3 ms·
> even if you were to just tickle them with a stick and steal 0.1% of their customers Just be careful with this line of thinking. This is the fallacy of "it's
by pc86 10y ago
> even if you were to just tickle them with a stick and steal 0.1% of their customers
Just be careful with this line of thinking. This is the fallacy of "it's a $2 trillion market, so if we get .001% of .001%...!"
- ksarmentrout 10y agoWhat makes this a fallacy? Because it's encouraging low expectations? I've heard this reasoning before and it's always seemed optimistic to me.
- anthony-james 10y agoThe fallacy is when people use the size of a market as support of why they should enter it, sort of like this: Founder: "We should enter X market! It has $1 Trillion worth of annual business." VC: "It must be heavily saturated, with mature, efficient companies. Why should we fund you?" And now is the fallacy - instead of replying with something like "we have better A, we do B differently and we're priced at C," they say "well we don't have to take over the entire market, we ONLY need .001% and we'll be billionaires!" And the fallacy, more specifically, is similar to an appeal to probability, because using such broad metrics aim to give the VC a false sense of confidence - that even if the founders aren't 100% successful, they only need to be .00001% successful for them to make a killing. But it still doesn't answer the original question: How does a founder go from 0% to .000001%. But when you're evaluating the marketplace, it's perfectly reasonable to say "I need x% of the market to break even, y% to earn a profit" and extrapolate from there. The idea itself isn't bad, it's when it's used improperly.
- Tarlen 10y agoValid point, to avoid this trap I did a modest amount of initial market research and realized a lot of people were having problems with my competitor's offerings and were actively looking for alternative solutions. I set out to test this as quickly as I could and just kept going at it when I verified they were willing to backup their frustrations with their creditcard.