3 ms·
Science writing, especially the hard core sciences, has a collection of terms that are used among practitioners and have very specific meanings that are well-un
by dekhn 10y ago
Science writing, especially the hard core sciences, has a collection of terms that are used among practitioners and have very specific meanings that are well-understood.
These usages convey fairly subtles signals about one's understanding of, and confidence in, a physical phenomenon.
This is typically only learned by people who write papers and have advisors who can guide them.
A really nice example of this which is also immediately readable is Watson and Crick's 1953 DNA structure paper.
http://www.nature.com/nature/dna50/watsoncrick.pdf http://www.nature.com/nature/dna50/watsoncrick.pdf
It's a classic understated style, with a small amount of boastful brilliance. The passive tone is a bit dated, but you can clearly see little was known about how DNA worked, and they were very careful not to make any strong claims without qualifiers.
- XorNot 10y agoAlso worth noting: they were entirely wrong about the suggested replication mechanism of DNA (it doesn't work like that in nature at all). But hence the words they couch that statement in.
- dekhn 10y agoI'm sorry, I'm not sure I understand. Their suggested replication mechanism was precisely correct. Please explain what you mean (btw I have a PhD in Biophysics, and my thesis was on the structure of DNA and RNA, you are free to use scientific language).
- XorNot 10y agoThe actual proposal they had for replication was that the helix can obviously self-replicate from single stranded by just having new nucleotides come in. The actual mechanism as you'd know bears barely a passing resemblance to that, since you've got the whole DNA replication complex assembly orchestrating it. So yes "suggests a replication mechanism" - but it doesn't remotely work as the suggestion would imply.
- dekhn 10y agoI think you're confused. Their description was precisely correct within the limitation of knowledge at the time. They certainly didn't imply that the mechanism was autonomously self-replicating (even though, thermodynamically speaking, that is correct). The replication complex is just an enzyme, it only speeds up things that are thermodynamically favored (replication can occur spontanteously because the dsDNA is lower energy, but it's rare because forming the phosphodiester bond requires a high activation barrier). I think for some reason you are expecting them to pull the full replication complex mechanism out of their hat in the '53 paper but none of that is really necessary. What they described is precisely the mechanism; the proteins are just decoration to make the process faster and more reliable.