8 ms·
I'd be interested in seeing a list of how each of these was achieved, not achieved, kinda achieved, or other (based on a major misconception?). For example, fo
by schoen 10y ago
I'd be interested in seeing a list of how each of these was achieved, not achieved, kinda achieved, or other (based on a major misconception?).
For example, for the first series:
Aerial navigation: achieved, but not as convenient and ubiquitous as suggested
City Improvements up to date: not achieved, although it's possible to move individual homes and buildings at great expense, and you can buy deliberately-portable ones for certain uses
Shopping made easy — moving sidewalks: achieved, but not as convenient and ubiquitous as suggested
Summer excursions to the North Pole: marginally achieved, but not regularly commercially available; also, the image's notion of "North Pole" seems to be "inhabited Arctic regions" which are not, in fact, the North Pole
Concert and Opera at Home: achieved (and how!)
No more Droughts. Rainmaking machines at work: not achieved (unreliable and expensive rainmaking technology doesn't prevent droughts)
Dispensing with Bridge and ferry: marginally achieved, but not convenient or popular for most purposes; http://hydrobikes.com/ http://hydrobikes.com/ is really awesome but still expensive and most people don't have somewhere to store one, and other waterwalking apparatus is generally in the same boat (if you'll pardon the pun)
New uses for Roentgen rays: achieved (!!), though not all forms are routinely available for civilian law enforcement use
Roofed cities, fine weather insured: not achieved
Submarine Excursions: achieved, but much less convenient and ubiquitous than suggested
Cruisers evading an enemy: not achieved, but see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DUKW https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DUKW (on a much smaller scale)
It would be neat to see this kind of analysis for all of the other sets they've collected.
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoIf I think of the scale of our buildings, combined with the protection of automobiles, I feel like we've sort of achieved roofed cities. You can drive your car from your garage to underground parking at your enormous Apple spaceship campus where you work, eat, and exercise under one roof. Then you can drive to the mall where you work, shop, and watch movies under one roof. Then you drive home. You're never exposed to the rain. Obviously this doesn't apply to most people but shopping malls is what got me thinking.
- jonnathanson 10y agoYes. I think it's fair to say that structural paradigms above and beyond the concepts of "roof" and "city" have emerged that have fundamentally changed the nature of this prediction. Perhaps unintentionally, this leads us towards a different model for making and assessing long-term technology predictions in the first place. Instead of making literal predictions based on form ("a roofed city"), we should make predictions based on function or goal ("effective shielding from inclement weather throughout the day"). Of course, even this framework doesn't protect us from the changing nature of needs and functions over time.
- inopinatus 10y agoWith the aid of a guidebook ("Cities without Ground", ISBN 1935935321) I have crossed central Hong Kong on foot, above street level, from rail station to mall to office and hotel and residential building and been under cover the whole distance. Similarly I've walked underground in Taipei and Tokyo for kilometers, surfacing entirely out of choice for a glimpse of sky, to remind myself this isn't Trantor after all. These are cities where it is a common experience to arrive at the airport, take the train into town, and never leave cover for the whole duration of a stay. It may not all the be same roof, but the permanently covered urban life is a reality today.
- BerislavLopac 10y ago+1 for comparing to Trantor rather than Coruscant
- OJFord 10y agoMontreal is sort-of partially-roofed by the ground. Designed to allow travel between shops, and perhaps home & work even in the event of heavy snowfall I believe. http://montrealvisitorsguide.com/the-underground-city-map/ http://montrealvisitorsguide.com/the-underground-city-map/
- schoen 10y agoThat's a good point. And it's really impressive how far you can walk without being exposed to the sky in central Boston or Singapore (or, I've heard, in Montréal). Or the MIT campus with its tunnels (you can walk from building 1 to E19 without going outside, which I will probably do when visiting in January to avoid the cold weather). https://whereis.mit.edu/ https://whereis.mit.edu/
- choonway 10y agoFor the droughts, in desert regions today desalination is a way to reliably produce water, not depending on mother nature. For the roofed cities, we have built airconditioned megamalls / underground shopping malls, so we do not have to be exposed.
- Animats 10y agoThe moving sidewalk shown, with parallel sections at different speeds, follows the design from the Paris Exhibition of 1900.[1] It seems to have worked well there, but nothing like it was ever built again. That moving sidewalk is not a belt; it's an endless train of flatcars with turntables between them. It's disappointing that someone hasn't built a glass-roofed city by now. Google was getting close in 2015, with their glass-roofed campus plan, but the city of Mountain View decided not to let them build it. Google admitted that the roof technology wasn't proven yet. The USSR built an armed cruiser that can move from the sea to land - the Zubr class hovercraft. Not for evading an enemy, for invading the land. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BjpCVQgKZsc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BjpCVQgKZsc [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJ0aqx6_5YE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJ0aqx6_5YE
- pricechild 10y agoI can just imagine Elijah Baley zipping around that boardwalk.
