8 ms·
Let us not lose sight of this: the enforcement of the "right to be forgotten" is a form of censorship. This is not about enforcement of copyright, or defamatio
by lisper 10y ago
Let us not lose sight of this: the enforcement of the "right to be forgotten" is a form of censorship. This is not about enforcement of copyright, or defamation, it's about an individual's ability to censor true information simply because that information happens to be about them. And it can only be effective if enforced globally. If the EU succeeds in enforcing the RTBF globally it would set a catastrophic precedent for freedom of speech.
- mavdi 10y agoPractice your freedom of speech outside my personal life.
- grzm 10y agoCan you expand on this? What I have in mind is where to draw the line between your personal life and your interactions with others. Posts on public forums (including HN)? Your Facebook page? Your github repos? Someone else writing a blog post about an experience they shared with you? I sympathize with some of the intent. It's increasingly difficult to have a private life. I just am wondering how practical it is. I know the Right to Be Forgotten doesn't necessarily include all of these, but I can imagine it be expanded in a way that's doesn't seem to be much of a "slippery slope".
- wav-part 10y agoHow about any personal information illegally obtained (the act already a crime most likely) be defined illegal unless already available legally. However there is still a question of, If a content be blocked globally if its illegal in some country. No IMHO.
- grzm 10y agoany personal information illegally obtained You're right, that should be removed. As you say, it's already a crime, so that wouldn't need any additional support by the RTBF.
- suby 10y agoI think I disagree. By that logic we would also be deleting information like that gained from the Snowden leaks
- grzm 10y agoDamnit. Why can't this be simple? Is this type of thing really personal information, though? Would it be something covered by RTBF?
- wav-part 10y ago> Is this type of thing really personal information, though? Its not. So the rule still works.
- DiabloD3 10y agoIt actually is simple. Covering up an illegal act using state-granted powers is illegal. Someone "breaking the law" to tell people you committed illegal acts is not illegal in any meaningful sense.
- patcon 10y agoWith all due respect, I think the position OP's advocating is that people need to start defending the right to have what you're calling a "personal life". Our lives are no longer personal, at least in the sense of information ownership, which is what we're talking about. The term's continued usage is a polite lie involving curtains and a cheerful aversion of thought. RTBF is reactive policy-making at it's worst. Resources are finite. Make those companies spend resources doing something useful for our rights.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoExcept it's not. The data is gone from the google index but you can still find it.
- lisper 10y agoBut the data in Google's index is still information, and forcibly suppressing it is still censorship.
- edblarney 10y ago" and forcibly suppressing it is still censorship." No, not by any reasonable definition of the term. Whether it's 'censorship' or not, absolutely depends on what kind of information is in question.
- biocomputation 10y agoYes, forcible suppression by a state actor is definitely censorship, but not all censorship is bad. I am generally in two minds about this because there are convincing arguments for both sides. In the US, some people have a terrible time getting a job because of a criminal conviction. Yes, they did something wrong, maybe even terrible, but does society benefit from keeping these people from obtaining gainful employment? If society does benefit, for how many years should the individual wear the scarlet letter? At present a criminal conviction in the US is a life sentence for a lot of people. What if the government passed a law that expunged their criminal records after 7 years, but did so for the greater good of society? The French people think that the scarlet letter is bad for their society.
- lisper 10y ago> not all censorship is bad I don't dispute that. I'm just saying that France should not be allowed to censor beyond their own borders.
- andrewflnr 10y agoHow long do you think it will take for RTBF advocates to figure this out and demand it be taken down at the source, too? Probably about as long as it takes for people to start working around search engines. At least then no one will be able to claim it's not censorship.
- danieldk 10y agoLet us not lose sight of this: the enforcement of the "right to be forgotten" is a form of censorship. Censorship is not the suppression of any information, it's the suppression of some types of information by some types of actors [1]. If someone gets dox'ed and their private address gets exposed to the internet, asking for the information to be removed is not censorship, but protecting private information. Having revenge porn removed is also not a form of censorship, but protection of the individual. It is very important that privacy is protected, especially because spreading (mis)information can destroy someone's life. Of course, the right to be forgotten can be misused. That's why it should be carefully encoded in law under which circumstances the right can be applied. [1] https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/censorship https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/censorship
- lisper 10y ago> it's the suppression of some types of information by some types of actors Yes, that's why I specifically cited copyright and defamation of examples of suppression of information that are not censorship. But forced redactions under TRTBF are clearly censorship.
- dmvaldman 10y agoHow free would your speech be if it was recorded for posterity with no way of controlling it? Just something else to think about.
- lisper 10y agoIf I want to control the distribution of my own speech I can do that now by asserting copyright.
- pessimizer 10y agoThe enforcement of copyright is a form of censorship.
- lisper 10y agoNo, censorship is the suppression of information based on content, not ownership.
- biocomputation 10y agoMany people believe that censorship applies only to speech limited by a state actor. Ex: the first amendment of the US Constitution means that the US government cannot repress your speech. It does not prevent others from doing so. Many other agents engage in repression of speech: we repress ourselves, so do parents, friends, communities, lawyers, contracts. We don't automatically regard repression of speech/expression as a bad thing, and in many cases we are glad for it.
- edblarney 10y ago"If I want to control the distribution of my own speech I can do that now by asserting copyright." No, you can't. If you say something in public, and someone records with an iPhone and puts in on YouTube - you have no legal recourse on that matter.
- codethief 10y agoInterestingly, in some (all?) European countries uploading the recording of your speech (or just you as a person) on YouTube would be a violation of your privacy rights, unless you're a person of public interest and gave that speech in public, i.e. in front of a crowd or something similar.
