5 ms·
Penny-Arcade TV on chronic anxiety and antidepressants
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- quellhorst 17y agoIt appears that these guys are still depressed. Get out, get some sun and exercise. That will work much better than antidepressants. Citations: Exercise is an Effective Antidepressant http://mentalhealth.about.com/cs/mindandbody/a/exercisedep.htm http://mentalhealth.about.com/cs/mindandbody/a/exercisedep.h... Sunlight / Vitamin D and depression http://newfoundlandnews.blogspot.com/2008/01/sadness-seasonal-affective-disorder.html http://newfoundlandnews.blogspot.com/2008/01/sadness-seasona...
- pw0ncakes 17y agoDepression and anxiety are biological problems, at least to some extent, and people who have serious biological problems can't just "get out, get some sun and exercise". The drugs work for a lot of people, although it's essential to make lifestyle changes (exercise, sun, healthy diet) in addition to using them... but the people who are in the worst shape can't muster the energy to get out of depression until they start taking the drugs. Anti-depressants are pretty amazing-- far from a panacea, but pretty effective.
- swombat 17y agoOpen air and exercise can have effects pretty comparable to many pharmaceutical remedies, for a wide range of conditions - including conditions of the mind.
- chaosmachine 17y agoThe problem with depression is even if you know doing activity x will make it better, you're too depressed to do it.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoAlso, anxiety and depression are often comorbid, so a person who is depressed may come out of the depression but still have anxieties about doing the things necessary to recover. An extreme example of this is agoraphobia, where a person's anxiety reaches such an extent that he becomes unable to leave his house.
- cmp 17y agoSunshine is not the best disinfectant. Last summer I had my first panic attack. Saying that, I wonder how many people who say "I had a panic attack" have ever experienced a full on, face on the floor, depersonalizing / derealizing panic attack. It felt like I was losing my mind. $250,000 in debt, followed by the disillusion of an 8 year relationship, loss of a job, and a move across the country in a three month period. Chase that with years of outright poverty (earning less than $10,000 [net] over the course of two years.) 7 days of Xanax and the wounds inflicted by three years of prolonged anxiety began to heal. I probably would have killed myself if it weren't for the seven tiny pills that let me keep coding. My company launches in about two months. [not my real account]
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI'm sorry to hear about this. I have had real panic attacks, and they're pretty awful. The worst part was the month during which I thought it was a physical medical condition, and the absolutely rotten quality of treatment I got in many cases. One example was (during the worst attack I ever had) a 7-hour ER wait, including 6 hours locked up in the psych ER, without being told why this was happening. Once I was able to see a doctor (1 doctor on staff for the whole psych ER) he was able to explain what was happening and why, but even then, all he could prescribe was Buspar, which doesn't do anything for panic. My experience is that the attacks don't go away entirely, but they become rarer and much more manageable. The depersonalizing attacks that feel like bad drug trips don't happen anymore for me (and stopped happening once I got appropriate medicine) because once I get to a 4 or 5 (heart racing, painful muscle tension, inability to concentrate) on the panic scale I can get it under control, taking a benzo if necessary.
- cmp 17y agoPsych-ERs are some of the most dehumanizing places I've ever been, and given the start of social services in North Central Texas. shudder Unfortunately, without insurance, any prescription usually necessitates a trip. Luckily, I have my anxiety in check now that it has a name, but, I've seen too many discarded people laying on hospitals floors with sheets over their faces. My current girlfriend is a third year in med school, I've begged her to ask the other med students to be especially kind to the patients during their psych rotations.
- GeoffWozniak 17y agoThat kind of flippant response is part of the reason depression and other mental health problems are still widely misunderstood.
- quellhorst 17y agoCan you elaborate?
- chipsy 17y agoIt is true that Vitamin D plays a major role in regulation of various systems, and can help to stabilize mood. I take tons of the stuff myself. That doesn't mean you should barf a "Vit D good" information packet on every story about depression, though. Without taking the time to add context, it looks rude and dismissive.
