6 ms·
Salto – UC Berkeley’s Agile Jumping Robot
- jstrieb 10y agoI question the benefit of any jumping robot that is designed for continuous hops if there is no evidence that it can land.
- sohkamyung 10y agoThat's targeted for future research. From the end of the article: "You've probably noticed that Salto doesn't have a lot of sensing on it right now, and its jumping skills are all open-loop. In order to orient itself, it uses a rotary inertial tail, but it's not (yet) able to adapt to different surfaces on its own. The next things that the researchers will be working on include investigating new modes of locomotion, and of course chaining together multiple jumps, perhaps with integrated sensing."
- lunaru 10y agoBut that's the more challenging (and thus more impressive) part of it. I haven't spent any time in researching "jumping" and I'm sure this jumping robot is impressive to those in the know, but as a layman, this is like a self-driving car minus the self part.
- asdfasdfa11112 10y agoEngineering is a discipline of taking a problem you cannot solve, breaking it into component problems that you figure out how to solve.
- DHaldane 10y agoConsider too the publication this research appeared in. Science Robotics is concerned with the scientific underpinnings of robotics, which in this case was the new ideas about how robots can jump. I could slap an off the shelf stereo SLAM system on the robot, but that's just solving an integration problem instead of doing the science.
- DHaldane 10y agoI'm honestly surprised about how much interest there has been in a landing controller. I always thought it was a bit less interesting than getting the robot bouncing around doing new things. I could see how being able to stop gracefully could be useful in some scenarios, but there are some other jumping tasks in the queue before I work on that.
- kriro 10y agoRather than working on the perfect landing I think a good enough landing would be sufficient (crash and get back into ready to jump posture). Mostly so that the scenario of back to back jumps can be tested (which would also be interesting for stress testing). I'd love to watch the wall jump over and over until the robot breaks/stops for example. Edit: I see something similar is mentioned in future research. Cool :)
- Animats 10y agoRather than working on the perfect landing I think a good enough landing would be sufficient (crash and get back into ready to jump posture). That's been done a few times. The first time was a mobile land mine developed at Sandia. It was a ball with a fuel-powered piston for jumping. After each jump, it used an interior weight to get itself positioned and aimed for the next jump. The plan was to drop a bunch of these from aircraft into enemy territory. When one of them detected a good target, like a convoy, all the mines nearby would converge on the target and blow it up.[1] There's also this small fence-jumping, tracked robot from 2009.[2] Landing is uncontrolled, but it can survive crash landings and run upside down, so that doesn't matter too much. [1] http://www.sandia.gov/LabNews/LN10-20-00/hop_story.html http://www.sandia.gov/LabNews/LN10-20-00/hop_story.html [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjANAebfs6Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjANAebfs6Q
- tgb 10y agoI'm honestly surprised that you're surprised - it's hard to judge what makes the problem difficult if you don't include landing. There's lots of ways to get something to 'jump' (like these toys [1]) that aren't too useful. This isn't meant to be a criticism of your work, but an explanation of the impression it made in me. If it had been presented as "here's a new approach to jumping with these advantages", I'd have been impressed. Billing it as "the most agile jumping robot ever" while not being able to land it is setting your audience up for disappointment. My touchstone for jumping robots is that Boston Dynamics robot that can jump onto a building, and then I saw yours needing safety nets to jump a meter - you just don't want to set me up for that comparison. On the other hand, your video did get me excited to see where you go in the next few years - I definitely do want to see chain jumps exectued, even in controlled evironments. [1] https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/2e/87/10/2e8710fe2ee3b60b262f9e4e66a4751d.jpg https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/2e/87/10/2e87...
- awqrre 10y agoYes, a robot that can jump on top of a building in 1 jump sounds more useful to me, something like this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6b4ZZQkcNEo&t=0m14s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6b4ZZQkcNEo&t=0m14s .
- elementalest 10y agoThis is a clever novel design and shows lots of potential. The next step would be attaining the ability to right itself and land on its foot. Some kind of machine learning (NN) would probably work well.