- olalonde 10y agoI'm not convinced it's against the spirit of it though. Freedom of speech is about the right to express thoughts without fear of government retaliation or censorship. The "right to be forgotten" is essentially about censoring one's own speech, which is quite different.
- biocomputation 10y agoGoogle defines itself as a global corporation and has stated many times that needs global access to talent, global access to markets, and global access to information. Yet a company that has benefited so much from globalization doesn't think that the French government should be able to enforce its laws globally. Stated simply, Google wants borders for everyone else and none for itself.
- lisper 10y agoNo, Google wants borders to mean something, and so do I. I don't think France should be able to impose its laws on me if I am neither a resident nor a citizen of France.
- biocomputation 10y ago>> and so do I So you believe in the concept of sovereignty. France's laws end at France's borders? Border should be strong, right? >> No, Google wants borders to mean something, and so do I. No, Google wants borders to mean something when it benefits them, such as in this case. They want borders to be meaningless when it benefits them, such as the ability to operate in almost every country in the world. These sorts of skirmishes will only increase in the connected world being promoted by corporations. Some people, including myself, would rather that it wasn't done quite so hastily.
- lisper 10y ago> They want borders to be meaningless when it benefits them, such as the ability to operate in almost every country in the world. Huh? That makes no sense at all. Of course they want to operate everywhere because that's how they make the most money. That doesn't mean that they don't respect national borders.
- Silhouette 10y agoThis is not about enforcement of copyright, or defamation, it's about an individual's ability to censor true information simply because that information happens to be about them. No, it isn't. In fact, the original CJEU ruling was quite clear that the right to be forgotten is not absolute and does have to be balanced against competing considerations like freedom of expression on a case by case basis. However, data protection laws in Europe are much stricter than in some places when it comes to things like incomplete or out of date information. A key detail in the right to be forgotten ruling is that it is not only the original source of such information that bears responsibility for it, but also search engines that make such information easier to find. The point is that while such technologies are useful for finding good information, they can also greatly magnify any damage caused by bad information. A search engine that links to a newspaper article describing how someone was accused of rape won't necessarily also link to the follow-up article describing how the key witness later admitted in court that they made the whole thing up and was found guilty of perjury themselves. And yet, a prospective employer or girlfriend or whoever else might have reason to look that person up by name won't know that and might reach entirely the wrong conclusion if they only saw the first article. More significantly in this hypothetical scenario, thanks to modern searching technologies, every prospective employer or girlfriend or whoever else might have reason to look that person up by name is likely to see the same article with the same missing follow-up, with potentially catastrophic consequences for the entirely innocent subject's life. That's an easy example that surely no-one is going to seriously argue against, because it's very clearly misrepresentative and the potential harm is obvious. Once you get into information that is factually correct but either no longer fairly represents an individual or is concealed for good reasons anyway, things tend to get more complicated. There are reasons that justice systems typically regard even most criminal convictions as spent after a certain period of time and no longer require disclosure beyond that point. There is a reason that courts sometimes order the identities of people involved in cases before them to be concealed. There are many other good reasons for confidentiality and privacy protections. In any of these situations, while whoever is disclosing the information in the first place may be the original cause of any resulting harm (and may be punished accordingly under the law), it remains the case that a search tool making the information much quicker and easier to find magnifies any resulting harm considerably.
- 10y ago
- edblarney 10y ago"The enforcement of the "right to be forgotten" is a form of censorship" This is a false representation of the issue. Your 'address' may very well be 'true' information - but people don't have the right to publish it. Your 'private notes stored at Google Docs' are 'true information' - does Google or anyone else have the right to make it public? No - we live in a new world, we need new rules, new laws - 'the right to be forgotten' in 99% of cases is completely benign and reasonable. 99% of the time entities may not want to 'forget' it's simply for economic reasons: they want the data to mine - that's it. This is 99% a 'consumer vs. massive company' issue - and far less an issue of 'right to access information'.
- wav-part 10y agoI think main concern against RTBF that its not well defined. It cannot cover every info associated with a person. Right to Privacy is more applicable and solves everything you want.
- pyrale 10y agoJust like any fresh law. Let the judge/regulation bodies polish it.
- lisper 10y ago> Your 'address' may very well be 'true' information - but people don't have the right to publish it. Of course they do. For anyone who has ever made a political contribution in the U.S., their address is public record. I have to pay the phone company extra to not publish my address and phone number. > Your 'private notes stored at Google Docs' are 'true information' - does Google or anyone else have the right to make it public? No, because I hold the copyright on my private notes. > 'the right to be forgotten' in 99% of cases is completely benign and reasonable. I'm actually not disputing that. What I am disputing is a country's right to enforce its laws outside its own borders.
- edblarney 10y ago"Of course they do. For anyone who has ever made a political contribution in the U.S., their address is public record." No, they don't. That is a specific case, wherein someone could arguably publish data, because it's public. It would be trivial to change that law - i.e. you cannot know the 'home address' of the contributor, or, you cannot publish it. In which case we're back to the normal scenario of 'your private info is not public info'. "No, because I hold the copyright on my private notes." FYI - you do not hold the 'copyright' on your Google notes - you have a 'user agreement' with Google, which is probably complex, and beyond the understanding of anyone who is not a lawyer, and may allow them to do all sorts of things. Bug you validate my case: as with 'google notes' - there's not reason that standard information could not be controlled in a similar manner. If you want to 'delete' your Google notes forever, you probably could, and Google would probably not keep a copy. They can do the same for other things.