7 ms·
I really wish that both Android and iOS had an option to outright prevent an app from doing anything in the background. No sensors, no location, no push notifi
by amluto 10y ago
I really wish that both Android and iOS had an option to outright prevent an app from doing anything in the background. No sensors, no location, no push notifications, no network access, no CPU time, URL protocols, no nothing. If I don't click the little app icon, the app shouldn't run, full stop.
- JankyTurtle 10y agoI'm pretty sure with most Android phones you can kill applications that are sent to the background immediately.
- 31reasons 10y agoNot even for messaging app?
- jacalata 10y agoAn option. Not a requirement for all apps.
- wlesieutre 10y agoI don't think they're suggesting a single toggle for the whole phone, just that it be a setting you can force for individual apps. You'd only do it to apps that have no business running in the background like Uber.
- kakarot 10y agoAndroid can do that if you enable developer tools. Not sure if it can be easily overridden by an app or not
- dgallagher 10y agoiOS gives you the option to disable Background App Refresh either for all apps, or for individual apps: Settings -> General -> Background App Refresh
- wheelerwj 10y agoso this will disable location and all other data for uber if its not in the foreground?
- foodstances 10y agoThat's a separate option. Settings -> Privacy -> Location Services -> Uber -> Never
- lm2s 10y agoI'm don't know why you were downvoted, background refresh has nothing to do with the location setting.
- IMcD23 10y agoPer Apple's developer docs, if background app refresh is off, the app can't process location updates in the background. This was mentioned elsewhere in this thread as well.
- wheelerwj 10y agothanks!
- DenisM 10y agoIf you kill an app on the iOS, it stays dead until you launch it again, iirc.
- omarforgotpwd 10y agoit stays dead until the system decides to reload it. It may decide to do this for various reasons such a entering a geofence, significant location update, or push notification. But turning off background app refresh should prevent all of these things from turning on your app I think. Also low power mode can also be used as a sort of incognito mode because it stops all background activity to preserve battery.
- bogomipz 10y ago>" It may decide to do this for various reasons such a entering a geofence..." Can you elaborate on this? Whats the connection with relaunching and a geofence?
- bschwindHN 10y agoI haven't worked with goefences, but I'm guessing you can tell the OS you're interested in receiving particular geofence events such as when a user enters one. So the OS will relaunch apps which subscribed to those events so they can act on it. Someone who has actually worked with geofences, please correct me if I'm wrong.
- ralfd 10y agoGeofencing notifies your app when its device enters or leaves geographical regions you set up. If the App is terminated iOS will relaunch it IF the user gave it "Always" authorization for sharing location.
- mahyarm 10y agoAnd you can turn all of those items off in the app's settings. It might be annoying although because it wont work as you want. It would be nice if apple added a general 'turn off all background activity' permission switch.
- StavrosK 10y agoYou can install Greenify to do exactly this. It helped me kill some pernicious apps that I needed once in a while but that would run all the time, killing my battery (I'm looking at you, Mi Fit). The only annoying and inexplicable thing is that some apps run their own background process for push notifications, rather than using GCM, so pushes stop coming in if you kill those.
- amluto 10y agoI think it's ridiculous that you need an app to approximately control other background apps. Denying background access to the phone should be the default. Anything else should need a permission popup IMO.
- benliong78 10y agoiOS gets close to what you want. Apps have to ask for specific permission for specific reasons (location, background download, etc), otherwise it just get killed after a few minutes. Security is always at odds with convenience. It's easy to require a pop up to ask for permission every time and have user getting so used to these pop ups that they just automatically tap "yes"
- StavrosK 10y agoI agree. Apps shouldn't be able to just run background processes willy-nilly, and I hate how that drains my battery for no good reason.
- a3_nm 10y ago> The only annoying and inexplicable thing is that some apps run their own background process for push notifications, rather than using GCM, so pushes stop coming in if you kill those. There are valid reasons for this, e.g., if you want your app to work on Android devices without the proprietary Google applications.
- bogomipz 10y agoI thought that Cyanogen had something like what you are describing. Can anyone confirm?
- lucb1e 10y agoConfirmed. See my previous comment.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI want effectively a phone that works like Sandstorm. :) If I want it to have a right outside itself, I'll grant it.
- joesb 10y agoiOS does that? You can set location permission for App with "Never/While Using/Always". You can disable Background App refresh for individual App. iOS App didn't even have ability to run in background in previous version.
- boulos 10y agoYou misunderstand. The App apparently can refuse to opt-in to the While Using option (Uber now only has Never/Always). This is ridiculous, and Apple's fault.
- berberous 10y agoI wish iOS forced all apps to offer "Always/While Using/Never" for location info. It's bullshit that Uber can refuse to offer the middle choice.
- uberq 10y agoA thousand times this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- paulddraper 10y agoSo...Uber has Always/Never functionality and you propose and change that makes the user choose Always/Never/Never?
- ap22213 10y agoWould be nice. But, then only the carriers and the platform owners get to track you. That's not really fair, either.
- babesh 10y agoYou can do that already with user exposed controls on iOS. Just force shut down the app.
- Too 10y agoIt's tricky to get the ux of this right. Say you don't want to give Firefox background access because it should only be active while you are actively browsing. Then that one time when you are about to download a 4GB iso, you start the download and minimize the app or even close the phone, when you get back the download was cancelled after just 2%. :( Not saying it can't be done, just that there are many corner cases that can easily "break the internet" for non tech users if not handled in a smart way.
- imh 10y agoI think that many of the corner cases (background downloads) are cornery enough to justify giving users the options. The UX is hard, totally, but it's worth it.
- lucb1e 10y agoI don't know which android distribution you're using but mine has that. Can recommend Cyanogenmod with privacy guard to everyone: it allows you to deny wake locks to applications. After doing this my battery chart is flat for 6 hours straight if I don't use my phone (I think that's the longest time I've tried). Telegram is the only application with wake lock permissions left. I once even tried denying my lock screen the permission, which was a mistake... Took a while to turn the device back on.
- amluto 10y agoI use CyanogenMod, and denying wake locks doesn't solve this problem. An application can register to receive any number of events that will wake it despite a lack of wake locks, like geofences, alarms, push notifications, waiting for another app to wake the device, etc. It's the same reason that denying the permission to automatically run on boot is basically useless from a privacy perspective -- the application will just automatically run when some other event happens.
- IMcD23 10y agoTurning off Background app refresh and removing the app from the recent apps list will accomplish this.
- gregman 10y agoTo prevent data from being used by the Uber app on Android I enabled data server mode, and from there denied the Uber app from having unrestricted data access (settings > apps > special access > unrestricted data access). This allows me to still use the Uber app and request a ride, and I'll receive texts once the car is near. Last week during Thanksgiving travel I received a advertisement from the Uber app (as a notification) when I arrived at the SFO airport, even though I did not use the app at all that day. That's when I decided it was time to take away the unrestricted data access. I do agree that it would be nice to have better privacy options for each app, but I thought I'd share this workaround for the time being.