3 ms·
Fighting fake news would not increase the degree to which Facebook shapes what people see. It would just adjust the criteria. Facebook already exerts total cont
by snowwrestler 10y ago
Fighting fake news would not increase the degree to which Facebook shapes what people see. It would just adjust the criteria. Facebook already exerts total control over what its users see.
"Discretion" is not the right word, though, because Facebook is algorithmic. The problem is simply that the algorithm is optimizing for the wrong thing, which is causing harm.
It's like if you decided what to eat and drink solely by how sweet things taste. Each individual bite would be pleasurable. But the long-term health effects of eating nothing but sweets would be terrible.
Blocking is not the only answer BTW. Simple labeling would go a long way. The Onion would still be funny with a little "satire" tag.
- makomk 10y agoIt would just adjust the criteria from things Facebook thinks they'd want to see to things that powerful people think would tilt the users' political views in the right direction. That's a major change, and one that - by design - transfers a huge amount of power and control from individual Facebook users to the centralized approvers of permitted content.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThinking about politics first is a backward way to look at the world. We need to know the truth about facts. Only then can we make useful political decisions about those facts.
- wu-ikkyu 10y ago"The truth about facts" is extremely ambiguous. However, I'm sure the new Minitrue department at Facebook will solve this problem.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoHow does Facebook determine what facts are without politics? Facebook fact checking materials before displaying them is fundamentally political, if only because the decision of filtering strategy is a political choice.
- snowwrestler 10y agoA news story that the Pope endorsed Trump is fiction and should be labeled as such. That has political implications because everything does. But evaluating content based on those implications, rather than on the actual facts, is a categorical error. We label fiction and nonfiction in libraries, book stores, movies, magazines, etc--basically every other medium for accessing content. Why not Facebook too?
- ikeyany 10y agoHow do you define fiction? "The Pope endorses Trump" would be labeled as fiction. But what about "The Pope endorses [some of] Trump's views"? Or "The Pope is a bigger fan of Trump than you think"?
- jamespo 10y agoHow about start with the most blatant examples... like spam detection
- snowwrestler 10y agoFacebook is not even addressing the most blatant, obvious fake news. In fact, they do the opposite: they promote it to millions of people. Or more accurately, they permit their software to do so. And they claim they have no responsibility, even though they built the entire thing.
- orionblastar 10y agoFacebook does not want to lose revenue from advertisers that submit fake news articles. I saw the BS News extension it checks each link for citing known fake news sites in their article. It is not practical as I keep seeing new fake news sites popping up from nowhere. Just register a domain, install Wordpress, write some articles and then pay for advertising on Facebook. Fake news sites got Trump elected by saying false things like the Pope supports him. It is serious when people only use Facebook as their only news site and read and believe without checking the facts first. If I were to make a fake news site detector I'd have it search Snopes and Politifact and others to see if it has been already reported as false. Basically the way it ends up is a new way to censor the news using AI. Suppose instead of a black list of sites they use a white list of trusted sites? Then block any new sites until they can verify them as trusted?
- Daishiman 10y agoThat applies to everyone in life and you're already doing that by looking at an algorithmically curated feed. I'd much rather it at least tell me what's fake news so I don't waste my time.
- adamsea 10y agoFacebook itself is already a bunch of powerful people - the people who make the decisions about how content is served to users.It's already a centralized source of power. Facebook already exercises this power by deciding how to determine what users "want" to see, i.e., what Facebook thinks users want to see. I'm not sure how you could claim that individual Facebook users have much power at all. What they see is totally determined by the platform.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoFacebook doesn't show people things Facebook thinks they'd want to see. Facebook shows people things that Facebook thinks will get them to spend more time on Facebook. There's a very important distinction between the two.
- rinze 10y ago> The problem is simply that the algorithm is optimizing for the wrong thing, which is causing harm. It's optimizing for the right thing, if you are Facebook: it's giving you more and more content you feel comfortable with, so you spend more time on the site and they can sell more ad space.
- zappo2938 10y ago"Facebook already exerts total control over what its users see." That bothers me a little. I have a page and Facebook somehow decides who and when a post is shown to a user who liked the page. It seems that Facebook shows it to a small group of people over an hours time or so and then depending on whatever metrics and interactions are made to a wider group or not. I don't know if it is good or bad because some posts that do very well on Reddit and Hacker News do very poorly on Facebook while posts that do very well on Facebook can do very bad on Reddit and Hacker News.