- fringe128 17y agoI'm sure these things can help but they aren't cures for depression. I exercise every day and get a lot of sun but still deal with depression and anxiety. I think that more important than sun/exercise is being around other people. Americans put such a high value on privacy to the point of isolation. I believe that that isolation allows psychological problems to come to the surface when they would otherwise not. Part of that is loneliness, part is the built in need to conform to a group's social dynamic which includes not acting crazy. Your behavior has a strong influence on your psychological state, so acting normal and happy can help regulate your moods. Not to imply that this is a cure either. Including meds, these are all just treatments and they may work better for some than for others.
- quellhorst 17y agoThat is a great point. In my research I found that having friends that you share time with and eat with improves happiness. Also, having less stuff actually makes me happier too.
- Alex3917 17y ago"Also, having less stuff actually makes me happier too." I've noticed this too. In addition to increasing cognitive load, stuff also tends to accumulate emotional baggage over time. (E.g., when your towels remind you of your ex-gf or whatever.) Just going through the house and throwing stuff out every couple years is profoundly therapeutic.
- maqr 17y agoFrom their language, the seem surprisingly uneducated about drugs in general. Also, I think the efficacy of SSRIs is still quite questionable. I'd love for someone who really understands the statistics and medical scales to do the comparison and tell us their opinion about Lexapro vs Placebo for depression or anxiety disorders. Note that Lexapro is the drug they're advocating, which is an SSRI, but there are plenty of other anxiety drugs (like any benzo) which are clearly effective.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoThis may not be what you're looking for, but I can vouch for Lexapro on personal experience. I had a bout of crippling panic attacks in the spring of 2008. I lost my job because of this (I was a trader at a hedge fund). I had about 30 attacks in the first 3 months. It was obvious from the 3rd or 4th day on Lexapro that the drug was doing something: I had some mildly annoying but harmless side effects in the first week or two-- sweating, "the yawns", tiredness, and weird visuals when going to sleep. After about a week on the SSRI, I began to have a panic attack while in the park and something weird happened-- the attack just ended after 5 seconds, and I felt no worse than if I'd been startled by a loud sound. The attacks became milder and more manageable. Now I have about one per month-- unpleasant, but not something that'd make me unemployable-- but none at any level of severity approaching what I had before I started taking the drug. Some of this improvement is due to lifestyle changes and increasing skill at handling the problem, but a large fraction of the improvement is directly attributable to Lexapro.
- drinian 17y agoZoloft stopped panic attacks for me after a similar series of absolutely crippling panic attacks. It's about as close to normalcy as you can get on a psychiatric drug -- also an SSRI like Lexapro, Prozac, etc. Reaction to each SSRI varies by person and depending on genetic factors, oddly enough.
- Tichy 17y agoWasn't having panic attacks a normal and healthy reaction for traders in 2008? Just saying...
- Alex3917 17y agoSee also: Are Prozac And Other Psychiatric Drugs Causing The Astonishing Rise of Mental Illness in America http://www.alternet.org/health/146659/are_prozac_and_other_psychiatric_drugs_causing_the_astonishing_rise_of_mental_illness_in_america http://www.alternet.org/health/146659/are_prozac_and_other_p...
- pw0ncakes 17y agoIt sounds like the problem here has more to do with irresponsible diagnosis (which most of us would agree is a serious problem regarding mental illness) than the drugs themselves. If someone has a manic reaction to antidepressants, the response should not be to diagnose them as having bipolar disorder, and then treat them as if it were the case, because it's unlikely that the person in innately/biochemically bipolar. It's to try a different drug. I'm not bipolar, and I've had a manic (or, much more likely, hypomanic) reaction to a vitamin (when I stopped using it, I was fine, but had done a few really moronic things up to that point). It happens, and aggressive diagnosis is not the solution.