- Animats 10y agoYes, that's where Asimov and Heinlein ("The Roads Must Roll") got the idea.
- Retric 10y agoIrrigation has more or less removed drought as a major issue in the US. We build city's in deserts and grow crops practically independent of rainfall. This is currently based on unsustainable water useage patterns, but there is also little point to leaving water underground.
- GuiA 10y ago> Irrigation has more or less removed drought as a major issue in the US. Heard of California? :)
- Retric 10y agoAhh California, where they grow Alfalfa in the middle of a Drought for export. Sounds like things are just fine. PS: California's problem is not drought, it's poor water policy.
- jaza 10y agobut there is also little point to leaving water underground. Seriously? http://www.actforlibraries.org/importance-of-aquifers/ http://www.actforlibraries.org/importance-of-aquifers/
- adrianN 10y agoYour link doesn't seem to provide any evidence that leaving the water underground would be beneficial. Depleting aquifers is only bad because once it's dry we can't use it anymore. So as long as using it now is at least as good as using it later...
- SAI_Peregrinus 10y agoCity Improvements up to date: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_of_Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_of_Chicago Chicago got rearranged, with buildings raised up and some moved around in the 1850s-60s. The creator of that card may have been thinking of something similar becoming commonplace.
- mncharity 10y agoThere are a lot of fun predictions. Ggl "1900 OR 19th.century predictions". Though they're now much less accessible than before Google news archive died, and the past was paywalled.:/ I'd love to see a taxonomy of prediction failure. What were the underlying ideas, and how did they go wrong. Ideas limited/blocked/displaced/abandoned due to technological/economic/market/social issues missed because ..., or some such. One thing to note is just how poor the analysis of old predictions is. It requires both engineering and historical expertise to address "why did US buildings stop being connected by bridges?" or "on what are robot arms (still) bottlenecked?". My fuzzy recollection is Peter Norvig gave a 'you can't predict the future' talk which dissed Ladies Home Journal(?) for 'no more horses'. And there's a lot of "the future / new tech is unpredicatable/surprising" which doesn't get questioned with a "So you follow science research? No. The engineering literature? No. The industry press? No. What part of your being surprised by technological change strikes you as surprising? Well, people in my echo chamber didn't parrot anything about it!" Sigh.
- mncharity 10y agoAerial navigation: Maybe the failure mode was missing the floor on balloon size? If unobtainium balloons that size existed, then yes, Model T blimp. Outboard fishing blimp. Wind/weather becomes an airplane-sized issue. Perhaps they over-extrapolated from shrinking sizes (lighter construction, hotter air and hydrogen) to 'becomes boat-like'? City Improvements up to date: Hmm. Cities had a lot more open space. And to build a building, you put in a rail line to the site. Now moving even a small woodframe, requires taking down poles and avoiding bridges[1]. IC and steelframe made construction cheaper. But, http://www.searsarchives.com/homes/1908-1914.htm http://www.searsarchives.com/homes/1908-1914.htm . And current manufactured and modular homes. So it works for small buildings. The pictured block-size construction seems implausible for stress scaling. Economics didn't work for new large buildings? And no room to slide away old large buildings? Shopping made easy: Maintenance nightmare, especially outside. Boston subway escalators were biting a person every few days, before brushes were added a few years ago. Consolidation of small shops into department stores and then malls (which did/do have escalators, but no/few walkways even now). But small shops continued until 1950's in midtown Manhattan. With lots of elevated trains, thinking "and soon there will be something like it at ground level" doesn't seem implausible. But rail is a tech sweet spot. Why doesn't NYC 5th avenue now have an airport-like walkway? Lack of crowd backpressure from corners? So maybe the failure mode was to greatly underestimate cost, plus safety? [1] picture of a house being trucked: http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/historic-kirkland-house-picked-up-and-moved-down-the-street/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/historic-kirkland-h... Another http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2709261/Moving-house-Entire-historic-DC-apartment-block-hoisted-wheels-sent-road-make-way-new-development.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2709261/Moving-house...
- amelius 10y ago> Shopping made easy — moving sidewalks: achieved, but not as convenient and ubiquitous as suggested Internet shopping is way more convenient than using moving sidewalks :)