4 ms·
Waiting to see when this crops up here, and how it'll fly considering Consumer Rights [0]. It falls into minor, so Google will have to: * free repair, (with a
by shakna 10y ago
Waiting to see when this crops up here, and how it'll fly considering Consumer Rights [0]. It falls into minor, so Google will have to:
* free repair, (with a repair notice describing the fault)
* replacement (must be the same condition as the purchase, so no second hand!)
* refund (the same amount you have already paid, provided in the same form as your original payment.)
And of course, the kicker:
> You are entitled to return a product if you believe that there is a problem.
And the business you purchased from has to foot the costs of said return.
All of these things are things Google has tried very hard to avoid, but they're selling the Pixel here, so they have to play by the consumer-oriented laws.
It'd be interesting.
[0] https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/consumer-rights-guarantees/repair-replace-refund https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/consumer-rights-guarantees...
- grennis 10y agoYou probably could mention where "here" is.
- cobookman 10y ago* replacement (must be the same condition as the purchase, so no second hand!) I believe apple & att will replace the broken phone with a manufacture refurbished device.
- shakna 10y agoUnder the Consumer Laws I mentioned, manufacturers have more leeway, but a business cannot require you to deal with the manufacturer. Apple is required, and does if you point out their obligations, to provide a new device if you purchased a new device. As phones are also guaranteed a "reasonable lifetime" of 5 years, this has led to replacing 4s with 5s and the like. However, as you mention ATT, you might be American, in which case, almost none of these guarantees applies to you.
- kefka 10y agoYep. That's "caveat emptor capitalism" at its finest.
- mannykannot 10y agoIf it is not already happening, can we expect more arbitration clauses in purchase agreements, or does the law already rule that out? (There will be different answers in different jurisdictions, I expect.)
- shakna 10y agoWithin Australia, Consumer Law overrules any and all conflicting arbitration clauses. For example, "extended warranties" you pay for are considered useless, and the ACCC recently did a public awareness campaign against them. Why? Products are guaranteed to last a "reasonable lifetime", where precedent determines reasonableness. Precedents I know: * "Dumb" phone, 10 years * Smartphone, 5 years * Fridge, 10 years * Car, 8 years * Laptop, 5 years * Tablet PC, 3 years
- karyon 10y agothat... sounds too good to be true. could you provide any references on what the actual consequences of this warranty are?
- shakna 10y agoThe guarantees can be seen here [0]. Personally, I've never needed to test it, as mentioning the Consumer Rights Commission is enough to make the worst of businesses suddenly become your best friend. However, a little research shows: The ACL will assist if the business refuses to honour the guarantee. [0] > "If we find that a retailer is not honouring the obligations imposed on the retailer under the consumer guarantee provisions of the Australia consumer law then the ACCC will take action to deal with those issues," Mr Samuel said. Optus, a sizeable telecom, got a decent fine for hiding stuff in fine print. > The ACCC has already been busy enforcing a prohibition on false, misleading or deceptive claims, with Optus recently agreeing to pay $178,200 in fines for potentially misleading consumers with some of its phone cap advertising. There's actually a TV show revolving around this stuff [1], so I'd say its relatively enforced. [0] http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-06-07/broken-but-out-of-warranty-you-still-have-rights/2749924 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-06-07/broken-but-out-of-warr... [1] http://www.abc.net.au/tv/thecheckout/ http://www.abc.net.au/tv/thecheckout/
- throwaway98764 10y agoIt's probably cheaper for Google to ignore the complaints and foot the lawsuit bill when/if it ever comes due. They have the cash, and it seems like the attitude of companies like Google is to "ask forgiveness, not permission."
- benologist 10y agoValve / Steam thought that, until their fraudulent refund policy had its day in court. Their TBD fine could be up to ~$900k US per person they stole from. http://www.pcgamer.com/valve-loses-australian-legal-battle-over-steam-refunds/ http://www.pcgamer.com/valve-loses-australian-legal-battle-o...
- mianos 10y agoGoogle does not sell the phone in Australia. You are buying it from Google Singapore and it is shipped from Hong Kong. It is charged in Australian dollars by an offshore credit card processor so you will also pay a non Autralian card processing fee. I did and ended up paying more than what they sell for in Australia. If you buy the phone from an Australian store or through the Australian carrier Telstra, yes you have consumer rights and very strong ones. If you bought it from the Australian Play Store, you have no rights except those in the country of origin. For shits and giggles have a try at getting them to tell you where you bought it from, it seems to be a question that is on script 'don't answer'.
- shakna 10y agoThe script may say not to answer, but contact the ACCC. You absolutely have consumer rights here, even if purchased overseas. They shipped it to you here in Australia, so are beholden to the rules. Valve, Yellow Pages and other overseas companies have been punished for ignoring those rules.