- jodrellblank 17y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1311484 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1311484
- jdietrich 17y agoI have one issue with the widespread use of psychiatric drugs. As laypeople, we readily recognise the social and cognitive basis of much of what is called mental illness. We clearly see that when our friends are overworked and in debt, they become anxious. We see people lose their job and become depressed. Anecdotally, I struggle to recall a single instance of anyone I know experiencing significant distress with no clear social or cognitive reason. As part of the medicalisation of our thoughts and emotions, we seem to have discarded the notion that we personally can change how we feel, by changing how we think and the way we live our lives. We have no model for how to think about our emotions in the broader context of our lives without involving someone with a certificate and a nice office. To me it seems absurd that much of the medical establishment would regard the unhappiness a recently bereaved person as a chemical imbalance or a symptom of illness, but there are no shortage of references to the use of anti-depressants to treat "bereavement related depression". I can't speak for anything beyond my own experience, but I have been diagnosed with a catalogue of mental illnesses by a variety of highly trained professionals. It turned out that my life was just really crappy and I needed to sort myself out. I felt hopeless because I really didn't have any reason to hope. I lacked energy because I had nothing to do. I felt nervous and restless because I was living in a shitty set of circumstances. A few significant but simple changes to my lifestyle and mindset suceeded where endless "treatment" failed. It occurs to me that it is possible that we are treating symptoms without addressing causes. We rarely treat physical pain with painkillers alone, but usually act to resolve the cause of the pain wherever possible. It seems illogical to me that someone can become depressed as a result of a specific event in their lives, be prescribed antidepressants and continue to take those drugs for many months or years, without anyone thinking to address the issue that precipitated the negative thoughts and feelings in the first place. I suggest that those advocating SSRIs as a cureall for anxiety and depression take a closer look at the recent metastudies into their efficacy. From the largest and most recent (JAMA. 2010;303:47-53): ""The magnitude of benefit of antidepressant medication compared with placebo ... may be minimal or nonexistent, on average, in patients with mild or moderate symptoms. For patients with very severe depression, the benefit of medications over placebo is substantial."" For all but the most severe depression, SSRIs are less effective than sunbathing or jogging. Given the quite substantial risk of side effects, especially amongst the young, I can't help but be dismayed at how widespread SSRI use is. Looking at the healthcare debate in the US, the elephant in the room is that USians consume vastly more medicine than anyone else in the world but see no real improvement in their health as a consequence. From my perspective as a cynical Brit, USians seem to have an almost mystical faith in the power of medicine and seem to have medicalised a dizzying array of things which most of the rest of the world does not consider disease. British dentistry is often the butt of jokes amongst USians and considered substandard, but in fact it is of a very high quality. The difference is that British dental standards are based on function rather than aesthetics. We tend to perceive American dentistry as being vain and neurotic, the maxillofacial equivalent of spinning rims. What we would consider artificially straight and white, many USians would consider the lower bound of normal. USians are literally bankrupting themselves on healthcare spending, but live shorter lives than Cubans, who spend 1/25th what USians do but lead healthier lifestyles. The United States has the world's highest rate of incapacity due to mental illness and the fastest growth in the rate of mental illness, despite prescribing more psychiatric medications than anywhere else in the world. I invite the reader to draw their own conclusions.
- katovatzschyn 17y agoI took anti-depressants (and similar) after a suicide attempt and put into ward. The emotion they took me to is not what I would say "anti-depressed." I was still depressed. There was still anxiety. There was still the hunger for suicide. What was done instead is a kind of "loss of caring." There would still be that crushing darkness, but it would not drive me so much. There would still be that crippling terror, never leaving, but it would not deter my actions so much. Every night my friend would call to me again, but his voice more quiet. Then come the side-effects. I would not recommend this life to one who can avoid it. This was my private hell and I would not return there willingly. It did not eliminate my despair. Just me more dull and numb to it. But maybe you are not like me.
- wizard_2 17y agoI want to take this opportunity to share the Icarus Project, I found it a very helpful place to discuss drugs (legal and not) mental illness and depression. Their tagline "Navigating the Space Between Brilliance and Madness". There was a time when I felt... mad, and I can't tell you how much talking to people who share in it helped. I also want to mention while on the topic of drugs that exercise another potent drug. Someone in a previous thread was downmodded (probably due to his tone) when they brought it up, and I just want to voice that while it's not a fix all solution, it can be used to help too. http://theicarusproject.net/ http://theicarusproject.net/