buying or using CryEngine going forward. CryEngine in terms of raw features often looks attractive and awesome. Most people I've known including myself have had issues arise once you try to build something real with it. Quite often things just don't work how they should or are incredibly quirky. There's always tons of things promised that will be "fixed" or "redone" and never get done in a reasonable amount of time. Just look at the Star Citizen situation. Hiring former CryEngine devs really helped the project they say, and that's not just because those people are awesome developers, it is because they understand the crazy quirks that most people who didn't work with that code every day don't and in some cases never will. The game engine market isn't an easy one, but frankly they brought this on themselves.