- wyager 10y ago> Some kind of machine learning (NN) would probably work well. This isn't exactly a constructive criticism, but that is essentially the most useless comment you could possibly make here. "This very general class of algorithms that I've heard about a lot would probably work here.". That is true! It's sort of like saying "Some kind of processor (Intel) would probably work well". It's completely incidental to the problem at hand, and most likely not worth saying. It's also just a bad suggestion, because you almost certainly don't need to resort to the "high-interest credit card of technical debt" for what is a control and kinematics problem. Even if there's not a nice closed-form solution, there are 100 other approaches that are more appropriate for this sort of thing than just jumping straight to a neural network. I'm not going to go into an explanation of control theory, but "use a neural network" is not the universal answer to every problem in engineering and computer science. /rant
- nathancahill 10y agoI think this is actually very constructive criticism and needs to be heard more on HN.
- vosper 10y agoFor anyone who doesn't get the quote, "high-interest credit card of technical debt" refers to a paper published by Google in 2014. PDF link: http://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//pubs/archive/43146.pdf http://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.co...
- nappy 10y agoPlease be kind to everyone :) I think there are better ways to state your criticism that don't read so harshly. And in being kind, I think people are more receptive to criticism and suggestions. It can seem pretty silly from a purely rational perspective, but we're all real human beings, trying to learn and understand things together.
- clamprecht 10y agoSalto means "I jump", or just "jump" in Spanish.
- jaclaz 10y agoIn Italian too, JFYI.
- serg_chernata 10y agoMore akin to backflip in Russian. :)
- DHaldane 10y agoHa. Neat.
- aresant 10y agoI love the nod to biomimicry in the video - inspiration from animal strategies and adaptations is an unfair advantage in robotics design.
- hugs 10y agoI realized this many years ago when I was working with underwater robotics. I learned that fish swim in a pattern that looks like a sine wave, and so I started to design robots to fit that pattern. Anyway, biomimicry is a fascinating field -- it's one of those things I wish I even knew existed before I had to pick a major in college.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DHaldane 10y agoHey it's my robot! I can field some questions if people are curious about anything in particular.
- antognini 10y agoAny relation to J.B.S. Haldane? I remember in one of my order of magnitude physics classes going through a problem to prove that all animals have a maximum jumping height of ~1 meter. J.B.S. Haldane made that observation in his paper On Being the Right Size: https://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html https://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html
- DHaldane 10y agoI do love that essay, but I'm no close relation of J.B.S.
- jayajay 10y agoUnleash a million of these on Mars, kind of like a scraper crawling websites for data.
- FeepingCreature 10y agoWhat happens if you take one, put it in a shock-absorbent coating (bubble wrap?) so it can take a bit of a fall, add a tiny low-res camera and hook it up to a neural network with the goal to maximize distance moved per second... then leave it alone in a room overnight? Or can it not get up on its own yet? [edit] If you add a thin piece of string to the top and connect it to the top of the room, I bet you can make a mechanism to set it upright when it falls over. Then it has all the time in the world to learn to land on its feet.
- grmarcil 10y agoSee Animats' answer [1] to a similar NN suggestion in this thread. There are some research groups trying robotic control with black box neural networks (pixels in, control commands out), afaik with limited success so far, particularly with this many degrees of freedom. Deep learning has yielded some really incredible results the last 5+ years, but those results have been concentrated in a few areas (computer vision, speech recognition, game decision, ...). So there is a tendency to think NNs can do anything, but really a) setting up a NN to work with a problem is non-trivial (architecture design, data collection, data labeling, feature selection) and b) very much an open research topic for many problems, ie not guaranteed to work at all. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13121158 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13121158
- kahrkunne 10y agoThis is the third time I've read this title and the third time I got the meaning of "agile" wrong... HN is doing things to my brain.
- M_Grey 10y agoVery cool little robot, and a great article.