3 ms·
If you want to say one is better, then you ought to at least define what being better means. "better" clearly does not mean the same thing to both of us. Linux
by ryao 10y ago
If you want to say one is better, then you ought to at least define what being better means. "better" clearly does not mean the same thing to both of us.
Linux does have plenty of nice things and plenty of nice work, but I am not going to dismiss everything being done elsewhere by declaring Linux to be "better". At best, I would say that it is ahead in some areas, behind in other areas and the same in many areas. As for what some of those "other areas" are, I recall Adrian Chadd implementing time division multiplexed atheros wifi support in FreeBSD that Linux does not have. Netflix also contributed a rather nice thing to FreeBSD that Linux did not have:
http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/it-wasnt-easy-but-netflix-will-soon-use-https-to-secure-video-streams/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/it-wasnt-easy-but-ne...
There are plenty of nice things in both platforms. Labelling one as "better" just doesn't do justice to either of them. It ignores opportunities for the "better" one to improve by denying that opportunities for improvement have been demonstrated to exist. It also denies the "lesser" one the acknowledgement of having done something worth while.
- dekhn 10y agothe BSD feature you mention was added to linux 6 months later. When I say something is "better", I mean "I've looked at the data, and integrated over a wide range of parameters". I'm still waiting to hear about a magical BSD feature that is better. That hasn't happened in about 10 years, hence my statement.
- ryao 10y agoI just linked one feature that by your own definition was better and you replied that Linux got it in 6 months, rather than "I did not realize FreeBSD does some great things in networking first". If you are as experienced in networking as you claim, you should stop waiting to hear about magical features that are better. Nothing will ever impress you as being magical. That is a downside of having experience. Maybe you would find talking to an actual expert on FreeBSD's network stack more interesting. I am not one and while I could list several other things I know, I am clearly is not doing it justice.